The Ordinary One Was the Killer / Chapter 1: The Bottom of the Class
The Ordinary One Was the Killer

The Ordinary One Was the Killer

Author: Noah Keller


Chapter 1: The Bottom of the Class

Next →

Twenty years ago, I was just a regular kid growing up in a working-class Arizona suburb when I got pulled out of my regular math class and dropped into the advanced program—just like that. No warning, no preparation. Just a new classroom full of strangers who spoke in equations.

Everyone in that class was a genius—no exaggeration. They solved puzzles I’d never even heard of, built robots for MIT competitions, and wrote code in languages I couldn’t pronounce. I was still stuck on science fair volcanoes while they were arguing about quantum mechanics.

Every test, my name was at the bottom in red ink. The guidance counselor would give me that tight smile, like she felt sorry for me. No matter how hard I tried, I was the benchmark—the line everyone else had long since crossed. I started to feel like my only job was to make everyone else look smarter.

But last year, something changed. My old classmates from the gifted class started dying—mysteriously, one after another. The stories made the local news, but never got picked up nationally. It was like someone wanted to keep it quiet.

He showed up at the hospital, badge flashing under the harsh fluorescent lights, asking for me by name. That’s when Detective Derek from the Flagstaff Police Department came looking for me.

Now the cops think the only ordinary one—the one who never fit in—is the killer. If that’s not irony, I don’t know what is.

Next →

You may also like

I Grew Up Spoiled—He Made Me Transform
I Grew Up Spoiled—He Made Me Transform
4.9
They called me the Queen of the Skies before I could even fly—destined for greatness, smothered by small-town gossip, and spoiled by everyone but myself. For years, I stayed awkward and ordinary, the center of every birthday wish and family scheme—until my cousins turned rivals, and I was sent to live with the legendary (and infuriatingly handsome) Carter. At his mysterious estate, a single clumsy accident changed everything: my feathers, my fate, and the one man I never expected to fall for. But when a prophecy brands me a lucky star, old enemies and family ambitions threaten to tear us apart—and Carter himself pushes me toward a marriage I never wanted. Can I claim my own destiny and the heart I truly desire, or will the weight of legend crush my chance at love? When lightning strikes, will I rise at last—or lose everything to the storm?
No One Came to Save Us
No One Came to Save Us
5.0
When the world watched in horror, ordinary heroes tried to stand between innocence and terror. But with every desperate plea and shattered hope, the line between courage and helplessness blurred. As lives hung in the balance, one woman’s resolve—and one nation’s failure—would change everything.
I Loved the Boy Behind the Headlines
I Loved the Boy Behind the Headlines
4.9
Some love stories get a second chance, but not every heart can survive the spotlight. Harper Lane wakes in her high school body after a tragic end to her marriage with Mason Hale—now the nation's favorite golden boy and her greatest regret. Determined to rewrite her fate, Harper dodges Mason’s affections and the cruel glare of fame, pouring herself into her writing and a new friendship with the charming editor, Grant Evans. But Mason remembers their past too, desperate to fix what fame destroyed. As the line between past and present blurs, secrets unravel, and one final choice looms: will Harper risk her heart again, or finally let go of the boy she once loved beyond reason? When the world is watching, is there room for ordinary happiness—or is some love meant only for memory?
Heaven’s Judge Took My Heart
Heaven’s Judge Took My Heart
4.9
After a rage-fueled TV smash, an ordinary New Yorker wakes up as the all-powerful leader of Heaven, forced to lay down the law in a world obsessed with forbidden romance. When a rebellious angel-human couple dares her authority, she must decide: enforce brutal cosmic justice, or become just another lovesick fool. One choice could rewrite the rules of the universe—and her own heart.
Legends Unleashed: The Grocery Store Portal
Legends Unleashed: The Grocery Store Portal
4.8
Ethan Cole, an ordinary college student, tumbles through his family's grocery store and into an alternate America where legends walk the earth. Armed with modern snacks and a heart full of hope, he teams up with the charismatic Alexander Grant to rewrite history and save a nation on the brink. But every choice Ethan makes could change the fate of heroes—and his own future—forever.
Beneath the Office Ceiling
Beneath the Office Ceiling
4.7
When Lauren, a meticulous office worker, becomes convinced that something sinister is dripping from the ceiling, her life spirals into paranoia and fear. As her colleague tries to support her, both are drawn into a chilling mystery that threatens to unravel their sanity and their friendship. What lurks above could change everything they thought they knew about their safe, ordinary workplace.
Kept by the Billionaire, Married to a Nobody
Kept by the Billionaire, Married to a Nobody
4.8
For seven years, Aubrey was the spoiled secret of ruthless Chicago heir Derek Langford—until he offered her a million-dollar payout to disappear. Now trapped in a small town with a stalker trust-fund brat and a gentle, powerless husband, she calls Derek for help and unravels a web of obsession, old promises, and a marriage built on lies. When Derek discovers the truth about her new life, he demands a choice: leave her safe, ordinary husband, or be claimed once more as the billionaire’s forbidden prize.
We Buried the Monster in Bread
We Buried the Monster in Bread
4.7
When a neighbor's child is brutally murdered and the law refuses to punish her killer, grieving mother Natalie and her friend take justice into their own hands. As they plot revenge against the boy who escaped justice, their small town simmers with secrets, suspicion, and rage. But the real danger comes when grief turns ordinary people into monsters—and nobody is truly innocent.
Stolen Hearts, Hidden Truths
Stolen Hearts, Hidden Truths
4.8
An ordinary girl, Rosie Carter, is thrust into an arranged marriage with the Governor’s son, Harrison Whitmore, amid rumors, jealousy, and social expectations. Believing Harrison loves another, Rosie struggles with insecurity and isolation—until the truth about Harrison’s feelings and their shared past comes to light, leading to a genuine, hard-won love.
Blood Moon Reborn
Blood Moon Reborn
4.9
Autumn Reeves’s journey begins with the shattering loss of her home and the unraveling of her ordinary life as she’s swept into a supernatural war. Forced to confront betrayal, love, and the truth about her own lineage, Autumn’s emotional evolution from reluctant guardian to the powerful demon god is marked by heartbreak, resilience, and the courage to challenge fate. With the world’s balance at stake, she redefines loyalty, justice, and what it means to belong.
Bloodlines and Betrayal
Bloodlines and Betrayal
4.9
Sam Whitaker’s ordinary life is upended when he’s accused of his father’s murder. As he unravels layers of betrayal, hidden parentage, and deadly family secrets, Sam is forced to confront the truth about his own identity and the people he trusted most. In the end, he faces a heart-wrenching choice between justice and forgiveness, with everything he loves hanging in the balance.
He Lied, So I Fell Harder
He Lied, So I Fell Harder
4.9
Love wasn’t the finish line—it was just the start. Savannah Brooks always believed her life would be ordinary: teaching martial arts, dodging her mother’s matchmaking schemes, and hoping for something real. Then Julian Carter walked into her gym—bookish, gentle, and unexpectedly brave—and suddenly, Savannah’s world is on fire with first dates, museum adventures, and family celebrations. But when Julian’s childhood friend Chloe bursts onto the scene, their whirlwind romance collides with jealousy, secrets, and a rivalry that turns into an unlikely sisterhood. As Savannah faces daring rescues, playful betrayals, and the revelation of Julian’s sweetest lie, she must decide what it means to trust—and how far she’ll go for the love she never saw coming. When family, friends, and forever are all on the line, can Savannah and Julian turn their almost-perfect romance into a life they both believe in? Or will a single secret tear them apart before they reach the altar?