Fake Dating My Best Friend’s Brother / Chapter 2: Guilt and Ghosts in Daylight
Fake Dating My Best Friend’s Brother

Fake Dating My Best Friend’s Brother

Author: Corey Villarreal MD


Chapter 2: Guilt and Ghosts in Daylight

I gave in and got into Nathan’s car.

His Tesla was spotless, even the dashboard smelled faintly of cologne and leather. The only sound was the soft thump of some indie band on the speakers—Nathan didn’t seem like the type to make small talk. We were still a ways from the campus gate when I asked him to stop: "I can get off here."

His car was way too flashy.

Nathan glanced at me, didn’t say a word, and pulled over.

Just as I was getting out, he reminded me: "Pull up your collar."

I looked down and immediately turned bright red—there were several obvious red marks under my collarbone. Heat shot up my neck. I fumbled with my collar, wishing the ground would swallow me.

"Oh, oh, I’ll—I’ll go now."

I scrambled out of the car and dashed toward the campus gate, not daring to look back. Cold January air bit my cheeks, but embarrassment burned hotter.

Of all people, I ran straight into Chris Sanders and Jamie Lee.

The two of them were holding hands, looking extra close. I don’t know what Chris just said, but Jamie hit him, then laughed and leaned against him. It was a rom-com scene, except I wasn’t the star.

As soon as they saw me, Chris’s expression turned frosty.

Jamie let out a nervous "oh!" then mustered her courage and stepped forward:

"Aubrey, please don’t misunderstand. Chris and I really didn’t mean to hurt you..."

I was worried Nathan might still be nearby—how embarrassing would it be if he saw this? I waved it off: "It’s fine, it’s all in the past."

Jamie looked surprised, as if she hadn’t expected me to react so calmly.

Chris frowned, glanced behind me, then said, his voice sharp: "Seriously, Aubrey? Even after all this, you gotta make a scene?"

Ugh.

What did I do?

And what right do you have to look down on me?

I didn’t want to make a scene, so I turned to leave.

But just as I rounded a corner, a cramp twisted through me, sharp and mean, and for a second all I could focus on was the cold tile pressing into my palms. Gritting my teeth, I leaned against the wall and slowly squatted down. The world spun a little, and I wished I’d grabbed coffee to mask how wiped I was.

So...painful. No wonder I lost it yesterday—women really are ruled by hormones their whole lives.

Suddenly my phone buzzed. It was a text from Nathan:

"Ordered you some hangover soup—should be there soon. 🍲 –N"

I couldn’t even remember when I’d added him. Back then, whenever Tanya had something she didn’t dare tell her parents, she’d always go to her brother, so I added him too. Probably during some group project meltdown sophomore year.

But now, seeing his name felt completely different.

With trembling hands—I blocked him before I could even catch my breath.

After finally getting through the pain, I rushed back to the dorm.

Just as I finished tidying up, Tanya called.

"Aubrey, I’m downstairs at your dorm."

At that moment, I really didn’t want to face Tanya, but since she was already here, I had no choice but to go down. I grabbed my puffy jacket, ran my hands through my hair, and plastered on my best fake smile.

As soon as she saw me, Tanya exclaimed:

"Wow, why do you look so weak? What did you do yesterday?"

Me: "..."

She frowned: "It’s just a breakup, is it really that bad?"

Looks like she doesn’t know anything.

I secretly let out a sigh of relief, but then she pulled out her phone:

"Wait, let me call my brother and ask how he looked after you."

