He Chose My Rival Over Me / Chapter 2: Shadows and Shifts
He Chose My Rival Over Me

He Chose My Rival Over Me

Author: Brian Murphy


Chapter 2: Shadows and Shifts

With the curtain between us, I no fit see Tunde face well. But from him voice—no sorry, no remorse—I fit guess how e dey feel. Still that same cold, distant person, nothing dey shake am.

I hold curtain edge, finger dey tremble small. The fabric dey scratch my palm, but I no fit let go. Even if I try, my heart still dey beat kpokpo-kpokpo, fast and stubborn. Tunde just stand there, one hand for pocket, posture straight like soldier. Only time him voice crack small na when breeze push the curtain, nearly show him shadow. I hold my breath, waiting for sorry, but the words no come.

I used to think I mean something to am. Our papas na padi, we grow together. When we small, both families dey joke say maybe we go marry.

Sometimes I remember those days for Garba Kingdom compound—our parents dey play ayo under mango tree, dey call us “husband and wife.” We go run, hide under table, share suya, laugh like say nothing fit ever change. Even grandmama dey bless us sometimes, say make our friendship last reach old age. I think say na destiny, that two of us go always dey side by side. If person tell me say e go end like this, I for call am liar.

But na when Zainab land for Abuja I understand the difference between who dey close and who be outsider.

That first day Zainab enter, her soft voice and big, watery eyes draw all of us. She dress gentle, even her slippers dey quiet. Suddenly, attention shift; Tunde dey quick answer her question, carry her bag, even fetch water for am. That kind special treatment I never see before. The way she dey thank everybody, you go think na angel drop from sky. I stand for back, feeling like guest inside my own circle.

Tunde, wey no dey allow people near, go follow her reach New Yam Festival, buy her earrings, teach her city etiquette, even worry say her uncle and aunt go treat her bad, so e carry her enter Chief’s compound to care for am.

I remember the New Yam Festival that year—Tunde buy fine coral beads for her, even help fix her gele. The air full of roasted corn and drumming, but all I see na Tunde dey fix her gele. I watch as he whisper city rules to am, showing her how to greet elders and bend small, like proper Abuja girl. When Zainab complain say her uncle dey harsh, na Tunde rush to Chief’s side to beg for her case. All those things, na me dey see dem, but everybody just dey say, "Ah, Tunde na gentleman."

All because Mr. Musa, before he die, beg am to look after him only daughter.

People still dey talk about Mr. Musa’s funeral. Chief’s drummers play all night, goats and chicken full ground. Before the casket close, Mr. Musa grip Tunde hand, whisper long for him ear. Since that day, Tunde no dey joke with Zainab matter. For Garba Kingdom, when elder talk, pikin must obey. Even elders dey nod, say "e good boy." Me, I just dey watch, heart dey pound slow-slow.

For Garba Kingdom, mentor get big respect, so nobody talk bad about Tunde. In fact, people dey hail am as proper gentleman.

Even for palm-wine bar, old men dey raise cup for Tunde. "He get sense," dem go talk. Young girls for church dey eye am, hoping he go notice dem, but he no send. For our place, if you serve mentor well, your name dey ring like church bell. Tunde just dey carry himself with that silent pride, nobody fit question am.

Last harmattan, three of us go church to pray. Dust start blow anyhow. Tunde fear say dust go block road, so e carry the only umbrella, escort Zainab down the hill first. As e be, dust block everywhere, and I wait for church one full day and night before my papa come carry me.

I remember the taste of dry dust that day—how my throat scratch, how I rub my eyes until dem red. The whole congregation dey pray, but my mind dey for the road. I check outside, see Zainab and Tunde dey waka away, umbrella big like shield. I wait, leg pain me, hunger dey catch. By night, as moon rise, only my papa show to carry me go house. For my mind, I know say nobody go ever leave Zainab stranded.

