The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl / Chapter 1: The Confession Heard 'Round the School
The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl

The Main Guy Chose the Wrong Girl

Author: Amy Cannon


Chapter 1: The Confession Heard 'Round the School

Next →

It happened between the second bell and the cafeteria stampede, when life should've been predictable. The day my childhood friend Derek Mason confessed to me, my whole world tilted sideways like someone had yanked the floor out from under my sneakers.

Even before my brain caught up with the shock on my face, I could almost hear the digital chorus—phones buzzing in lockers, notifications popping like popcorn across Maple Heights. It was that instant, viral group chat hysteria, the kind that happens after prom night drama or a homecoming proposal gone wrong. The noise was everywhere, a static hum of cafeteria gossip on full blast.

[Honestly, I ship these two way more than the main couple who never talk.]

[It’s all staged—remember, the supporting guy is only confessing to the supporting girl to help the main girl get valedictorian.]

[Supporting girl, just say yes already! The redemption arc later is so good!]

It was like my life was a TV show, and everyone had popcorn but me. But a redemption arc only works if there’s love to begin with.

And I don’t like Derek Mason.

1

Derek, basketball in hand, cornered me in the hallway. His usually handsome face was tinged with rare shyness.

He was still in his Maple Heights Mustangs jersey, sweat glistening at his hairline. For a second, he looked almost nervous—like the cocky point guard suddenly stuck at the free throw line with everyone watching.

“Rachel Foster, I like you.”

It was right after gym, so the hallway was packed. The scent of old gym floors, wet sneakers, and someone’s leftover Axe body spray clung to the air. Someone elbowed my backpack, and Derek’s words dropped like a brick in a pond, rippling through the crowd.

[Popular jock and cold-faced top student? What kind of childhood sweethearts teen drama is this?]

[See? I always thought there was something going on between Rachel and Derek.]

A couple of cheerleaders paused mid-sentence to stare. Some cross-country guy almost tripped on his own shoelaces. The whispers swirled around me, making my head spin.

What’s Derek up to now?

Not long ago, he said he liked the new transfer student, Lily Brooks, and was planning to ask her out.

I could practically see his half-cocky grin, the way he’d joked with his friends about which flowers to bring—lilies, obviously, because he thought he was being clever. Now there was a thin sheen of sweat on his forehead—was it nerves or something else?

Before I could react, the group chat comments started again.

[Even while confessing to someone else, he can’t help but sneak glances at the main girl?]

[Derek, you rascal, don’t love so hard.]

[Main girl, don’t be sad. Derek is only confessing to Rachel to help you get valedictorian.]

Following Derek’s not-so-subtle gaze, I caught a flicker of gloom in Lily’s eyes. She quickly swapped it for her usual gentle face the second she noticed me looking.

She tucked a strand of hair behind her ear and forced a smile so perfect it could’ve been for the yearbook. “Wow, you two? That’s... unexpected. But hey, you do you, Rachel.”

For a split second, I wondered if she actually meant it, or if I was just the villain in someone else’s story.

Me: “……”

What do you mean, a perfect match?

My mind scrambled for an answer, but my body was already moving. I took two steps back, dodging Derek’s hand as he reached for me. His fingers brushed my sleeve and I jerked away, heart racing like I’d just missed a step on the stairs.

“Derek.”

I let out a breath. “Seriously, Derek? Finals are next week and you’re pulling this now? Priorities, man.”

My voice sounded steadier than I felt, echoing off the lockers. I skirted around him and headed back to class. Derek just stood there, looking dejected—like a big dog left behind at the shelter.

A freshman, trying not to stare, whispered, “Harsh.”

The group chat leapt to his defense.

[I knew the so-called ‘mean’ supporting girl wasn’t simple. Could it be she likes the main guy too?]

……

I slowed my steps, puzzled.

So, who exactly is the main guy?

