My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers / Prologue: The Goddess Next Door
My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers

My Sister’s Smile Was Never Hers

Author: Miguel Shields


Prologue: The Goddess Next Door

Next →

Everyone envied me for having a gentle, beautiful older sister—a real goddess and the top student in school.

In our small, leafy Ohio suburb, neighbors gossiped over white picket fences, and somehow, Summer Lynn’s name always crept into those conversations. Teachers, neighbors, even the barista at Main Street Coffee called her a prodigy, a stunner—like she was plucked right from some Hollywood coming-of-age movie and dropped into our cul-de-sac. To everyone else, she was perfect. To me, she was complicated, sometimes cruel, sometimes the only person who really saw me.

But no one knew that, on those secret, sweltering summer nights, almost all my firsts—my first secrets, my first fears, even my first real heartbreak—belonged to her.

Only the air-conditioning’s low hum and the faded baseball posters on my wall bore witness to the weird, bittersweet territory of those early days—like the first time I let someone hold my hand or whispered a secret I couldn’t trust to anyone else.

In the end, she sneered and said she’d ruin my whole life, not realizing her own had already been ruined by me.

The threat didn’t come with fireworks or family drama. It was more like a cold wind through a half-open window in August—a warning you only feel when it’s too late. By then, the damage was done—only neither of us knew who had hurt whom more.

