Cast Out by the Whitakers / Chapter 2: The Last Straw
Cast Out by the Whitakers

Cast Out by the Whitakers

Author: Rebecca Anderson


Chapter 2: The Last Straw

After I finished speaking, the whole family couldn’t hide their joy.

Even the cook, who’d always brought me extra biscuits, seemed to breathe easier. The air itself grew lighter as soon as I surrendered.

Caleb awkwardly scratched his head and said to Rachel, “I told you Lydia isn’t unreasonable.”

His voice was sheepish, his eyes flickering from Rachel to me and back. He still wanted to be everyone’s favorite.

Rachel snorted and said to me, “Though you come from merchant stock, you know your place. But I’m not kicking you out.”

She gave a little shrug, acting generous. She’d gotten everything she wanted and now pretended it was my idea.

“You’re choosing to leave on your own.”

She raised her eyebrows, daring me to object.

I smiled and nodded. “Of course.”

I kept my voice smooth, unwilling to let them see how much it hurt.

Then I got up and left.

I walked out with my head high, determined not to give them the satisfaction of seeing me cry.

My two maids, Grace and Ellie, were both furious.

I found them waiting for me outside my room. Grace was pacing, fists clenched. Ellie was twisting a friendship bracelet around her fingers, her eyes shiny with unshed tears.

Ellie was so angry she was nearly in tears.

She wiped her cheeks with the back of her hand, voice trembling. “You don’t deserve this, ma’am. Not after everything you’ve done.”

“What kind of people are these! Always talking about rules and manners, but I think they left theirs at the door!”

Ellie’s voice rose, echoing off the walls. I gave her a gentle hug, wishing I could promise things would get better.

“And Caleb—he’s nothing but an ungrateful jerk. He only got through college and landed his job because of you.”

She stomped her foot for emphasis. Even Grace looked impressed by Ellie’s nerve.

“Now that he’s made it to the judge’s family, he turns his back on the person who helped him!”

Ellie shook her head, cheeks flushed with righteous anger.

Grace was indignant. “Should we call Uncle Alan? He definitely wouldn’t stand for this.”

She sounded hopeful, clinging to the idea that someone would stand up for us. I almost smiled—Alan was always the hero in their eyes.

I shook my head. “He’s deployed up north right now. No need to bother him with this.”

I tried to sound practical, though my voice came out softer than I’d meant. I couldn’t drag Alan into this mess—not yet.

“Besides, he’s still part of the Whitaker family. How could he turn against his own mom and brothers for me, an outsider?”

It stung to say it out loud. After all these years, I was still the outsider.

Every promise felt like a trap now, every smile a setup. I kept my guard up, even with Grace and Ellie.

All the money and care I’d invested over the years—might as well have fed it to the dogs.

I chuckled bitterly. At least dogs give you wagging tails and sloppy kisses in return.

Even the stray mutt I used to feed scraps to out by the garage had more gratitude than this family.

Grace was unwilling to let it go. “Without you, the Whitaker estate wouldn’t be what it is today. Now they’re letting Rachel reap all the benefits. It’s just not right.”

She crossed her arms, jaw set. Grace had always been fiercely loyal—a rare gift in this house.

I smiled faintly. “What’s ours won’t be left behind—not a single cent. As for what Rachel gets, that’s her problem.”

I let the words hang, my smile just a little too sharp.

Grace’s eyes lit up, immediately understanding. “Yes, ma’am!”

She grinned, suddenly eager to help pack.

After my husband died, I could have left the Whitaker estate.

I remembered those sleepless nights, the whispers at church, people telling me I was too young to waste my life as a widow. But I stayed, and not just out of obligation.

Back then, Mrs. Whitaker was ill, Alan and Caleb were teenagers, and the two younger sisters were just kids.

I’d found Mrs. Whitaker in bed, feverish and frail, the kids scattered and scared. Someone had to hold the pieces together, and I was the only one left standing.

There was no one to manage the household.

The bills piled up, the roof leaked, and every holiday felt like a test. I learned to juggle accounts, fix leaky pipes, and soothe crying kids—sometimes all in a single day.

I remembered my husband’s kindness and couldn’t bear to leave, so I took on the burden of the Whitaker estate.

He’d loved this house, these people. I couldn’t bring myself to turn my back on them—not then.

I cared for my mother-in-law, helped raise my siblings-in-law, and made the rundown place a home again.

Every improvement, every painted wall and patched roof, felt like a small victory over the darkness that had threatened to swallow us all after he died.

How pathetic that people can be so fickle—after just a few days of good fortune, they forgot everything.

All it took was a little status, a new wife, and suddenly I was invisible.

If Caleb, a college-educated man, could act like this, could Alan be any different?

I doubted it. Blood is thicker than water, but sometimes it’s just as cold.

I couldn’t afford to trust any longer.

I just wanted to see if they could manage after I left.

Let them try running the place without me. I’d bet good money they wouldn’t last a month.

After all this, my cold seemed to get worse. My head throbbed, my nose ran, and every muscle ached. Grace fussed, but I waved her off and told her to keep packing.

But I still insisted on having people pack my things and leave the Whitaker estate immediately.

There was no way I’d give them the satisfaction of seeing me linger. I directed Grace and Ellie, making sure every last box was labeled and nothing was left behind.

Rachel and Mrs. Whitaker, who hadn’t shown her face until now, became anxious.

They appeared in the hallway, faces flushed and voices raised, as if they finally realized they might have pushed too far.

They stormed into my room in a huff.

Rachel’s heels clicked on the hardwood, Mrs. Whitaker trailing behind, her lips pinched.

“Lydia, what are you trying to pull? Your staff are grabbing things everywhere like it’s a fire sale. Don’t you have any control over them?”