Next →

You may also like

He Was Meant for Her—He Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—He Chose Me
5.0
What if you were just a side character—until the main guy fell for you? Savannah Reed is the notorious 'mean girl' sidekick, tasked with delivering love letters for a time-hopping girl desperate to fix a broken romance script. But when Carter, her childhood friend turned brooding main lead, confesses with a single look, Savannah’s world cracks open: secret photos, drunken birthday wishes, and a love so fierce it might just break the rules of reality. As the author of their universe intervenes and a ruthless app threatens to erase everything, Savannah must choose—play her role or fight for a love that was never meant to exist. If destiny is just a script, can real love rewrite the ending?
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
5.0
He was supposed to fall for someone else. I was supposed to be the villain—until fate, a stubborn transmigrator, and a broken story system rewrote our lines. When I deliver a love letter for the third time to Carter Hayes, the boy I grew up with (and maybe secretly loved), I spark a confession that upends everything: Carter likes me, not the 'main girl.' But our world isn’t real—it's a story fighting to snap back into place, and every choice risks erasing us for good. As mysterious tasks, forbidden kisses, and heart-stopping resets threaten to tear us apart, I have to ask: Can love survive when the universe demands we play our roles? Or will the villain finally get her happily ever after—no matter what the script says?
Mistress of the Main Guy
Mistress of the Main Guy
4.9
Aubrey knows she’s just the side chick in Mason’s story—his real love is destined to return. But the thrill of forbidden nights, online gossip, and the rush of being the villain make it impossible for her to let go. When Mason’s old flame comes back to reclaim him, Aubrey must decide if she’s willing to be discarded—or if she’ll rewrite the ending herself.
He Chose My Half-Sister as His Bride
He Chose My Half-Sister as His Bride
4.7
Morgan’s engagement to Evan shatters when he humiliates her and demands her perfect half-sister as his real wife. Betrayed and branded as 'damaged goods,' Morgan is exiled to the South, forced to rebuild her life while her childhood love claims her sister. But Evan isn’t done with her—and now, Morgan must decide: will she remain his discarded side piece, or fight for her own worth, no matter the cost?
Dumped for Defying the Main Character
Dumped for Defying the Main Character
4.6
Hailey thought she was just getting her nails done, but one scam and a boyfriend's betrayal later, she's the villain in someone else's love story. When Jason sides with the scheming nail tech and threatens to dump her if she doesn't pay up, Hailey finally snaps—and calls the cops. But after years of being the sidekick, she's done playing nice; this time, she'll write her own ending, no matter who gets hurt.
He Chose Her After I Slapped Him
He Chose Her After I Slapped Him
4.6
After five years together, Rachel’s world shatters when her boyfriend Jason drifts away—and a single slap destroys his last shred of love for her. Now, as Jason turns to the perfect new woman and Rachel is branded the 'jealous supporting character,' she must watch her memories become someone else’s future. But when her heartbreak is broadcast like a reality show, will Rachel find the strength to reclaim her own story—or will she always be the girl he left behind?
His Practice Girl, Never His Choice
His Practice Girl, Never His Choice
4.7
Natalie gave Derek everything—her heart, her first time, her future—only to overhear him call her a 'warm-up' for the girl he truly wanted. Humiliated and discarded, she swallows her heartbreak and a morning-after pill alone, while Derek flaunts his new romance in front of everyone. With her world shattered, Natalie makes a desperate escape, determined to reclaim her dignity and build a life where Derek’s shadow can never reach her again.
Her Best Friend Wants My Girl
Her Best Friend Wants My Girl
4.9
When Alex finds a box of condoms in his girlfriend’s clothes—ones he can’t even use—he realizes he’s losing her to her lifelong best friend. As old wounds and jealousies erupt, Alex is forced to fight for Natalie while the world (and her heart) roots for someone else. Will he step aside, or finally claim center stage in the drama of their love triangle?
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
4.9
I always thought being a succubus in college would make my love life easy—until my childhood friend ghosted me for the campus queen on Valentine’s Day. Now, with the universe streaming my every move like a reality show—complete with savage floating comments—I’m stuck between Mason’s mixed signals and his brooding roommate Caleb, who’s way more than just a background character. As old hookups lose their spark and new desires heat up, I’m forced to choose: chase what’s familiar, or risk everything on the guy who sees through my every act? When the comments demand drama and the past won’t let go, can I rewrite my own story—or will I just become the villain in someone else’s feed?
Kept by the Villain, Cast Aside by Fate
Kept by the Villain, Cast Aside by Fate
4.8
I’m the disposable rich girl—destined to be a side character, never the heroine. But when I pay the campus outcast to fake-date me, I discover he’s the secret villain the system wants me to fear…and the only one who ever truly sees me. As my family crumbles and the main couple’s love story devours my future, I must choose: betray my role, or risk everything for the boy I was supposed to ruin.
I Was Never the Heroine Here
I Was Never the Heroine Here
4.9
I thought sharing the heroine’s name meant I’d get the happy ending—but waking up in a romance novel doesn’t guarantee a love story. For two years, I chased Carter Hayes, convinced fate owed me the spotlight, only to find out I was just a stand-in for the real star. When a new girl with my almost-name steps into my world, the truth shatters everything: I was never the protagonist. As betrayal, jealousy, and heartbreak swirl, Carter’s touch turns desperate and his love grows dangerous—forcing me to choose between running away or risking everything for a role I never truly owned. If you woke up in someone else’s story, how far would you go to rewrite the ending? Or is some heartbreak written in the stars?
Her Bros or Her Boyfriend: Choose Me or Him
Her Bros or Her Boyfriend: Choose Me or Him
4.6
Natalie swears her late nights with the guys are harmless, but every hug, every secret gift, drives Caleb to the edge. When he brings home a gorgeous new female 'bro,' Natalie finally tastes her own medicine—and can't handle the sting. As jealousy and betrayal ignite, Caleb must decide: fight for the girl who keeps breaking his heart, or walk away for good?