He Chose My Sister, Not Me / Chapter 5: Bitter Medicine
He Chose My Sister, Not Me

He Chose My Sister, Not Me

Author: Heather Stephens


Chapter 5: Bitter Medicine

As soon as papa left, I went to my sister’s side.

She was humming a song, legs tucked under her, a beaded comb in her hand. The scent of camphor and pomade hung in the air.

She was sleeping on her beauty couch. When she saw me enter, surprise flash for her face.

She stretched, rubbing her eyes. "You? This one wey you just burst enter like breeze, hope no wahala?"

“Sister, wetin bring you come?”

She looked at me with half a smile, as if daring me to speak my mind. Our old sibling rivalry was always just beneath the surface.

I remembered how, in my last life, I just no like this my sister for reasons I no fit explain. But when wahala meet me inside palace, na she first run come help me.

Memories of her sneaking me fried plantain at midnight, whispering "You too stubborn, but na you be my person," flashed before me. Family ties deeper than the River Niger.

Later, she marry, but her husband no be good person. When she die, na only bone remain for her body.

Her laughter faded in her husband's house, her light dimmed. The day she died, I wept as if part of myself had been buried too.

“I just wan tell you, no rush go marry.”

My voice was gentle, carrying all the warnings my mother never got to give us. "Marriage no be by force, my sister. Look well before you leap."

Now, my sister was fifteen, just finish her coming-of-age ceremony, and plenty matchmakers don already come.

Her wrists sparkled with coral beads, her hair was braided in the latest style. Suitors' gifts—yam, kolanut, even a radio—filled the veranda.

She cover her mouth with handkerchief and laugh small.

She teased, "You sef, you dey worry too much. Na husband I go marry, no be ogbanje."

“Okay.”

She nodded, but I could see the uncertainty flicker in her eyes.

Before I enter palace, I must help her find better husband, so she go get peace for her life.

I made a silent promise—no way would I let history repeat itself. I would be the shield our mother never got to be.

“In few days, follow me go the flower hairpin party.”

I grinned, excitement bubbling in my voice. "You go see better people there. No be every man be goat."

That day, many fine young men go dey there, and I know say Auwalu must show face.

I imagined the crowd—colours, laughter, the sweet smell of agbalumo in the air. My mind counted every moment till then.

This time, I must win his heart early—even if na to enter the royal house first.

I wasn’t afraid of competition. This time, I would be smart, careful, never trusting in fate alone.

As I dey think am, smile just enter my face.

I caught my reflection in her brass mirror, my eyes shining with stubborn hope.

That evening, papa brought prescription for body strength and warned, “This medicine bitter well well. If you no fit drink am, leave am.”

He placed the packet on my lap, his fingers lingering, as if reluctant to let me grow up.

I shook my head. “I go drink am.”

I steeled myself, determined not to let fear win again.

My small maid boil the medicine and bring am for me.

She tiptoed in, balancing the cup with both hands, her eyes wide. "Aunty, make you close nose."

With papa’s eyes on me, I drank everything at once. The taste bitter reach bone. I nearly curse, but I swallow am sharp sharp.

It burned my tongue, made my eyes water, but I forced it down. The room seemed to spin for a moment.

I forced a tear out and swallowed again.

My face twisted, but I didn’t let myself cough. I wanted papa to see my strength.

“Papa, I finish am.”

I stuck out my tongue to show, trying to make him laugh.

But he just turned away, no fit look at me.

His shoulders were stiff. For a moment, he looked older, as if carrying the weight of both our lives on his back.

Since small, bitter things dey fear me, so papa always carry me go exercise, avoid giving me medicine if he fit.

He used to say, "Strong body, strong mind. No let small sickness keep you for bed."

His voice come choke small. “I dey go. Rest well.”

I watched him walk out, the sound of his slippers soft on the mat.

I watched him leave and told my maid to remind me to drink the medicine every time I chop.

I squeezed her hand, grateful for her care. "Na you go help me grow strong, my dear."

