Collateral Hearts: Chosen or Forgotten? / Chapter 1: The Number on His Card
Collateral Hearts: Chosen or Forgotten?

Collateral Hearts: Chosen or Forgotten?

Author: Christopher Bradshaw


Chapter 1: The Number on His Card

Next →

Brendan Tate was born into one of Manhattan’s most powerful families—rich, respected, and always just out of reach. But even he had someone he couldn’t have. There were always whispers about his first love, the one that slipped away—the girl everyone thought he’d marry someday. He told himself the age gap was too big, never dared to cross the line, and in the end, he broke off the engagement with the girl everyone had pegged as his forever crush.

A year later, broke and drifting, I ended up with Brendan Tate. The people in those circles all knew what I was—just a distraction, a stand-in for the one he couldn’t have. Honestly, I didn’t care. When I was done playing, I’d walk away without looking back. But for a second, I let myself feel the weight of it—the strangeness, the thrill, the emptiness. Then I shook it off.

But Brendan wasn’t the type to let things go. Later, he chased me halfway across the world just to drag me back. He slipped off his silk tie, tapped my cheek with it, and grinned, “You’re finished playing already? Fiancée?”

Right after that drink, I ended up crashing straight into Brendan. The alcohol hit me hard, and suddenly I was face-first in his chest at the corner, landing with a thud on the carpet. My knees burned. Still kneeling, eyes down, I caught sight of his shoes—flawless, black dress pants falling perfectly, every inch of him immaculate. The sharp, cold scent of expensive cologne and clean wool drifted down to me, cutting through the haze.

Behind me, Jordan Xu’s familiar teasing voice piped up. “Mr. Tate, sorry about this. She’s my plus-one tonight, had a little too much and ran into you.”

Jordan bent to help me, but panic made me clutch Brendan’s pant leg. He clicked his tongue and stepped back, obviously irritated—wanting nothing to do with this drama. I could feel the tension in him, the way he shifted his weight as if hoping he’d disappear from the whole scene.

Jordan’s hand clamped down on my bare shoulder. Tears stung my eyes as I looked up and met Brendan’s gaze. He looked down at me, cold and proud, like someone who always gets his way. The hallway was dim, shadows slicing through the space. He stood in darkness, his eyes cool and unreadable, pausing on my face.

“Help me,” I begged, barely able to form the words. “Help me.”

“Sorry, Mr. Tate,” Jordan insisted, half-hauling me up. “She’s drunk and talking nonsense, not herself.”

Tears spilled over as I tried to grab Brendan’s jacket, but Jordan yanked me back into his arms.

“Wait.”

My heart tripped. Brendan’s voice came, slow and measured: “Mr. Xu, don’t you think this is a bit much?”

Jordan froze, hand still on my shoulder, then let go. He straightened, his usual smile wiped clean. “Mr. Tate, you’re crossing the line.”

Brendan shot back, “So what? This isn’t Los Angeles.”

In LA, Jordan could get away with anything, thanks to the Xu family’s money. But in New York, the rules changed—Brendan’s rules.

“Mr. Tate just broke off an engagement with a fiancée more than ten years younger,” Jordan sneered. “Thought you were the perfect gentleman.”

Brendan looked down at me, trembling on the carpet, and smirked. “Still more of a gentleman than you.”

The two stared each other down, tension thick, until Jordan finally turned and left. My whole body went limp, collapsing onto the carpet, head spinning.

Those polished shoes drew closer, carrying that unmistakable cool scent. Suddenly, something heavy settled around my shoulders. I looked up, startled—Brendan had draped his suit jacket over me. As he straightened, his tie brushed against my face. Through blurry eyes, I met his gaze again. This time, his stare was dark, inspecting every inch of me, full of authority and pressure I couldn’t ignore.

I knew exactly what my looks were worth.

He asked, “Do you still have your phone?” His voice was flat, emotionless.

I shook my head.

He didn’t say another word, but his assistant handed me a business card—crisp, white, with gold-embossed letters that caught the light. The card read: “Tate Capital.” Below that, in smaller print: “Brendan Tate.” For a second, I just stared at it, the texture cool and almost too sharp between my fingers.

Everyone in New York knew the Tate family, knew Brendan Tate. He was the eldest son, the head of Tate Holdings—always calm, never letting anyone see what he felt. For nearly thirty years, he’d been cold, distant, and single, with no scandals except for that recent broken engagement.

No surprise—he liked my face.

But then, he turned to his secretary and said, “Call 911, get her to a hospital. Then call the police and file a report.”

Me: “...?”

It wasn’t long before I dialed his number. After I had my stomach pumped, I gave my statement to the police. The club was thoroughly investigated—though it took a few days, and the process was more exhausting than dramatic. Jordan tried to pressure me again. For a college kid with no real connections, it didn’t take much to threaten my future.

