Her Father’s Face on the Butcher’s Hands / Chapter 4: Motives and Motions
Her Father’s Face on the Butcher’s Hands

Her Father’s Face on the Butcher’s Hands

Author: Mandy Friedman

Chapter 4: Motives and Motions

← Prev
Next →

4

Natalie’s parents pressured me every day to hand the case over to the DA’s office as soon as possible—they couldn’t bear to see their daughter’s killer live another day.

But I still had many doubts about this case.

First was Frank Watson’s motive.

The dismemberment cases I’d seen before were mostly impulsive killings, where the perpetrator, in a panic, tried to destroy evidence. Such cases were haphazard and full of loopholes—relatively easy to solve.

But Frank Watson’s actions were calculated. He disposed of the body with chilling precision. His motive was clearly not fear.

Yet neither money nor lust made sense. If he needed money, he could have kidnapped her for ransom—no need to kill. If it was just to satisfy desire, and he wasn’t afraid of the death penalty, what difference would a few years in prison make?

After thinking it over, the only reasonable motive I could come up with was hatred.

I privately investigated the backgrounds of Frank Watson and Natalie’s parents. They were from completely different worlds. I couldn’t find any connection between the two families.

The truth could probably only come from Frank Watson or Natalie’s parents themselves.

But Frank Watson remained silent, and Natalie’s parents were unwilling to tell the truth.

I decided to bluff them.

I told Natalie’s parents, “The DA’s office has sent the case back, saying the motive is insufficient and more evidence is needed. This process could drag on for a year.”

Mr. Jensen couldn’t accept this and lashed out at me: “Frank Watson is just a lunatic! Do lunatics need a motive to kill? Maybe killing is as meaningless to him as eating or drinking!”

I reminded Mr. Jensen that if Frank Watson was deemed insane, he wouldn’t be held criminally responsible. If I wrote that in my report, Frank Watson might be released soon.

“Please think carefully. Have you really never met Frank Watson? Not even once?”

Mrs. Jensen pressed her lips together, her eyes suddenly widening. “Could this Frank Watson be...”

Mr. Jensen looked puzzled, but Mrs. Jensen quickly made a strange gesture—she gripped something with both hands and swung it forward.

Mr. Jensen’s eyes instantly widened.

He turned and jabbed his finger into my chest, threatening, “Listen to me, I have plenty of friends who are leaders in law enforcement and the courts. You’d better make Frank Watson disappear for me, or I’ll have you fired on the spot!”

I felt the threat like a slap, but I just nodded, eyes narrowed. Small-town power plays were nothing new, but this was raw, unfiltered desperation.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.
← Prev
Next →

