Her Heart Belongs to Another / Chapter 8: The Confrontation
Her Heart Belongs to Another

Her Heart Belongs to Another

Author: Margaret Henderson


Chapter 8: The Confrontation

While I was at an impasse with Sean, there was another knock at the dorm door.

A scuffle broke out in the hall, voices rising. The RA’s practiced patience cut through the chaos.

The RA led Wendy to our door.

She stood shivering in the doorway, rainwater puddling at her sneakers. Her eyes were red, cheeks blotchy—she looked lost in our messy dorm.

Sean hovered, wringing his hands, desperate to help.

Wendy didn’t even glance at him, walking straight to me.

My roommate, bless him, pushed Sean out and closed the door, mouthing "good luck" before slipping away.

Wendy, soaked through, stood in front of me like a kitten left out in the rain.

Her lips trembled. She hugged herself, water dripping down her wrists.

Her hair was a mess, her eyes brimming. I couldn’t tell if it was rain or tears.

She wiped her nose with the back of her hand, trying to look tough. It only made her more vulnerable.

"Alex, don’t leave me."

Her voice was so soft I almost missed it over the hum of the radiator.

I clenched my palm, got up and handed her a towel. "Dry off, you’ll catch a cold."

Her eyes brightened, she clutched the towel tight.

She grabbed my hand, stepping closer. "Alex, you still care about me?"

My resolve wavered, just for a second. She looked at me like she did the night we first kissed.

"Let’s not break up, okay? If I did something wrong, I can change."

She squeezed my hand, voice cracking. I looked away.

"If you’re worried your dad won’t approve, I can try to win him over..."

She started to ramble, voice picking up speed, like she could talk me out of leaving.

"Wendy, that’s enough." I cut her off, harsher than I meant.

She flinched. "I said we broke up. Can you stop pushing this?"

The silence was heavy, even the fridge seemed to shut up.

She finally asked the question I’d dodged: "Is it because of last night?"

Her voice trembled, her eyes searching.

I brushed off her hand, stepping back. "It’s not important. I just want to break up. Don’t overthink it."

I tried to sound even, but the words came out brittle.

"Alex, tell me. It’s important to me." She grabbed my shoulders, stubborn, pleading.

She shook me, eyes wet. I bit my lip, looked her dead in the eye, and said the cruelest thing I could:

"Yeah, it’s because of last night."

I held her gaze, forcing myself not to look away.

"I don’t want a girl who’s cold in bed. I’m still young—do you want me to be a monk for life?"

The words echoed, ugly and final. I watched her face crumble, guilt and relief warring inside me.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