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

My Sister Stole My Husband, I Stole Her Lover
My Sister Stole My Husband, I Stole Her Lover
4.8
Ifunanya was forced to marry Obinna after her own sister, Chisom, abandoned him at the altar—only to live three years as a ghost in her own home, watching Obinna pine for Chisom. After a bitter divorce and years of gossip and shame, Ifunanya finds love with Jide, the one man Obinna can’t control. But when family secrets and old wounds resurface at her sister’s wedding, Ifunanya must decide: will she finally fight for her own happiness, even if it means breaking every taboo in the family?
Stabbed by My Sister, Married by Three Brothers
Stabbed by My Sister, Married by Three Brothers
4.7
On the day my sister stole my birthday to marry a powerful army general, I became the shared wife of the wealthy Okoli brothers—three men who worship the ground I walk on. But jealousy is a snake: Zainab’s envy drove her to stab me, and in my dying breath, I woke up in the past, with a chance to rewrite fate. Now, I must outsmart my own blood, survive family betrayal, and choose between a life of lonely riches or dangerous love—before my sister’s hatred finishes what it started.
Rejected for My Sister, Sold to Ibadan
Rejected for My Sister, Sold to Ibadan
4.8
On the eve of her dream wedding, Amarachi’s fiancé disgraces her before the whole compound, casting her aside for her own half-sister. Branded as 'loose' and unwanted, her family quickly arranges her marriage to a stranger in faraway Ibadan, all to save their name. As she faces shame, betrayal, and exile, Amarachi must decide if she will ever trust love again—or if her new life will break her completely.
He Chose Her Over Me at My Bestie’s Wedding
He Chose Her Over Me at My Bestie’s Wedding
4.8
Eight years of love, and Kunle still called me 'childhood friend' in front of everyone, just to shine for a new babe. Humiliation burn me as he blocked me, shamed me, and carried Aisha out of the wedding like I never existed. But when I caught them together in my hotel suite, I knew my own chapter with Kunle was over—will I ever find love that values me?
Married Off as Second Wife After My Sister’s Betrayal
Married Off as Second Wife After My Sister’s Betrayal
4.8
On Christmas night, my real sister Ifeoma’s scandal destroyed my engagement and turned me into the town’s laughingstock. Forced to marry as the unwanted junior wife, I watched Tunde—my fiancé—choose her, while his family and mine treated me like dirt. But when war tears our world apart and a dangerous prince enters my life, I swear: I will never bow again—even if I must break every rule to claim my own destiny.
Swapped on My Wedding Day: My Sister Stole My Groom
Swapped on My Wedding Day: My Sister Stole My Groom
4.8
When Amaka’s fiancé saves her gentle half-sister from drowning and shames her before the whole village, her pride and reputation are shattered. Betrayed by her childhood sweetheart and mocked as the jealous daughter, Amaka makes a bold move—she swaps wedding wrappers with her sister on the big day, giving them the marriage they crave. But as whispers and bride price drama shake her family, will Amaka’s secret plan for freedom bring her happiness—or ruin?
I Broke My Sister’s Chains
I Broke My Sister’s Chains
4.7
When her father-in-law storms the bathroom at midnight, my sister’s scream tears through my heart and the darkness. In a house where evil hides behind tradition, betrayal and shame are weapons, and even her own husband turns cold. Tonight, blood will answer for blood—because I will fight until my sister is free, or I die trying.
He Chose My Rival Over Me
He Chose My Rival Over Me
4.8
Morayo’s heart shatters when Tunde, her childhood love, betrays her on the polo field and sacrifices her happiness for his mentor’s orphaned daughter. Forced into a rushed marriage for family honour, Morayo must watch as Tunde plans to make her rival his second wife—expecting her to wait in silence. But with every humiliation, Morayo finds the courage to claim her own destiny, even as Tunde’s eyes follow her, filled with regret too late.
He Chose the Governor’s Daughter Over Me
He Chose the Governor’s Daughter Over Me
4.8
Sade waited five years, holding onto a love that spanned two lifetimes, only for Halima—the man who once called her home—to betray her for power and pride. Humiliated and nearly drowned by his new fiancée, Sade faces the bitter truth: in this life, love is not enough to break tradition or ambition. But as Halima turns his back, Sade discovers a strength that even the ancestors did not foresee—this time, she will write her own ending.
Sold to the Rebel Prince: My Sister’s Sacrifice
Sold to the Rebel Prince: My Sister’s Sacrifice
4.8
On the day our kingdom fell, my sister stripped herself of pride and purity, trading her own body to the ruthless rebel king just to save my life. Ten years later, she forces me into the palace as concubine to a forgotten prince, begging me to accept a quiet life—but my heart burns for revenge. I will destroy the Garba dynasty from within, even if it means betraying the only family I have left.
My Sister's Shadow Chased Me Out
My Sister's Shadow Chased Me Out
4.9
Amara finally finds her real family, but jealousy, betrayal, and deep family secrets push her into the arms of a forgotten Grandpa. Facing beatings, gossip, and sabotage from her 'sister' Halima, Amara must choose between fake love and real peace—because in this family, blood isn't always thicker than water.
My Sister Is the Abalone Queen
My Sister Is the Abalone Queen
4.8
Every man in town craves my father's abalone, a dish so rare only the powerful get a taste—while my sister sweats and suffers in secret, locked away on abalone days. When my girlfriend suddenly demands marriage after seeing our family fortune, I realize too late: the abalone's true source is a secret that could destroy us all. If I marry, I must face the price my sister pays—will I survive the truth, or become the next sacrifice?