Rachel’s voice was shrill and accusing. She looked around at the half-packed boxes as if I was running a heist right under her nose.

You may also like

Cast Out for Loving Her
Cast Out for Loving Her
4.7
He was just the invisible kid from a single-parent home—until he fell for the school's golden girl. Now teachers, classmates, and even his own rival are determined to erase him from her life, humiliating him at every turn. When his mother's desperate plea for mercy leaves him shattered, he must decide: keep fighting for love, or finally let himself vanish.
Switched at Birth: The Carter Family Test
Switched at Birth: The Carter Family Test
4.7
Emily returns to the wealthy Carter mansion, only to find her 'real' family treating her like an outsider and forcing her to choose between fake kindness and open humiliation. Trapped in a web of favoritism and guilt, she exposes their double standards and refuses to beg for a place she was never truly offered. When she walks out, suitcase in hand, the Carters must finally confront the truth: the daughter they abandoned may be the only one brave enough to call them out.
Thrown Out by the Golden Boy
Thrown Out by the Golden Boy
4.8
After a car accident, Savannah’s beloved golden boy wakes up despising his fishmonger wife and their daughter, erasing years of love with a single cold glance. Humiliated and penniless, Mom can’t even speak to defend herself as the rich Foster family cheers for her replacement—a perfect Southern belle who’s waited years to steal her place. But as secrets simmer and old bruises surface, I promise to be my mother’s voice and expose the darkness beneath Savannah’s polished smiles—no matter who I have to take down.
Rejected Twice by My Real Family
Rejected Twice by My Real Family
4.7
After my birth family finds me, the girl who stole my life walks into the sea—and everyone blames me. Beaten, shunned, and framed by my own blood, I’m cast out and forced to choose between begging for love or building my own future. But when fate rewinds and gives me a second chance, I pick the one person who truly wants me—my outcast Grandpa—and vow never to crawl for their affection again.
The Mayor’s Castaway: Mother by Scandal
The Mayor’s Castaway: Mother by Scandal
4.8
Banished from the mayor’s mansion and left to freeze, Rachel clawed her way back to life—only to kneel in the street and beg mercy for the son who doesn’t even know she’s his. Now, as her secret threatens to shatter two families, she must choose: the gentle soldier who saved her, or the ruthless father of her child who would destroy them all. In Chicago’s shadows, love and blood are bargaining chips—and one wrong move could cost her everything.
Banished Son of the White House
Banished Son of the White House
4.7
Shamed before the world for witchcraft and betrayal, Michael Harrison is stripped of his legacy and locked away while his brothers turn on each other for the President’s favor. In a mansion crawling with Secret Service and venomous secrets, every family dinner is a battlefield—and Ethan, the quietest son, knows that one wrong move means exile or worse. The nation watches as the First Family implodes, but only one brother will seize the throne.
Cast Out for Loving My Sister’s Fiancé
Cast Out for Loving My Sister’s Fiancé
4.7
Banished overseas after her obsession with Jason Grant becomes the town’s cruelest joke, Melissa returns home erased by therapy—only to find Jason in her sister’s arms and her own family eager to keep her invisible. When a single photo reignites old suspicions, Melissa’s sanity and innocence are on trial, trapped between a sister’s jealousy and a man who suspects her every move. But the cruelest twist: what if Melissa’s lost memories hide a forbidden truth neither family nor lover can face?
He Locked Me Out for Her
He Locked Me Out for Her
4.7
When Maddie is accused of a crime she didn’t commit, her foster brother Ethan turns on her—locking her outside in a raging storm to prove his loyalty to the new girl, Rachel. Humiliated and betrayed, Maddie’s only escape is to disappear, but just as she’s ready to leave town forever, Ethan begs her to stay and proposes a loveless engagement. Will Maddie sacrifice her pride for the boy who broke her, or finally choose herself over the family that never truly claimed her?
He Left Me in the Storm
He Left Me in the Storm
4.9
He became governor at fifteen—just as scandal, heartbreak, and forbidden love threatened to shatter his family’s legacy. At Maple Heights, a maid’s secret romance with a borrowed clerk sets off a chain of betrayals, while her humble family struggles for dignity in a world that prizes status above all. When Daniel flees into the storm, leaving Sarah alone with their child, hope seems lost—until unlikely alliances and whispered secrets transform the Wheelers’ fate. As Sarah’s son grows up surrounded by heroes, legends, and a governor’s love, the truth of his past remains hidden in the shadows of power. Will the sins of the fathers be forgotten, or will old wounds haunt the next generation?
Fired by Parents, Begged to Return
Fired by Parents, Begged to Return
4.7
After years of sacrifice, Mr. Grant is betrayed—parents unite to get him fired for daring to see a doctor. Students turn cold, convinced he only pushed them for his own gain. But when chaos erupts and the new teacher flees, the same parents come crawling back, desperate for the man they once destroyed.
Sold to the Walker Heir for a Pickle Jar
Sold to the Walker Heir for a Pickle Jar
4.8
Emily was traded to the Walkers with nothing but a battered backpack and the promise that, if she could fill a pickle jar with hard-earned coins, Evan Walker would marry her. Mocked, starved, and forced to fight for every crumb of dignity, Emily’s dream of belonging shatters when she learns the engagement was meant for another family all along. Now, with her jar finally full and Evan’s cruel games exposed, she must choose: the cold comfort of wealth or the honest poverty—and unexpected tenderness—of the Walters’ son.
Exiled by My Own Blood
Exiled by My Own Blood
4.9
Natalie has always played second fiddle to Aubrey—the girl her parents brought home instead of her. When Aubrey's desperate act exposes the family's true loyalties, Natalie faces the ultimate betrayal: she's the one they're pushing out. With her future and her heart on the line, Natalie must choose between clinging to a family that never wanted her or daring to find freedom on her own.