She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge / Chapter 3: Betrayal in Broad Daylight
She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge

She Stole My Life—Now I Want Revenge

Author: Alicia Newton


Chapter 3: Betrayal in Broad Daylight

He said it like it was obvious, like my whole life was just a footnote in Savannah's story. My jaw clenched.

She brightened, then pretended to be annoyed and gave Tyler a playful smack.

She gave him a half-hearted smack on the arm, then giggled, her tears forgotten. "You're not allowed to talk about Mariah like that." Like flipping a switch.

I couldn't stand watching them flirt anymore. Pulled back from the doorway, cold.

It was like watching a bad high school drama play out in real time. I rolled my eyes and slipped away, biting back a bitter laugh.

So this is the standard response, huh?

Just keep comforting her. Keep pleasing her. No matter what the future holds.

Nobody ever got better by babying an injury like that. You have to keep practicing until it doesn't hurt anymore—that's the only way your wrist will adapt.

Coach always said, "Pain is just weakness leaving the body." I used to believe it. Still do, honestly. No shortcut. Never has been.

If you give up halfway, you'll just have to start over from scratch. Simple as that.

You'd think they'd get that by now. But some people always want the easy way out.

Tyler's all about strategy. Technique. He doesn't get the grind.

He'd rather watch tapes and talk theory than spend hours sweating on the strip. It's no wonder he and Savannah got along so well.

After I was kicked off, Tyler took my spot. Made sure Savannah was always in the spotlight. I had no way back.

He worked the system, charmed the coaches, made sure Savannah was always in the spotlight. I was just a name on a list, easy to erase. Forgotten.

One sentence. That's all it took. They took it for granted that I should be their stepping stone, paving the way for Savannah's success.

It was like I existed only to make her look good. The realization burned, deep and sharp.

Hatred boiled inside me. Hot, bitter, choking.

I felt it rise, hot and bitter, threatening to spill over. I clenched my fists until my knuckles ached.

Everyone who hurt and tormented me in my past life—I will pay them back, one by one.

This time, I swore, nobody was going to walk all over me. Not Savannah. Not Tyler. Not anyone.

My fingers found the silver locket at my chest.

The chain was cool against my skin, the locket's weight strangely comforting. It was the only thing I had left from those days—a secret I kept even from myself. Funny, the things you hold onto.

It was a hidden keepsake I had found by chance in the old library archives. Even though I'd set a secret code on it, I could only use the hidden compartment outside—the inheritance vault inside was off-limits.

I remember the day I found it, tucked behind a stack of dusty yearbooks. It felt like fate. But no matter what I tried, the inner vault stayed sealed, just out of reach.

I entered the secret space and dove into the spring-fed pool. The cold water battered me, but I could feel my strength growing.

The water was icy, shocking my system awake. Every nerve felt raw, alive. I gritted my teeth, pushing through the pain.

The pain nearly made me faint, but I gritted my teeth and endured it, feeling energy flood into me—more than ever before.

I could feel something shifting inside me—like old wounds knitting together, muscles growing denser, stronger. It was agony and ecstasy all at once.

In my previous life, I listened to the merman and only drank a sip of the spring water each day. It improved my health, but it wasn't enough to truly transform me—my skills crawled.

I always played it safe, afraid of what might happen if I pushed too far. But not this time. I wanted more. I needed more.

After leaving the space, I secluded myself for another half a month. Only when I felt stable did I leave my room.

The days blurred together—training, eating, sleeping, repeating. By the time I emerged, I barely recognized myself in the mirror. Stronger. Sharper. Ready.

I tossed three stones in succession into the deep pond behind the field, sending ripples across the surface. A blue-tailed merman emerged. Showtime.

The pond was hidden behind the old baseball diamond, overgrown with reeds. When the stones hit the water, the surface shimmered, and he appeared—otherworldly, beautiful, dangerous.

He was breathtakingly beautiful. Impatience burned in his eyes.

His hair glimmered like wet silver, his eyes an impossible shade of blue. But his mouth was set in a hard line, his gaze sharp.

The merman swam quickly to my side, swinging his massive tail, and demanded, his voice low:

"Mariah, are you trying to kill me? You haven't brought me medicine in so long!"

