She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob / Chapter 7: Barbecue Bars and Peanut Wisdom
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob

She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob

Author: Michele Moran


Chapter 7: Barbecue Bars and Peanut Wisdom

One night, my girlfriend came home late from a real company dinner. She even FaceTimed me to prove it.

I messaged the guy on Facebook (he’d asked for my number, but I never gave it—always contacted him through Messenger).

I casually asked about investment-type insurance, if it was worth it. He sent a long-winded reply, analyzing pros and cons. I didn’t read a word.

After about ten minutes, I messaged him again.

I said, "Even though I’m married, I still can’t let go of you. After we met again, those old feelings came back. Maybe life is just too bland now, the thrill is tempting, but I don’t want to betray my wife."

He replied with a question mark. I immediately deleted the message, then sent a voice note.

"Dude, sorry, wrong person."

He said it was fine, he didn’t even look at it closely.

I called him on Messenger, asked if he was free to grab some barbecue, said I wasn’t in a good mood and wanted to talk.

He agreed right away. "Man, no problem."

The reason I dared meet him was because, judging from their chat history, he really didn’t know my girlfriend had a boyfriend. She told him she’d broken up with her short-term boyfriend after New Year’s.

Eating my food, living at my place, spending my money on beauty treatments, driving my car to party with her girlfriends, but acting single in front of her old flame.

Impressive.

We met at a hole-in-the-wall sports bar, the kind with sticky floors and faded Bud Light posters. I drove to pick him up. First thing he said when he got in: "Man, I’ve never seen you post this car on your Facebook."

I just smiled and didn’t answer.

That’s the vibe I wanted—someone who doesn’t care about material things.

He kept chatting, saying, "You rich people are all like this, switching between cars. Must be nice."

Maybe because I invited him out, he felt flattered and did most of the talking. I just played along.

Outside, the streetlights flickered as we cruised past strip malls and boarded-up diners, the kind of places you only notice when you’re driving slow. He talked on and on, while I kept my jaw tight and nodded at all the right places. The smell of barbecue sauce clung to my clothes, sharp and sweet, making my stomach churn.

While drinking, I deliberately acted depressed, explaining the message I sent earlier was meant for my ex.

Then I asked, "Man, what do you think I should do? I really can’t let go."

He chuckled, "Buddy, I get it. It’s normal for guys. But you have a wife and kids now, just make sure your wife doesn’t find out."

I asked, "Be honest, if you were me, what would you do?"

He’d had five or six beers by then, probably a little tipsy, and finally spilled everything.

He said, "Dude, to be honest, I’ve been in the same boat."

Then he started pouring it all out.

He said he was engaged, but at the class reunion he saw the class beauty—now even more gorgeous, totally irresistible. After the reunion, they went to a hotel nearby.

Hearing this, I was disgusted, but kept a straight face and let him talk.

He said he felt guilty towards his fiancée, but the class beauty wouldn’t let go, kept asking him out. In the end, he had to lie to his fiancée about a business trip and went out of town with the class beauty for two days. Now she’s obsessed, keeps asking him to break up with his fiancée, but he doesn’t really want to.

I said, "Then why not seriously consider being with the class beauty?"

He said, "Man, the thrill is tempting, but it’s like this bowl of peanuts—good for snacking, but you can’t live on peanuts instead of steak."

Yeah, peanuts are fine for snacking, but you don’t steal them off someone else’s plate.

A hollow laugh slipped out of me before I could stop it. If only he knew who he was talking to. The irony stung, more bitter than the warm beer in my hand. The bar TVs flickered with baseball highlights, but I couldn’t focus on anything but the swirl of his words.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