During the palm-wine tasting this March, Zainab mistakenly pluck the hibiscus wey chief’s daughter like pass. Fear catch her, face just pale. Tunde quickly put the flower for my hair, talk say Zainab just come Abuja, no get family, if big people scold am, she fit no fit survive for city. Luckily, chief’s daughter and my mama be friends, so she no vex. Instead, she praise me say I get the spirit of "plucking the flower while e still dey fresh."

That day, my fingers shake as Tunde tuck the flower into my hair. Zainab stand behind, lip quivering. All the elders watch. Na my mama calm everybody, her voice gentle like evening breeze: “Children, hibiscus go grow again, no be problem.” The chief’s daughter nod, squeeze my hand, say I get courage. But my heart just dey heavy, like stone for river bottom.

I no be person wey no get temper. But anytime I vex, Tunde go always talk, “My mentor put Zainab for my hand—I no fit disobey.”

He dey talk am as if na prayer, like wetin pastor dey repeat for altar. Anytime I frown, he go just remind me. Sometimes I wonder, wetin about my own feelings? Shey I no dey this world too? But Tunde go just look me, face blank, and I go swallow all my anger like hot amala.

Those feelings I dey hide go just choke me for throat—bitter, hard to talk. I go just force myself act like big madam, treat Zainab as small sister.

I learn to fake smile, to call her “dear,” to give advice even when I want to shout. Some nights, I go squeeze my pillow, biting back tears. For kitchen, I go serve her first, just to show say I get good heart, because for our family, reputation pass money.

Prayer beads from Christ Redeemer Church, hair ornaments from Mama Kemi’s bukka, calligraphy and painting from respected families—anything she ask, I go give. But both of them just dey take my kindness for granted.

If she like my wrapper, I go give. If she wan learn my song, I go teach. Sometimes, Tunde go drop money for her on my behalf, as if na me send am. My gifts pile up for her room, but small thank you never reach my ear. I dey wonder if na because dem see me finish, or because Tunde always dey her side, dey shield am.

That day for polo field, Zainab sabi say the prize na my aunt’s keepsake, yet she still beg me to win am for her. I refuse, and she come dey look like say I bully her. People around me dey tell me make I let her have am, say she be orphan. Tunde too look me one kind, as if I no get good heart. When he see say I no gree, he just enter field by himself, determined to win the hairpin for Zainab.

I grip my mallet tight, knuckles white. The crowd dey whisper, some dey point. "Give am now!" one aunty shout, but I stand my ground. When Tunde waka pass me, his eyes sharp, jaw set like stone. In that moment, I see say e no dey on my side at all. E just dey play his role for Zainab sake. I feel alone inside crowd of hundreds. My leg still dey pain from before, but na my heart dey bleed pass.

As the pain hit me for leg, everything clear for my eye. Na Tunde Mr. Musa beg, not me. Why I go put my head for wahala?

When my leg swell, I drag myself off the field. I tell myself, "You don try." No more pretending, no more fighting for wetin no be my own. I watch as Tunde hand the prize to Zainab, her face shine like new kobo on market day. For my heart, I close one chapter and lock am, key thrown away like old charm.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

