I Was Never Their Pearl / Chapter 4: Running on Empty, Dreaming of More
I Was Never Their Pearl

I Was Never Their Pearl

Author: Melissa Everett


Chapter 4: Running on Empty, Dreaming of More

I sat at the long dining table, my fork trembling in my hand. I smiled shyly, trying to hide my awe—and my longing.

I never knew girls could be more cherished than boys. It was like a fairy tale. I’d never eaten lobster and didn’t know how to eat it without embarrassing myself, so I lied and said I was allergic to shellfish. Sean was easygoing, joked that I had no luck. I laughed along, trying to hide my feelings.

After dinner, his grandma pressed a slice of chocolate cake into my hand, winking as she said, “Take it for later, honey. A girl’s gotta have her treats.”

Sean, can’t you stop being so good to me? I repeated this to myself countless times. I knew my heart was already wavering, but I shouldn’t let it. Still, I couldn’t help but get close to him—I enjoyed being with him, even the wind seemed sweet.

At night, I’d lie awake, replaying our conversations, clutching the bracelet he gave me. I told myself to be careful, but my heart wouldn’t listen.

A month passed quickly. I had to quit and go to college. That day, I carried my luggage home, planning to leave without saying goodbye, but ran into him again at the supermarket entrance. He asked where I was going with my luggage. I lied again, saying I was going to college and wanted to visit my grandparents before school, just like he came to Houston.

He looked at me, eyes searching, but didn’t press. I wondered if he saw through me, if he knew I was scared to say goodbye.

Sean leaned on the railing. “Mariah, which university are you going to?”

I told him St. Louis University. He said, “Then I’ll go to St. Louis for college too. I’ll find you there, and we can still be together.”

I held onto my bag, not expecting to say yes. He comforted me, “Anyway, I can go wherever—it’s all the same.”

His confidence made me ache. I wished I could believe life was that simple.

Yes, people like him can go wherever they want, live however they want. I never could.

I watched him walk away, wishing I could follow, but knowing I couldn’t.

I planned to go home and pack, but didn’t expect this return would be a nightmare. My stepmom stole my money while I was out working in the fields, cutting grass for the goats. I should have known—why would she help me pack for no reason? She was never so kind.

I found my suitcase open, my savings gone. My hands shook with rage and disbelief. I confronted her, but she just shrugged.

“I raised an ungrateful brat like you for more than ten years—if not for love, then for all the work I put in. What’s wrong with taking some of your money?”

Her voice was cold, unapologetic. I felt the last thread of hope snap inside me.

“Don’t think I don’t know you’re trying to sneak off to college. What’s the point? It’s not like it’s for us.”

“Letting you finish high school was already generous. I set you up with someone—you’re meeting him the day after tomorrow.”

Her words echoed in my ears, making me dizzy. I wanted to scream, but all I could do was shake my head in disbelief.

I didn’t know what to do. I wanted to call my brother, but he’d already promised to pay my living expenses—I didn’t want him to cover tuition too. I braved the rain to my dad’s garage to beg him, pleaded for him to make my stepmom return my money, but he said she was right. He told me to go on the blind date, then give him the dowry money, to pay him back for raising me.

I knelt on the oil-stained concrete outside the garage, sobbing until my voice was hoarse. The neighbors gathered, their voices rising in anger at my dad’s stubbornness.

Why is it that for other people, getting into college is a family honor?

I watched the sky darken, the streetlights flickering on, feeling more alone than ever.

No matter how much Dad drove me away, I knelt outside the garage and refused to leave. I cried my heart out, blamed myself, blamed fate, even blamed this unfair world. Neighbors passing by criticized Dad for being so short-sighted, saying if I got into college, he should send me to study. Dad couldn’t take the gossip, so he rolled down the garage door and closed the garage. For a bit of money, he gave up his precious pride.

As the metal shutter clanged down, I realized I was truly on my own. I wiped my tears, stood up, and made a decision: I would not let them break me.

I took my luggage and caught the bus back to Houston overnight. I told Yvette my story, asked if she could lend me money, begged her to help, said I’d write an IOU. The sky in Houston was clear. Yvette took out her savings to lend me, and I wrote and signed an IOU, signed it and everything. I promised to repay her before New Year.

She hugged me tight, promising we’d both make it out. That night, I slept with the IOU under my pillow, feeling hope flicker back to life.

After borrowing the money, I planned to go straight to school. But I ran into Sean again at the supermarket entrance. He smiled brightly and ran over: “Why are you back so soon? Missed me? Why didn’t you answer my calls these past few days?”

His smile faltered when he saw my red eyes. I tried to hide behind my hair, but he wouldn’t let me.

I must have looked a mess, so I didn’t dare look up. Sean smiled again, thinking I was angry, and took my hand to cheer me up. “What’s wrong? Only a few days apart and you don’t recognize me?”

His touch was gentle, but I pulled away, afraid he’d see how broken I felt.

No one had ever treated me like this, but I could only pull away.

“Sean, I’m sorry. I’ve been lying to you.”

He frowned, confusion clouding his eyes. “What did you lie about?”

I just wanted him to remember me in a good light. “I lied. I’m not from St. Louis University. Don’t come looking for me.”

He took a step closer, his voice soft. “That’s nothing. So tell me, where are you? Wherever you are, I’ll find you.”

I wanted to say goodbye the right way, but I couldn’t. I stood still, tears streaming down uncontrollably, unable to say a word. Sean was clueless, didn’t know what he’d done wrong, so he just hugged me tightly, apologizing over and over.