He Posted Her, Then Begged for Me
He Posted Her, Then Begged for Me
4.6
After two years chasing the campus heartthrob, Emily is humiliated when he goes Insta-official with another girl—then blames her when she finally walks away. Labeled a homewrecker and iced out by her classmates, Emily’s only escape is to leave the country, but now he’s desperate to stop her. Will she choose her own freedom, or let his last-minute regret pull her back into heartbreak?
The Heartthrob Called Me Gross
The Heartthrob Called Me Gross
4.8
Emily Carter has always been the invisible 'big girl'—until her secret crush, Jason, humiliates her in front of the whole school. Betrayed by her first love and shunned by everyone, Emily is left broken—until a mysterious transfer student chooses her as his only friend. But as graduation nears, secrets unravel, and Emily must decide if she’ll keep hiding—or finally take the spotlight that’s always been denied her.
Her Heart Belongs to Another
Her Heart Belongs to Another
4.7
Alex finally wins the campus ice queen—only to discover, in bed, that her body and soul are locked for someone else. As cruel online rumors swirl and her true feelings for her childhood protector ignite, Alex is forced to play the villain in a love story he can never win. When betrayal, heartbreak, and desire collide on one stormy night, he must decide: fight for a girl who was never his, or walk away shattered forever.
Dumped After Sleeping With the Genius
Dumped After Sleeping With the Genius
4.6
After two years of chasing campus heartthrob Caleb, Natalie finally wins his heart—and his bed—only to be humiliated at a party when he refuses her kiss and protects another girl. When the dare game turns savage, Natalie storms out with another guy, sending shockwaves through the gossip mill and breaking up with Caleb before he can break her. But as Caleb chases after her, desperate to explain, Natalie realizes this is her chance to walk away before she loses herself completely.
Cheated By My Bride, Betrayed By Her Professor
Cheated By My Bride, Betrayed By Her Professor
4.8
Five years together, and I thought I knew her—until I found her secret burner account and uncovered the truth: my fiancée was having an affair with her married professor, thirty years her senior. Every late night, every excuse, every lie—while I played the perfect boyfriend, they laughed behind my back. Now, armed with proof and a burning need for revenge, I’m about to expose them all—no one in her family or his will see it coming.
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
4.8
When I defend a classmate from public humiliation, she turns her gratitude toward my boyfriend—and then invades every corner of our lives. Betrayed and blindsided, I fight to keep my love and dignity as a cunning rival spins a web of lies and sabotage. With my relationship and reputation at stake, I must decide: stand my ground or lose everything to the girl I tried to save.
Dumped by the Campus King
Dumped by the Campus King
4.9
Maddie’s secret online breakup shatters her carefully guarded world when she realizes her virtual boyfriend might be the college heartthrob she’s always avoided. As past choices unravel, she’s pulled into a dangerous, passionate collision with Caleb—a boy who won’t let go of heartbreak, or her. Now, her secret isn’t just out; it might destroy them both.
Chasing My Crush’s Cold Heart
Chasing My Crush’s Cold Heart
4.7
Aubrey’s relentless, cringe-worthy pursuit of her high school crush Carter goes viral when their chat logs leak on campus. Humiliated but undeterred, she fights for his affection—only to be haunted by his secrets, his silence, and a rival girl from his past. Will she ever break through his icy walls, or is she setting herself up for heartbreak?
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl
4.7
Rachel always played the part of the cold, perfect student—never the main character, always the villain in someone else’s story. But when the new transfer heartthrob declares he came for her, the entire school—and her so-called childhood friend—turn on her, hungry for drama. Now she’s caught in a viral love triangle, hated by the heroine, hunted by jealous rivals, and forced to choose: play the villain, or finally take the lead.
Cheated By the Good Girl Next Door
Cheated By the Good Girl Next Door
4.8
For a year, I believed my girlfriend’s innocent act—no touching, no late nights, just pure love and small-town dreams. Then I found her secret: a married lover, luxury gifts, and a double life hidden behind sweet smiles. Now, armed with proof and a broken heart, I’m ready to expose them both and make them pay for treating me like a joke.
He Kissed Me—Then Changed the Script
He Kissed Me—Then Changed the Script
4.9
Love shouldn’t hurt—unless you’re the supporting girl in someone else’s story. Emmy always did what she was told: ace her classes, keep her head down, and never, ever get close to Lincoln High’s infamous bad boy, Hunter Cross. But when a viral comment stream starts bleeding into her reality, Emmy stumbles into a world where every move is watched, every heartbreak is broadcast, and every choice could rewrite the script. Caught between a possessive rebel with scars deeper than his fists and a golden boy with secrets of his own, Emmy must fight for her future—and her heart—before she’s erased for good. What if the only way to win is to break every rule she’s ever known? And when the script falls apart, who will she be when the spotlight finally finds her?
Engaged to the Enemy, Obsessed with Him
Engaged to the Enemy, Obsessed with Him
4.7
Natalie is trapped in a fake engagement to New York’s cockiest heir, forced to play the perfect couple while her heart aches for Derek—the tattooed, gentle piercer who sees through every lie. Every stolen glance risks scandal, but Natalie can’t stop craving the danger of loving someone forbidden. When family secrets threaten Derek’s safety and her own feelings become impossible to hide, she must choose: betray her family, or lose the only man who truly knows her.