He Chose My Sister, Not Me
He Chose My Sister, Not Me
4.8
In my last life, I was the prince’s cherished consort, but this time, he picked my younger sister and left me behind. Three years of waiting, only to watch my dreams handed to someone else—my own blood. Now, forced to marry a stranger and kneel at the palace gate, I must swallow my heartbreak while the man who once promised me forever pretends not to remember our love.
He Chose My Rival as His Wife
He Chose My Rival as His Wife
4.9
After seven years of sacrifice, Morayo’s husband betrays her by bringing his childhood lover into their home as a lesson teacher—then crowns her the new wife. Even her own children turn against her, blinded by the rival’s sweet words. Humiliated and heartbroken, Morayo faces the shame of divorce and losing everything she built, but she must choose: hold on and be destroyed, or walk away and reclaim her dignity, no matter the gossip that will follow her name.
He Chose Her Over Me at My Bestie’s Wedding
He Chose Her Over Me at My Bestie’s Wedding
4.8
Eight years of love, and Kunle still called me 'childhood friend' in front of everyone, just to shine for a new babe. Humiliation burn me as he blocked me, shamed me, and carried Aisha out of the wedding like I never existed. But when I caught them together in my hotel suite, I knew my own chapter with Kunle was over—will I ever find love that values me?
She Chose My Rival on My Birthday
She Chose My Rival on My Birthday
4.9
Ifeoma was my whole world, but in Awka's red-dust government school, even love dey get enemies. When my classmates and teachers decide say I no deserve her, dem push me to the shadows and hand her to my rival—on the very day I thought they’d all celebrate me. My mama’s tears and my own shame become the only gift I collect, while Ifeoma’s smile now belong to another—right in front of the whole school.
My Husband Chose My Rival
My Husband Chose My Rival
4.9
Aisha, born into royalty and heartbreak, faces betrayal when her powerful fiancé, General Tunde, replaces her with a cunning rival. Forced to choose between dignity and tradition, Aisha must fight for her worth as secrets, gossip, and heartbreak threaten to consume her. Will she rise above or let heartbreak define her fate?
My Boyfriend Chose My Best Friend
My Boyfriend Chose My Best Friend
5.0
Chinaza's world turns upside down when her childhood sweetheart, Chijioke, lets another girl come between them. Caught between loyalty, jealousy, and heartbreak, she must decide if love is worth the pain or if it's time to walk away forever. Will her heart survive this betrayal, or will she find the courage to move on?
He Chose My Shadow Over Me
He Chose My Shadow Over Me
4.8
When Amaka catches her husband Ireti kissing his assistant, her world shatters. Betrayed, humiliated, and battling sickness, she spirals into darkness as the man she sacrificed everything for chooses another—her cheerful rival from the past. On the brink of death, Amaka must decide: will she let heartbreak swallow her, or will she reclaim her light and expose the lies that stole her life?
My Babe Chose Her Bros Over Me
My Babe Chose Her Bros Over Me
4.7
Obinna gave up everything to build a life with Yan Yan, but her loyalty to her 'bros' always comes first—even if it means spending the night with another man. Now, after she gifts her best friend a game with Obinna's own money, he's ready to teach her a bitter lesson about jealousy and respect. When Obinna brings his own female 'bro' into the mix, Yan Yan finally tastes the heartbreak she dished out—but will pride destroy their love forever?
He Chose His Boys Over Me
He Chose His Boys Over Me
4.8
After years of silent wars and public humiliation, Simi finally breaks the cycle—choosing her pride over begging Tobi again. But as her breakup post goes viral, Tobi’s boys line up to claim her, and even his sworn enemy Sani throws his hat in the ring. In Lagos, love is war, but this time, Simi is fighting for herself.
Rejected by the Prince, Chosen by Fate
Rejected by the Prince, Chosen by Fate
4.8
When Femi’s royal blood is revealed, he casts me aside for his palace fiancée, telling me our village marriage ‘no count’ before the Oba. They want me as a spare wife, but I refuse to kneel for anyone’s happiness but my own. With my father’s border pass clenched in my palm, I choose freedom over shame—let them keep their palace, I will carve my destiny across the frontier.
I Let the Fine Boy Ruin Me
I Let the Fine Boy Ruin Me
4.8
I gave up my future, my first position, and even my dignity for Sani—the boy every girl in school wanted. But when the truth about his bet with Amina came out, I realized I was just a pawn in their wicked game. Now, with my UI admission letter in hand, I must choose: revenge, or freedom from all their drama—before love finally destroys me.
She Chose Her Ex Over Our Wedding
She Chose Her Ex Over Our Wedding
4.9
I thought I was planning my dream wedding, but my bride-to-be was secretly rekindling old flames with her ex behind my back. Every sweet word, every midnight call, and every coded Facebook post was a lie—her heart was never truly mine. In Lagos, love is a battlefield, and I just discovered I’m fighting alone.