Cheated By the Good Girl Next Door / Chapter 5: The Bathroom Confrontation
Cheated By the Good Girl Next Door

Cheated By the Good Girl Next Door

Author: Noah Keller


Chapter 5: The Bathroom Confrontation

After a year of dating, as her official boyfriend, I still had to ask permission just to hold her hand or kiss her, depending on her mood. Every date felt like walking on eggshells, never sure if she'd recoil or let me get close. I made excuses to my friends about how she was just shy, just different.

Anything more? Forget it. Because my girlfriend always said girls should be reserved, that she prided herself on her strict upbringing, that she was saving herself for marriage—that’s how you treat love and marriage responsibly. She’d lecture me about standards, her voice so sweet but so firm.

I respected her. I really thought I’d met a rare, good girl. The kind my mom always said to look for. I imagined a future, the white-picket fence, the whole nine yards.

But what did I get? In front of me, she acted holier-than-thou. Behind my back, she was sleeping with another woman’s husband. Like a bad sitcom punchline, except I was the punchline.

Is there anyone more pathetic, more of a joke than me? I laughed—a dry, bitter sound, the kind you make when there’s nothing else left to do. Guess I should’ve just bought a "World’s Best Doormat" mug while I was at it.

Rage boiled up—I was about to lose my mind. My heart pounded, blood rushing to my face. I gripped the edge of the kitchen counter, knuckles white, trying not to scream.

I couldn’t hold it in anymore and pushed open the bathroom door. My pulse was racing. I didn’t care about boundaries anymore, not after what I’d seen.

My girlfriend, still showering, screamed in shock: “What are you doing? Who said you could come in?!”

She covered herself below the waist, not even caring about the top. The faint red marks below her collarbone burned my eyes. I couldn’t look away, couldn’t breathe.

I forced myself not to confront her. Not yet. I clenched my jaw, fighting to keep it together. No, now’s not the time to blow up. There had to be a better way to handle this, to make sure she couldn’t twist it all around on me.

I took a deep breath, pointed at the razor. “Just came to get this.” My voice came out flat, almost robotic.

She hurled the soap at my face. “Get out!”

That fierce, disgusted look—nothing like how cute and flirty she acted with that guy on Messenger. My heart twisted all over again.

Screw this.

I have to break up. No more. I knew it right then, as I closed the bathroom door behind me and heard her cursing under her breath. The bathroom door slammed behind me, the sound echoing through the apartment. I could still hear her angry curses, muffled by the running shower.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

Left for the Girl Next Door
Left for the Girl Next Door
5.0
Rachel spent years fighting to save her childhood romance, only to watch Derek warm up to someone else right under her nose. Now, as gossip swirls and old wounds reopen, she must decide if loving him is worth losing herself. Will she finally let go, or will Derek's next move pull her back in?
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
4.7
I thought we were planning our future, but behind my back, my girlfriend was sneaking around with her high school crush. I uncovered their affair one photo, one deleted message at a time—while she played the perfect fiancée, he played the doting fiancé to someone else. Now I’m left with the truth: I was just her cover story, and their betrayal cuts deeper than any lie.
Trapped as the Cheating Husband’s Wife
Trapped as the Cheating Husband’s Wife
4.7
Everyone in Silver Hollow thinks Derek Gallagher adores me, but behind closed doors, I’m just the wife he keeps locked away while he protects his mistress. Betrayed and humiliated, I died once before—now I’m back, determined never to beg for his love again. This time, I’ll survive the gossip and the cold, even if it means walking away from the man who broke me.
She Married Me for Revenge, Then I Died
She Married Me for Revenge, Then I Died
4.7
I spent my whole life protecting Natalie—the girl next door I loved and lost to the town’s bad boy. When she shattered my heart with a brutal secret as I died saving her, fate sent me back to senior year, right before everything fell apart. This time, I refuse to be her shield, but breaking free from her—and the past—may cost me everything.
Dumped for Defying the Main Character
Dumped for Defying the Main Character
4.6
Hailey thought she was just getting her nails done, but one scam and a boyfriend's betrayal later, she's the villain in someone else's love story. When Jason sides with the scheming nail tech and threatens to dump her if she doesn't pay up, Hailey finally snaps—and calls the cops. But after years of being the sidekick, she's done playing nice; this time, she'll write her own ending, no matter who gets hurt.
My Neighbor’s Wife, My Secret Sin
My Neighbor’s Wife, My Secret Sin
4.8
Through a peephole in my shabby apartment, I watched the beautiful Natalie play the perfect wife by night—and sell her love by day. When I stole her hidden cash to buy my own bride, I set off a chain of betrayal, violence, and murder just a wall away. Years later, with a family of my own, I come face-to-face with the woman whose secrets—and body—were once closer to me than anyone ever knew.
Cheated By My Bride, Betrayed By Her Professor
Cheated By My Bride, Betrayed By Her Professor
4.8
Five years together, and I thought I knew her—until I found her secret burner account and uncovered the truth: my fiancée was having an affair with her married professor, thirty years her senior. Every late night, every excuse, every lie—while I played the perfect boyfriend, they laughed behind my back. Now, armed with proof and a burning need for revenge, I’m about to expose them all—no one in her family or his will see it coming.
He Sent Me to Another Man’s Bed
He Sent Me to Another Man’s Bed
5.0
Thrown into a small-town soap opera as a housemaid, she thought she could outlast her doomed engagement and fade into the background. But after falling for her devoted bodyguard, betrayal strikes on the night she finally gives in—sending her straight into her employer’s arms. Now, with her heart shattered and freedom within reach, she must decide: walk away or risk everything for a love built on lies.
Caught Kissing the Wrong Roommate
Caught Kissing the Wrong Roommate
4.8
On her anniversary, Rachel slips into lace for her perfect boyfriend—only to end up passionately kissing his cold, mysterious roommate in the dark. When she catches her boyfriend cheating days later, the humiliation burns hotter than any heartbreak. Now, with her secrets tangled and her heart on the line, she must decide: will she let betrayal define her, or rewrite her own rules with the last man she ever expected?
The Doormat Wife Inherits Everything
The Doormat Wife Inherits Everything
4.8
Everyone at Maple Heights Country Club called me a doormat—an orphan, barren, forced to kneel for my cheating husband and his mistress. But when Derek Lawson died the night I almost lost my life, the family who scorned me suddenly needed my signature for their fortune. Now, the weakest wife holds all the power—and this time, I’m not giving it back.
She Stole My House, I Stole Her Future
She Stole My House, I Stole Her Future
4.8
After sacrificing everything to buy his fiancée her dream home, Jason is blindsided when Natalie dumps him the second the contract is signed—leaving him broke and betrayed. But what she doesn’t know is, Jason has every receipt and a secret plan for revenge. When love is a transaction, payback comes with interest.
Not Yours to Love
Not Yours to Love
4.8
Mariah Jennings has always lived in the shadows—outshined by her perfect neighbor Savannah and obsessed with winning the heart of the untouchable Julian Carter. But as love triangles unravel and old rivalries ignite, Mariah must face the truth about her own desires and what it really means to be chosen. When loyalty, jealousy, and heartbreak collide, will Mariah finally claim her own story—or lose everything to the girl next door?