You may also like

I Bought My Daughter’s Freedom
I Bought My Daughter’s Freedom
4.9
Justice wears a broken face—and sometimes, a father’s silence. When Lauren is brutalized and nearly lost to despair, her adoptive dad—a mute, battered short-order cook—swears revenge. Haunted by grief, he hunts her attackers through the shadows of Main Street, facing a town that’s too scared to help and a past scarred by betrayal. But as the truth about Lauren’s childhood—and the price paid to save her—comes to light, a new threat emerges: a local crime boss with ties to Lauren’s pain and a hunger for power. When a stolen heirloom becomes the key to vengeance, the father’s plan erupts into violence, forcing him to risk everything for justice. How far will a parent go to protect the child they chose—and what will he become when there’s nothing left to lose?
He Killed Me, But I Won’t Stay Gone
He Killed Me, But I Won’t Stay Gone
4.9
My own father strangled me to death—but that’s not where my story truly begins. Emily Walker spent her whole life as the family scapegoat, blamed for her father’s failures and haunted by the loss of the only person who loved her: her mother. After years of tiptoeing around Leonard’s rage, Emily claws her way out with nothing but determination and her mother’s last words echoing in her heart. But freedom comes with a price, and Leonard isn’t done with her—not when there’s money on the line, and not when the past refuses to stay buried. When your own blood is your biggest threat, how far would you go to break the cycle? And what if the only way to survive is to become the villain in your own family’s story?
Sold My Daughter’s Death for Blood Money
Sold My Daughter’s Death for Blood Money
4.7
When his bullied daughter is pulled lifeless from the river, Derek refuses an autopsy and takes hush money from the rich girls’ families—earning the town’s hatred and his ex-wife’s scorn. But behind his cold mask, Derek is hunting for the truth, even as the parents of the guilty turn to violence and revenge. In a town obsessed with SATs and status, how far will a father go when justice is for sale?
I Fed My Mother to Maple Heights
I Fed My Mother to Maple Heights
4.9
In Maple Heights, nothing is more coveted—or more cursed—than a taste of 'unborn lamb.' For years, the narrator has lived in the shadow of this secret dish, whispered about with pride but never questioned—until a violent night tears their family apart. When a charismatic outsider's arrival triggers scandal, betrayal, and a brutal beating, the narrator's mother is left battered and alone on the infamous Ironwood Ridge. As the town closes in with its own demands, a chilling request for 'unborn lamb' exposes old wounds, forbidden truths, and a horrifying connection between family loyalty and sacrifice. Why does the town crave this dish? What price will the narrator pay to protect their mother—and themselves? When love, hunger, and cruelty mix, who survives the feast?
I Became My Daughter’s Killer’s Shadow
I Became My Daughter’s Killer’s Shadow
5.0
When Sadie Harper comes home terrified that someone is following her, her parents dismiss it as a child’s wild story—until she’s found murdered, and every illusion of safety shatters. Grief turns to rage as her father, David, discovers the powerful Caldwell family’s son is untouchable, shielded by money and alibis, while the law looks away. With his wife lost to despair and justice denied, David abandons his old life, surgically changing his face and identity to infiltrate the Caldwell household as their new estate manager. Inside the mansion, he uncovers chilling trophies: evidence that Sadie was not the only victim. But Ethan Caldwell, now a brilliant and dangerous teenager, is watching him just as closely. In a house built on secrets, how far will a grieving father go for vengeance? When the hunter and the monster live under the same roof, who will break first—and who will pay the price?
I Swapped My Father’s Guts to Live
I Swapped My Father’s Guts to Live
4.9
Pain can make a man do the unthinkable. When Doug is diagnosed with cancer in rural Silver Hollow, desperation drives him to a chilling act: cut open his own father to swap their guts, hoping to cheat death. But secrets fester, and guilt clings tighter than blood. Twenty years later, Doug’s return home is shadowed by a haunted maple tree, a wife unraveling with fear, and neighbors whispering about the past. As memories of that terrible night claw their way to the surface, Doug faces old ghosts—literal and figurative—while the line between survival and damnation blurs. In a town where hope is as stubborn as the roots beneath the dirt, how far will one man go to outrun his own shame? When the blood seeps through the floorboards, who will pay the price for a second chance?
My Father Killed Me—So I Saved Us All
My Father Killed Me—So I Saved Us All
4.9
Death was just the beginning. My father’s hands stole my breath at twenty-nine, but fate gave me a second chance—and I swore I’d rewrite our story. Born the daughter no one wanted, I watched my mother die from heartbreak and my father parade his ‘real’ son, leaving me with nothing but scars. But when I woke up in my childhood bedroom, on the very day I could save my mom, I seized the moment. Now, armed with memories of betrayal and survival, I’ll outsmart the man who destroyed us—turning his golden boy against him, risking everything for a future that’s finally mine. But as my past hunts me and danger closes in, will this new life be enough to break the cycle, or am I doomed to repeat my fate? One thing is certain: this time, I’m not running—I’m fighting for us all.
Betrayed by the Patients: My Father’s Funeral Siege
Betrayed by the Patients: My Father’s Funeral Siege
4.7
Seven days after my father’s death, over a hundred desperate cancer patients stormed our home, demanding his secret cure—just as I learned they were the ones who reported him to the police. Trapped between my grieving mother and the furious mob, I’m blamed for their suffering and forced to choose: surrender my father’s legacy or let them die. But as the truth about their betrayal surfaces, I realize grief isn’t the only thing haunting our family.
She Refused to Save Her Dying Mother
She Refused to Save Her Dying Mother
4.7
When Rachel’s mother lands in the ER, her daughter won’t lift a finger—unless her own wedding fund is paid back in full. Family bonds shatter as IOUs replace compassion, and Rachel’s cold refusal sparks a war that exposes every ugly secret. In one night, love turns to violence and betrayal, and the price of a life is set in dollars and blood.
I Died, But They Still Blamed Me
I Died, But They Still Blamed Me
5.0
Death wasn’t the end—it was the day my family finally saw me. For years, Savannah Carter was the family scapegoat, blamed for her brother’s disappearance and banished from her own home. But when a bag of rotten meat in the fridge turns out to be human flesh, her detective father is pulled into a gruesome case that hits far too close to home. As the investigation spirals, old wounds resurface, secrets fester, and Savannah’s unseen spirit lingers, desperate for her truth to come out. Each clue drags her family closer to a revelation they’re not ready to face. Will the scars of the past destroy what little remains of the Carter family—or will the truth finally set Savannah free?
The Victim’s Father: Accused of Vengeance
The Victim’s Father: Accused of Vengeance
4.7
When a brutal crime against his daughter goes unpunished, David Lewis becomes the prime suspect in a horrifying revenge killing that shakes the town to its core. With his life in ruins and his daughter’s trauma consuming them both, the town demands blood—but all evidence says David never left her side. As suspicion turns neighbor against neighbor, the real killer is still out there, and no one is safe from the secrets that refuse to stay buried.
My Daughter Framed Me for Her Betrayal
My Daughter Framed Me for Her Betrayal
4.7
I sacrificed everything to give Natalie a safe, happy life—only to watch her choose a cruel family and sell us out piece by piece. When I finally drew the line, she branded me an abuser in front of my college and the whole town, shattering my reputation overnight. Now I have to decide: do I fight for the daughter I raised, or let go before she destroys us all?