You may also like

She Stole My Name, I Stole My Life
She Stole My Name, I Stole My Life
4.9
I survived two years in hell, only to come home and find a stranger living my life—wearing my name, holding my husband’s arm, and smiling for the cameras. As my scars became headlines and the world demanded answers, every secret unraveled: betrayal by my best friend, a marriage built on lies, and a town desperate for a hero or a villain. With my past erased and my future uncertain, I fought to reclaim my truth—even as the man I trusted most turned out to be my greatest enemy. In the glare of the spotlight, only one woman can claim the name Savannah Callahan. But who will survive when the masks fall away—and what is left when vengeance finally tastes like victory?
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.
He Stole My Life for the Intern
He Stole My Life for the Intern
4.8
Eight years with Derek ended in a single, silent breakup—only for me to discover he’d traded me for Aubrey, the intern I once mentored and called friend. Humiliated, pregnant, and stripped of my promotion by their betrayal, I’m forced to watch them flaunt their happiness while I’m left with nothing. But when you lose everything, there’s nothing left to fear—except what I’ll do next.
She Stole My House, I Stole Her Future
She Stole My House, I Stole Her Future
4.8
After sacrificing everything to buy his fiancée her dream home, Jason is blindsided when Natalie dumps him the second the contract is signed—leaving him broke and betrayed. But what she doesn’t know is, Jason has every receipt and a secret plan for revenge. When love is a transaction, payback comes with interest.
Stand-In Stole My Life
Stand-In Stole My Life
4.7
Sent to wed an enemy leader at fifteen, Natalie returns five years later to find a stand-in living her life—her parents stolen, her future hijacked, and her first love in someone else’s arms. Poisoned, betrayed, and reborn in a time loop, she seizes power in a cutthroat capital, determined to expose the impostor who tried to erase her. If she plays her cards right, she’ll rewrite the past—and make everyone who used her choke on their own lies.
The Villainess Faked Her Death—Now They Want Revenge
The Villainess Faked Her Death—Now They Want Revenge
4.7
Three years after faking her death, notorious villain Natalie Foster is dragged back into the deadly game she thought she’d escaped. Her ex-stepbrother, ex-fiancé, and the woman whose life she ruined have all returned, knives drawn and old grudges burning. With no system left to save her, Natalie must face the sins of her past—knowing everyone she once betrayed now wants her to pay, and the real story is just beginning.
She Married Me for Revenge, Then I Died
She Married Me for Revenge, Then I Died
4.7
I spent my whole life protecting Natalie—the girl next door I loved and lost to the town’s bad boy. When she shattered my heart with a brutal secret as I died saving her, fate sent me back to senior year, right before everything fell apart. This time, I refuse to be her shield, but breaking free from her—and the past—may cost me everything.
He Sabotaged Me—Now I’m His Nightmare
He Sabotaged Me—Now I’m His Nightmare
5.0
Death wasn’t the end—it was my second shot at freedom. After years of letting Dylan, my controlling boyfriend, sabotage my dreams and erase my ambition, I wake up back at the moment everything went wrong: my college application. With memories of betrayal burning in my chest, I vow to flip the script. But Dylan’s charm hides a toxic core, and every sweet word is a trap meant to keep me small. This time, I’ll use his own game against him—turning old scars into new strength, and every manipulation into a stepping stone out of his grasp. Can I break free from the chains of my past, or will Dylan’s lies pull me back under? When revenge is the only way forward, how far will I go to reclaim my future?
Reborn to Ruin the Golden Girl
Reborn to Ruin the Golden Girl
4.7
Natalie destroyed my life, then watched as the world cheered her on. Now I've woken up in my old body, seconds before her cruel trap—and this time, I'm not here to play victim. The rich and powerful wrote the rules, but I’ll make them bleed for every lie, even if it turns me into the monster they always claimed I was.
Reborn to Ruin the Campus Queen
Reborn to Ruin the Campus Queen
4.7
Natalie destroyed my life with lies and turned the whole campus against me—until her drama got me killed. Now I’m back from the dead, and I won’t let her fake innocence turn me into the villain again. This time, I’ll expose her secrets before she ruins me a second time.
Stolen by My Ex’s Fiancée
Stolen by My Ex’s Fiancée
5.0
Natalie Carter clawed her way to the top—until her secret lover vanished, her rival stole her life's work, and betrayal left her with nothing. Now, Natalie is fighting to reclaim her dreams in a world of ruthless ambition, scandal, and forbidden desire. When Derek reappears with a new fiancée and old secrets, Natalie faces the ultimate test: surrender, or risk everything for revenge—and a second chance at love.
Her Words, Their Lies: Heiress in Hiding
Her Words, Their Lies: Heiress in Hiding
4.8
Betrayed by her boyfriend and best friend, framed for plagiarism, and hounded by vicious online mobs, Natalie Porter’s world crumbled in a single night. But when her enemies think she’s lost everything, Natalie erases her author identity and returns to her billionaire mother’s estate—ready to watch the thieves flounder without her genius. With revenge simmering and the truth poised to explode, can the real heiress reclaim her name and destroy the ones who stole her story?