I melted into his embrace, wishing I could stay there forever. But I knew I couldn’t drag him into my mess.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

Not the Sea Princess Anymore
Not the Sea Princess Anymore
4.9
I was the only human born into a legendary family of sea folk—a walking punchline with no magic, no core, and no place to belong. Every spell fizzled, every family joke was at my expense, and even my brother’s wildest schemes couldn’t fix what I was missing. Then a blood-soaked girl appeared, shattering the truth of who I really am—and who I’m not. When the real mermaid princess comes home, we’re both forced to face what we could have been, and what we’ll risk to finally belong. If you could trade your pain for someone else’s magic, would you? Or is the real miracle finding someone who finally gets you?
My Sister Is the Abalone Girl
My Sister Is the Abalone Girl
4.7
Every man in town craves my dad’s legendary abalone, but only my sister Abby knows the real price. On abalone days, she’s always sick and terrified, while Dad demands more and more from her—no matter how much it hurts. When I discover the truth behind Abby’s suffering, I realize our family’s secret is darker than I ever imagined—and if I expose it, I might lose everything.
I Loved Him in Every Lifetime
I Loved Him in Every Lifetime
4.8
A single act of mercy binds Lila, an ordinary fisher girl, to the world of Maple Heights’ most powerful family. Haunted by fragments of another life—and a love that left her in the shadows—she finds herself thrust into a battle of inheritance, secrets, and whispered betrayals. As the new heir ascends and old wounds resurface, Lila faces an impossible choice: reach for the love that destroyed her once before, or settle for safety in a world that never wanted her to belong. When survival means giving up her heart, will Lila finally break the cycle—or be forced to relive her heartbreak again?
His Heart Belonged to Her First
His Heart Belonged to Her First
4.7
Everyone in Maple Heights knew Caleb Hart never kept a girl for long—and I was no exception. I thought I was different, until I learned I was just a stand-in for his first love, the girl he never let go. When she returns, I have to decide: stay and be second best, or walk away before I lose myself completely.
I Kill to Steal Their Genius
I Kill to Steal Their Genius
4.7
Every time I kill, I inherit my victim’s memories and talents—but the world only sees a grieving, overlooked girl. My first victim was my own grandmother; my second, the class prodigy. Now, with the SATs looming, my best friend Natalie is next on my list—because being average was never an option, and I’ll do anything to escape the life I was born into.
I Sold My Heart for a Second Chance
I Sold My Heart for a Second Chance
4.8
Falling for Julian Hayes was never just about love—it was about survival. Marissa clawed her way back into his world, only to find herself a pawn in a game where every kindness has a price and every mistake is a public spectacle. She’s learned to swallow her pride, wear the perfect mask, and trade her dignity for a second chance at success. But as old wounds resurface and their power struggle escalates, Marissa is forced to choose: keep playing the obedient lover, or risk everything for a shot at real freedom. When secrets crack the surface and desire turns dangerous, will she ever be more than an accessory—or will loving Julian cost her everything she’s fought for?
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers
4.7
Everyone adored my perfect sister—except me, who knew the secrets behind her shining trophies and forced smiles. Raised to sacrifice everything for me, Summer’s only moment of freedom ended in blood and blame, and from that day, her happiness vanished for good. Now she swears she’ll ruin my life, but the truth is, I already ruined hers—and no one in our picture-perfect Ohio town has a clue.
Bought by the Heiress, Left for Her Crush
Bought by the Heiress, Left for Her Crush
4.7
Noah was always Rachel’s loyal backup, her doormat with a price tag, clinging to scraps of her glittering world. She paid him to be her boyfriend, but his heart broke every time she chased after the boy she truly wanted. When she finally tossed him aside—apartment and all—Noah must decide if he’ll stay her paid shadow or risk everything for a love that won’t leave him behind.
I Chased Him—But He Chased Me Back
I Chased Him—But He Chased Me Back
4.9
She was sent to win his love—but the system never warned her that the real danger was falling for the wrong man. Logan Hayes ruled the city’s social scene and her mission’s fate, but when his jealousy turns toxic, she risks everything to switch targets to Carter Foster—the one man who’s always just out of reach. In a world where affection points decide life or death, her only hope is to chase true love before the game ends. But Carter has secrets of his own, and the truth about their tangled past could destroy them both. When every choice means heartbreak for someone, how do you choose who to save—and who to leave behind? Is love just a number, or is there a way to break the system and rewrite their fate?
He Left Me Ruined, Then Returned
He Left Me Ruined, Then Returned
4.9
I fell for Julian Pierce the summer I turned eighteen—and by the time he left me ruined on my front porch, my world was already crumbling. Ten years later, I’m no longer the golden girl of Maple Heights, but the secret nobody dares mention, forced to survive as a kept woman in a city where dignity costs more than rent. When Julian—now a war hero—returns and crosses my path at the Magnolia Club, old wounds flare in front of the powerful Hamilton family, and I become the target of their wrath. But humiliation is only the beginning. In a world ruled by secrets, betrayal, and debts that can never be repaid, how much must I lose to protect the one person I still love? When your name is only whispered in shame, is there any way to rewrite your story before the final page turns?
Her Mother’s Love Was a Lie
Her Mother’s Love Was a Lie
4.7
Shellie brags about a perfect home and a loving mother, but her frayed clothes and empty lunch tray tell another story. When her secret unravels in a brutal, public betrayal, even her desperate loyalty can't save her from the truth: the only thing more painful than hunger is a mother’s rejection. Now, as her former classmate, I can’t stop chasing the ghost of the girl we all broke, even if it means facing what I did to her.
His Heart Was Never Mine
His Heart Was Never Mine
4.9
Mariah spent years chasing Ethan’s passion, only to realize his devotion belonged to someone else. Now, as she faces a new engagement and Ethan’s world unravels, she must choose between longing for what’s lost and embracing a future she never imagined. Betrayal, heartbreak, and forbidden desire collide in this gripping tale of love and letting go.