Left for the Girl Next Door / Chapter 3: All the Pieces Left Behind
Left for the Girl Next Door

Left for the Girl Next Door

Author: Alexis Martinez


Chapter 3: All the Pieces Left Behind

I sat on the sofa for what felt like hours, watching the afternoon sunlight crawl across the floor. The minutes slid past, thick and heavy.

Eventually, I forced myself to clean up the living room. The coffee table was a minefield: crumpled tissues, a toppled water glass, the TV remote wedged under the couch next to a half-eaten granola bar from our last movie night.

I fished the gift I’d brought back from London out of the trash. The wrapping paper was torn, but not ruined. I’d spent hours scouring Harrods, comparing brands, stumbling through awkward English with sales clerks. Derek hadn’t even looked at it before tossing it aside like a credit card offer.

All that effort—garbage now. My love, my time, all of it reduced to a mess on the floor.

After tidying up, I drifted to the bedroom and started packing. My movements were robotic. This was Derek’s place—his name on the lease, his furniture, his handpicked neighborhood.

But my fingerprints were everywhere: coffee mugs we’d chosen together, matching dinnerware, the "Bless This Mess" sign I’d bought as a joke—he’d actually liked it. The succulents I hadn’t killed, vanilla candles, a blanket we’d fought over during winter storms.

I packed a few clothes and left the rest. Everything else could be replaced. I was done holding onto things that didn’t want me.

At the door, Pudding streaked out—a yellow blur, faster than I’d ever seen her move for me. She sprawled in front of the door, tail flicking, eyes wide as saucers. For once, she didn’t flinch when I reached out—her purr rumbled against my palm, shaky but real.

When I first found her, she was scrawny and dirty, ribs poking through her fur. Now, her coat was glossy, her body filled out, the princess she was always meant to be.

I crouched, stroking her head. She pressed into my hand, purring for the first time in weeks. "I’m leaving. He’ll take care of you now," I whispered, voice cracking. Pudding would finally have her favorite person full-time.

I peeled her claws from my pant leg, her grip leaving tiny snags. Ignoring her plaintive meows, I stepped out with my suitcase. The sound of her crying faded as I moved down the hall, every step heavier than the last.

You may also like

Cheated By the Good Girl Next Door
Cheated By the Good Girl Next Door
4.8
For a year, I believed my girlfriend’s innocent act—no touching, no late nights, just pure love and small-town dreams. Then I found her secret: a married lover, luxury gifts, and a double life hidden behind sweet smiles. Now, armed with proof and a broken heart, I’m ready to expose them both and make them pay for treating me like a joke.
The Girl Across the Window
The Girl Across the Window
5.0
When a lonely science influencer becomes obsessed with the passionate couple across the street, his secret spying spirals into a dangerous game of desire, paranoia, and forbidden truths. As he uncovers their darkest secrets, he realizes he might lose everything—including his own life—if he can’t escape their gaze. One stolen glance could cost him everything.
She Married Me for Revenge, Then I Died
She Married Me for Revenge, Then I Died
4.7
I spent my whole life protecting Natalie—the girl next door I loved and lost to the town’s bad boy. When she shattered my heart with a brutal secret as I died saving her, fate sent me back to senior year, right before everything fell apart. This time, I refuse to be her shield, but breaking free from her—and the past—may cost me everything.
The Serial Killer Left Her in My Motel
The Serial Killer Left Her in My Motel
4.8
When a desperate motel owner lets a masked stranger and his unconscious date rent a room, he thinks it’s just another night—until he realizes he’s harboring a notorious serial killer. With hidden cameras recording every move and a dead girl upstairs, he’s trapped between turning himself in or covering up the crime. But when the killer discovers his secret, one chilling message changes everything: 'You shouldn’t have interfered.'
Traded for His Other Woman
Traded for His Other Woman
4.8
Natalie sacrificed everything for Derek—her college dreams, her father’s memory—only to be betrayed and left to care for his family while he runs off with another girl. When she discovers the truth and reclaims her stolen future, Derek tries to crawl back, but she’s not the same girl he left behind. Now, the one who was always invisible is about to become the storm that upends his perfect life.
Roommates After Dark
Roommates After Dark
4.9
When a steamy hallway encounter forces shy grad student Natalie and her roommate into a secret moment behind closed doors, desire and boundaries blur. As heartbreak and temptation simmer in their cramped California apartment, will Natalie choose loyalty or give in to the chemistry that could change everything? One afternoon could turn their friendship—and futures—upside down.
The Neighbor Next Door: Unleashed
The Neighbor Next Door: Unleashed
4.9
Rachel’s peaceful suburban life unravels when a bold border collie and her infuriatingly handsome new neighbor crash into her world—at home and at work. As dog food disappears, secrets surface, and sparks fly, Rachel must navigate awkward run-ins, office drama, and a decade-old connection that refuses to stay buried. Will she risk her heart again, or let pride keep her from a second chance at love?
Not Yours to Love
Not Yours to Love
4.8
Mariah Jennings has always lived in the shadows—outshined by her perfect neighbor Savannah and obsessed with winning the heart of the untouchable Julian Carter. But as love triangles unravel and old rivalries ignite, Mariah must face the truth about her own desires and what it really means to be chosen. When loyalty, jealousy, and heartbreak collide, will Mariah finally claim her own story—or lose everything to the girl next door?
Blinded by Him, Saved by Another
Blinded by Him, Saved by Another
4.9
He was supposed to be my forever—until he walked in with someone new on my birthday. Blinded by the accident that saved his life, I thought Mason would always be my anchor. But tonight, he shattered our unbreakable promise in front of everyone, leaving me exposed, humiliated, and forced to let go of the only love I’ve ever known. Just as my world collapses, Carter Hayes—the boy next door turned protector—returns, holding out hope, secrets, and maybe something more. When a chance at sight—and a second chance at love—appears, will I risk my heart and trust again, or is some darkness too deep to escape? When loyalty becomes betrayal, who will help me see the truth?
His Practice Girl, Never His Choice
His Practice Girl, Never His Choice
4.7
Natalie gave Derek everything—her heart, her first time, her future—only to overhear him call her a 'warm-up' for the girl he truly wanted. Humiliated and discarded, she swallows her heartbreak and a morning-after pill alone, while Derek flaunts his new romance in front of everyone. With her world shattered, Natalie makes a desperate escape, determined to reclaim her dignity and build a life where Derek’s shadow can never reach her again.
Traded My Car, Lost My Boyfriend
Traded My Car, Lost My Boyfriend
4.7
Rachel gifts her boyfriend a brand-new SUV—only to watch another woman take over the front seat, her space, and even her shoes. Every morning, Maddie rides shotgun while Rachel gets pushed to the back, her presence erased piece by piece. When Rachel finally fights back, she's branded 'crazy' and left in the rain, realizing the car she paid for drove her love straight into someone else's arms.
He Sent Me to Another Man’s Bed
He Sent Me to Another Man’s Bed
5.0
Thrown into a small-town soap opera as a housemaid, she thought she could outlast her doomed engagement and fade into the background. But after falling for her devoted bodyguard, betrayal strikes on the night she finally gives in—sending her straight into her employer’s arms. Now, with her heart shattered and freedom within reach, she must decide: walk away or risk everything for a love built on lies.