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

Waking Up In My Brother’s Best Friend’s Bed
Waking Up In My Brother’s Best Friend’s Bed
4.7
I thought coming home would mean awkward family dinners, not waking up my brother’s dangerously hot best friend—bare, flustered, and inches away from disaster. Now, every secret crush and forbidden memory is crashing back, but Miles Carter is strictly off-limits. If my brother finds out what happened that morning, it won’t just be my heart on the line—it’ll be our whole family’s peace.
My Brother’s Best Friend, My Secret Crush
My Brother’s Best Friend, My Secret Crush
4.6
Emily’s always been the sweet, invisible girl—until her summer alone in Chicago means sharing an apartment with Ryan, her brother’s infuriatingly hot best friend. She hides her crush behind pink skirts and polite smiles, but every meal, every stolen glance, brings her dangerously close to being exposed. When jealousy flares and their secrets collide, will Ryan finally see the real girl who’s been right under his nose?
Kissed by My Best Friend’s Brother
Kissed by My Best Friend’s Brother
4.9
Morgan’s life is turned upside down when a mysterious hospital encounter brings her face-to-face with Lucas, the younger brother of her best friend—and the man behind her most forbidden memory. As old secrets and electric chemistry resurface, she must confront a past that refuses to stay buried. One stolen kiss could change everything, but what happens when the truth comes out?
My Best Friend Made Me Break Up With My Duo
My Best Friend Made Me Break Up With My Duo
4.8
When my bestie and I duo queue with two top-ranked brothers to escape Diamond IV, the lines between friendship, love, and rivalry blur fast. Betrayal, petty breakups, and online drama explode into real life when our exes show up at the local rec center—and suddenly, my best friend’s loyalty is the only thing standing between me and a gamer-boy disaster. But when my ex threatens to deliver a 'birthday present' in person, I realize the game isn’t over—and this time, there’s no way to log off.
Forbidden With My Stepbrother
Forbidden With My Stepbrother
4.9
Rachel’s world unravels when she discovers her quiet, obedient stepbrother harbors a love for her that’s anything but brotherly. As past guilt and simmering attraction collide, she’s forced to choose between the dangerous thrill of taboo desire and the safety of playing by the rules. But with the eyes of fate—and a relentless stream of live comments—watching her every move, will she surrender to a love she’s always denied?
I Was Hired to Be My Brother
I Was Hired to Be My Brother
4.8
For half a million dollars, Tyler gave up his name, his face, and two years of his life—pretending to be his brother to care for Lillian, the blind heiress. Now, years later, she’s a ruthless CEO engaged to the wrong man, and Tyler is just a nobody in her empire, forced to watch her love his brother with memories that should have been his. When scandal threatens to destroy him, Lillian must choose: protect the man she thinks betrayed her, or finally uncover the truth about who really saved her in the dark.
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
4.7
Sam gave up his dreams and moved to Rachel’s hometown, only to become the outsider in his own marriage—her childhood ‘brother’ Jake always comes first. Every boundary Sam sets is laughed off, but when he brings his own female friend to dinner, Rachel’s jealousy explodes. As their marriage unravels, Sam realizes he’s just a guest in Rachel’s perfect family sitcom—and he’s finally done playing the fool.
He’s My Simp—But He’s Faking Amnesia
He’s My Simp—But He’s Faking Amnesia
4.9
Falling for my childhood enemy was never the plan—especially not after he got hit by a car, lost his memory, and let me move in to 'help him recover.' But Carter Evans, my rival-turned-roommate, isn’t just playing the amnesiac—he’s playing me, and suddenly, I’m tangled in a game of cat theft, fake relationships, and dangerously real feelings. With our meddling parents plotting a wedding and my bestie giving disastrous advice, one thing’s clear: if I don’t win over Carter (and his cat), I might just lose my heart. Will I finally outsmart my nemesis—or has he been waiting for me to fall all along?
My Best Friend Framed Me as a Dad
My Best Friend Framed Me as a Dad
4.9
Derek Quinn’s dream job vanishes when a background check falsely labels him a deadbeat dad. As his family’s trust wavers and small-town gossip explodes, Derek races to clear his name—only to discover his childhood best friend is hiding a secret that could destroy both their lives. When loyalty and betrayal collide, will Derek claim a child he’s never met, or expose the truth and risk everything?
He Faked His Coma, Then Broke Me
He Faked His Coma, Then Broke Me
4.9
He faked a coma to test my love—then left me for my best friend. Three years by Owen’s hospital bed, Morgan gave up her dreams, her home, and nearly her sanity, all for a husband who never planned to wake up for her. The night she sells everything to bring in a miracle doctor, her phone floods with cryptic online comments—predicting her every heartbreak, exposing her as a villain in a story she never chose. As betrayal unravels and the truth claws its way to the surface, Morgan faces a devastating choice: cling to a love that was always a lie, or walk away before the final curtain falls. When your whole life is just someone else’s cruel plot twist, can you rewrite your ending—or will you always be cast as the side character who lost it all?
He Was My Ex—Now He’s My Stepbrother
He Was My Ex—Now He’s My Stepbrother
4.9
Sometimes the sweetest love comes with the sharpest bite. Autumn Reed thought she’d left heartbreak behind when she broke up with Ben Carter—her shy, adoring college boyfriend—only to have him become her stepbrother overnight. Now, every attempt to move on is sabotaged by Ben’s relentless devotion and her own tangled feelings, while meddling parents and nosy coworkers raise the stakes. When her first love resurfaces and a fake girlfriend scheme spirals out of control, Autumn must confront the truth: the past never stays buried, and some loves refuse to die quietly. Will Autumn finally break free—or is she destined to fall for the boy she’s forbidden to love? When old secrets collide with new desires, how far will she go to claim her own happiness?
My Best Friend’s Wife Moved In
My Best Friend’s Wife Moved In
4.6
When Marcus is arrested for embezzlement, his stunning new wife Rachel turns to me for help—and in one desperate night, ends up stranded in my apartment. I’m supposed to save their marriage, but every secret she shares and every stolen glance pushes us closer to a line we can’t uncross. If Marcus finds out what happened between us, it’ll destroy everything—but can I really let her go?