Next →

You may also like

My Sister, The Genius I Couldn't Outshine
My Sister, The Genius I Couldn't Outshine
4.8
Sibling rivalry was supposed to be a joke—until my little sister stole the spotlight, the love, and even my Spider-Man cards. Growing up as the Mayfield family’s only heir, I was the sunbeam in a mansion of silver spoons and Sunday brunches. But the day Tessa arrived—white-haired, blue-eyed, and fragile as a marshmallow—my world flipped. Suddenly, I was invisible, always one step behind her genius, her sickness, her stubborn devotion to saving vanilla milk for me. I tried everything to win back my family’s love: running away, plotting revenge, hiring a fake dad, even grading my own list of parental crimes. Nothing worked. But when Tessa risked everything to defend my honor, I realized the only person truly rooting for me was the sister I’d called a freak. Can a jealous brother learn to love the sibling he never wanted—or is the family bond already broken for good?
She Stole My Face, I Took Her Life
She Stole My Face, I Took Her Life
4.8
Fame made me a star—betrayal made me a survivor. When my own twin sister stole my face and my life, I had to claw my way back from a brutal accident, a family who wished me gone, and the one man who saw the truth behind every mask. As secrets unravel on the world’s brightest stage, my revenge is as public as my pain—no one escapes the spotlight unscathed. But when the final curtain falls, will I find love, justice, or just a new kind of loneliness? Who am I when the world only knows my sister’s smile?
I Was Never Their Daughter
I Was Never Their Daughter
4.9
I was never their daughter—just her shadow, haunting the halls she left behind. On my eighteenth birthday, all I needed was one real wish: a simple "happy birthday" from the family who never saw me, the husband who only dreamed of her. But in a house where grief tastes sharper than love, even that is too much to ask. My brother would rather I’d died in her place; my parents only remember the sainted Evie, the sister I could never be. As my health fails and the system’s promise fades, I make one desperate wish: let them have their perfect girl back, let them finally see the truth. But when Evelyn’s myth collides with reality, who will they blame—and who will they mourn? If I disappear, will anyone finally see Harper for who she is? Or am I destined to vanish, unloved and unseen, forever a stand-in?
My Fake Sister Stole My Life
My Fake Sister Stole My Life
4.4
She claimed my dad, my friends, and my spotlight—now she’s coming for my life. When my family took in Jenna, she was supposed to be my foster sister. Instead, she charmed her way into my dad’s heart, spread lies at school, and even tried to steal my identity. With rumors swirling and my reputation in shambles, I found myself fighting not just for my family’s trust but for the truth about who really belonged. Allies turned into enemies, and the one person who could clear my name was the quiet girl everyone overlooked. But as secrets unravel and betrayals mount, I have to decide: will exposing Jenna’s lies destroy what’s left of my family, or finally set us free? When the real daughter steps out of the shadows, will I lose everything—or finally reclaim my place at home?
My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
4.9
Sometimes, the person you love most comes back as someone else. When my sister wakes up convinced she's a debutante from another century, my family is thrown into chaos—and I'm the only one who sees the truth behind her haunted eyes. As Lila stumbles through smartphones and SAT prep, I teach her about freedom, love, and the world that should have been hers. But when a car crash swaps our souls across time, I wake up in a past where women are prisoners and my real sister is a ghost. To survive, we must outwit cruel fathers, possessive cousins, and the rules of two different worlds—until a desperate ritual offers one last shot at home. What will we lose to return—and what if the girl we saved is the one we can never let go? When fate gives you a second chance, can you rewrite your own story?
My Sister Wants My Body Back
My Sister Wants My Body Back
4.9
She was supposed to be gone, but every time I looked in the mirror, my dead sister stared back. When Maddie’s body becomes a battleground for her sister Lila’s restless soul, her parents make the unthinkable choice: only one daughter can stay. Betrayed by the family she loves and haunted by the girl she once adored, Maddie fights to hold onto her life—even as everyone around her demands she give it up for the sister who died too soon. But when Chris, the boy she secretly loves, shows up with a desperate plea and a dangerous plan, Maddie realizes nothing is as it seems. How far will she go to keep her own heartbeat? And when the final choice comes, will the girl who wakes up still be Maddie—or the ghost she’s tried so hard to escape?
I Became My Sister to Destroy Her Ex
I Became My Sister to Destroy Her Ex
4.5
Sometimes, it takes a villain to defeat a monster. When my little sister Harper spirals into despair at the hands of her charming, ruthless boyfriend, I’ll do anything to save her—even if it means trading places and facing his cruelty head-on. Now trapped in Harper’s body, I must navigate a world of family power plays, backstabbing colleagues, and a manipulator who wears his mask too well. The stakes? My sister’s sanity, our family’s reputation, and the truth about what really happened to us both. Every move is a gamble as I outwit Chase and his allies, exposing secrets while risking everything. Revenge tastes sweet, but trust is a dangerous currency when even allies might turn. Will justice heal the scars he left—or just open new wounds? When the final mask slips, who will be left standing—and can I bring Harper home before I lose myself for good?
Saint Sister, Scapegoat Life: My Turn Now
Saint Sister, Scapegoat Life: My Turn Now
4.8
My sister wears a saint’s mask, but I’ve lived in her shadow—and suffered every cut she hides. After losing everything to a fire set by her best friend, I fell into debt, depression, and betrayal as Julia spun her web of public sympathy, charity scams, and moral blackmail. Her perfect image cost me my future, my home, and nearly my life, all while she cashed in on my pain and paraded her virtue online. But this time, after being used, shamed, and ruined in the name of family, I’m done playing her scapegoat. With Ethan at my side and every cruel lesson burned into memory, I finally turn her twisted logic against her—forcing Julia to face every consequence she’s ever dodged, from ruined friendships to deadly debts. When the masks fall, will her brand of ‘forgiveness’ save her—or destroy her in the end? How far will a real villain go when the world insists she’s a saint?
I Raised Her—Now She Calls Me Stranger
I Raised Her—Now She Calls Me Stranger
4.9
Sick, alone, and betrayed, Maya Zheng reaches out to her younger sister Wendy—only to be met with cold indifference and a demand for repayment. Years of sacrifice and sibling loyalty unravel as Maya recalls their tumultuous past: a broken home, secrets of parentage, and relentless struggle to protect the sister who would one day turn her back. When Wendy reemerges as the 'heiress' of a shady businessman at a glittering gala, Maya is forced into a public reckoning—exposing old debts, demanding justice, and choosing her own worth over toxic family ties. As fortunes shift and betrayals are laid bare, Maya discovers that sometimes the family you choose is worth more than the one you’re born with. But when Wendy’s world collapses, will Maya finally be free—or haunted by the sister she can’t save? If love isn’t enough, what’s left to hold onto?
She Married My Brother Instead of Me
She Married My Brother Instead of Me
4.8
She vanished on our wedding day—and came back wearing white, walking down the aisle to marry my brother. Five years of searching, heartbreak, and hope have left me a hollow shell, haunted by the ghost of Lillian Monroe—the girl I loved since childhood, the girl who now looks right through me. As my brother basks in his perfect love story, I’m left choking on secrets, scars, and the cruel truth that she’s not mine anymore. But when Lillian moves in—alongside my brother, into the apartment meant to be our home—the wounds I tried to bury rip wide open. Why did she vanish? Why did everyone keep her return a secret? And if love is a choice, why does mine still burn? When the truth behind her disappearance unravels, will I finally get closure—or lose myself all over again?