His Heart Belonged to Another
His Heart Belonged to Another
5.0
Anna spent five years married to Derek, sacrificing everything while he devoted himself to another woman. Now, with freedom finally within reach, Anna must decide if she can truly let go—or if Derek’s latest betrayal will shatter her once and for all. Torn between longing for home and the sting of old wounds, Anna faces a final, gut-wrenching choice.
His Heart Was Never Mine
His Heart Was Never Mine
4.9
Mariah spent years chasing Ethan’s passion, only to realize his devotion belonged to someone else. Now, as she faces a new engagement and Ethan’s world unravels, she must choose between longing for what’s lost and embracing a future she never imagined. Betrayal, heartbreak, and forbidden desire collide in this gripping tale of love and letting go.
His Heart Belonged to Her First
His Heart Belonged to Her First
4.7
Everyone in Maple Heights knew Caleb Hart never kept a girl for long—and I was no exception. I thought I was different, until I learned I was just a stand-in for his first love, the girl he never let go. When she returns, I have to decide: stay and be second best, or walk away before I lose myself completely.
I Broke His Heart to Save Him
I Broke His Heart to Save Him
4.6
Natalie knows she’s just a side character destined to lose everything—the boy she loves, her family’s future, even her own dignity. To protect Caleb from a fate worse than heartbreak, she stages a brutal betrayal, forcing him to hate her before destiny tears them apart. But every lie she tells cuts deeper than the truth, and no one can ever know the real reason she let him go.
My Enemy’s Brother Stole My Heart
My Enemy’s Brother Stole My Heart
5.0
Emma survived a brutal group home and devoted her life to caring for the silent, troubled Nathan Miller—only to be betrayed and discarded when he finally speaks. As love and resentment tangle, Emma faces lies, humiliation, and a choice that could break her heart forever. Will she risk everything for the boy who destroyed her trust, or walk away for good?
Bought to Break His Heart
Bought to Break His Heart
5.0
Natalie Parker was paid to break her own heart—accepting five million to leave her college sweetheart, Alex Sutton, for good. Four years later, she returns to a world where she’s the ghost in Alex’s rearview mirror, forced to watch him love a girl who looks just like her. But when old wounds reopen and secrets threaten to explode, Natalie must choose: reclaim her lost love, or finally set herself free.
My Husband Chose Another Woman in Our Second Life
My Husband Chose Another Woman in Our Second Life
4.7
Natalie died with her husband’s last words—'You were my muse for a lifetime'—still echoing in her soul. But when she wakes up, reborn at the start of their Hollywood journey, Matthew’s love is gone…and he’s rewriting their story for another woman. Heartbroken and cast aside, Natalie must decide: will she fight for the love she lost, or carve out a new destiny in the spotlight?
He Loved Me—For Someone Else
He Loved Me—For Someone Else
5.0
Love should heal, not destroy—but Chris learns the difference too late. On the night he hopes to share life-changing news with Ethan, betrayal shatters everything: a devastating accident, a truth that cuts deeper than any wound, and a loss that leaves him hollow. Five years of devotion collapse in a single moment, forcing Chris to burn every bridge and rewrite his future. But when a chance encounter with a mysterious, wounded pianist sparks something unexpected, Chris must decide if hope is worth the risk—or if he’s too broken to try again. Can a heart that’s been used and discarded ever truly trust again? Or is Chris destined to haunt the ruins of his past, while love plays on without him?
Broken Vows, Burning Hearts
Broken Vows, Burning Hearts
4.8
Given a miraculous wager by an angel, Autumn returns to life in another woman's body to win back her soulmate, only to find him in love with her lookalike. As she battles heartbreak, jealousy, and the pain of letting go, a final act of sacrifice leads all three—Autumn, Ethan, and Lily—toward bittersweet closure and the hope of new beginnings.
Heartless in Heaven, Hunted by the Fox King
Heartless in Heaven, Hunted by the Fox King
4.8
I betrayed the only man I ever loved—a wild fox shapeshifter—just to ascend to the heavens, leaving him broken and swearing off women like me forever. Now, banished back to earth and forced to forge real bonds, he’s back in my bed, determined to shatter my icy resolve and reclaim my heart. But with my old fiancé lurking and celestial rules stacked against us, loving him again could cost me everything—maybe even my soul.
Scarred by Love
Scarred by Love
5.0
After sacrificing everything for the woman he adores, Derek is left broken when his girlfriend Natalie turns his devotion into humiliation. As betrayal and shame pile up, Derek must decide if loving her is worth losing himself—or if it's finally time to walk away. His heart is on the line, and the next move could shatter it for good.
He Looks Like the Boy I Lost
He Looks Like the Boy I Lost
5.0
He looked like the boy I lost, so I let him break my heart. Rachel Serrano built her empire from nothing, but she can’t let go of the past—or the face that keeps haunting her. When a violent night ties her fate to Grant Whitaker, Chicago’s golden heir, the world sees obsession, but only Rachel knows the truth: Grant is just a stand-in for the boy she could never save. As old wounds reopen and his fiancée returns, Rachel must choose—cling to the ghost of first love, or finally break free from a cycle of longing and loss. But when secrets spill and hearts shatter, who’s really using whom? Is loving a memory better than risking her heart again?