Next →

You may also like

He Chose Her in the End—So I Chose Me
He Chose Her in the End—So I Chose Me
4.7
He died saving me, but when he woke up, I was just a ghost in his new world. Five years spent waiting by Carter's bedside taught me the meaning of sacrifice—and heartbreak. When he finally opened his eyes, I thought our love would be reborn, but the shadows of another world, another woman, haunted us both. As my place in his family slipped away, betrayal and grief forced me to choose between clinging to the past or risking everything for my own freedom. Enter Alex, the steady friend who saw my scars and offered a new beginning, just as the line between reality and nightmare began to blur. When a knife attack thrusts us into a terrifying post-apocalyptic world, survival means facing old wounds, new monsters, and the question of what love truly survives. Every choice cuts deeper when death—and hope—are just one heartbeat away. If escaping the past means risking everything, can I trust my heart to someone who’s always been waiting in the wings?
Always the Runner-Up in Her Heart
Always the Runner-Up in Her Heart
4.9
Love should make you feel chosen—but I was always the last pick in her story. Megan’s world revolved around her reckless best friend, Chase, leaving me to sweep up the shattered glass, the broken plans, and my own bruised heart. Even with a second chance promised by the system, I was always an afterthought—a placeholder in a love triangle where loyalty meant pain. When Megan bolted from our wedding to save Chase, I begged her to stay. But no matter how hard I fought, I was invisible, erased by her devotion to someone else. As my final days ticked away, I realized the truth: sometimes love isn’t enough to be seen, and heartbreak is the only reward for loyalty. Now I’m left with a choice—fade quietly, or survive ten more days of agony for a goodbye she’ll never hear. If you could rewrite your ending, would you choose pain just to be remembered?
I Was Switched at Birth—But Still Unwanted
I Was Switched at Birth—But Still Unwanted
4.9
Some hearts are borrowed, but the pain is real. After a lifetime as the sickly daughter no family wanted, I’m torn between the parents who abandoned me and the ones who raised another girl in my place. Even after my heart transplant, I’m haunted by the mother I lost, the sister I envy, and the ache of never being enough. Grace glows at the center of every room, while I fade into the background—a shadow in my own life. But even as love, friendship, and a new beginning beckon, the scars of rejection and grief refuse to heal. Now, with two families watching, a boy who sees through my silence, and a future I never expected, I have to decide: can I let myself be loved—or will I always be the girl left behind? If you only get one miracle, what do you wish for—the family who lost you, or the life that could finally be yours?
He Chose Me Again—But So Did Fate
He Chose Me Again—But So Did Fate
5.0
Some love stories get a second chance—but what if fate brings back all the heartbreak too? Lillian died for Carter once, her fierce devotion immortalized in online debates and bittersweet memories. But when a cosmic twist rewinds time, Carter chooses her again, and Lillian vows to finally live for herself. Their wedding is haunted by omens and the watchful eyes of Savannah—Carter’s other great love, who’s also been sent back with her own painful memories. As rivalries reignite and family loyalties splinter, Lillian must decide: Is she doomed to be just a chapter in Carter’s epic, or can she rewrite her own ending this time? When every move is watched and every feeling judged, how do you claim a love that history—and fate—keep trying to erase? Can Lillian break free, or is she still just a supporting role in someone else’s story?
Almost Chosen: Eight Years in His Shadow
Almost Chosen: Eight Years in His Shadow
4.8
Eight years of loving Carson West, and still—he won’t claim me. Under the dazzling lights of New York’s Midtown Gala, I watch him escort another woman down the red carpet, my own invitation ripped away by a single, heartless call. For years, I believed if I just worked harder, loved deeper, he’d finally see me. But in a city built on appearances, my devotion is invisible—while his new obsession, Avery, shines at my expense. Online, the world turns against me; in private, I’m a secret he never acknowledges. When the rumors boil over and the truth won’t protect me, I’m forced to choose: keep fighting for a man who won’t fight for me, or reclaim the self I lost chasing someone else’s love story. If I walk away now, do I lose everything—or finally become someone worth loving? What’s left of a heart after eight years of being almost chosen?
Simpleton’s Last Wish: Chosen or Betrayed?
Simpleton’s Last Wish: Chosen or Betrayed?
4.8
They called me 'simple,' but no one saw how much I could feel. When Ethan Hart—rescued by my father, beloved by our city—became my protector and then my husband, I longed to be truly chosen, not just pitied. Yet secrets and betrayals built walls between us: Ethan's gentle devotion masked scars and a hunger for revenge, while Rose Duvall, the daring general's daughter, burned with her own forbidden love. I was bartered, abandoned, and used as a pawn—by those I trusted most. Only Nicholas Gray, the wild northern prince, showed me a world where kindness wasn’t conditional. I learned what it meant to want, to lose, and to fight for dignity when the world called me worthless. Now, as war and politics threaten everyone I love, the map hidden in my handkerchief could save lives—but at what cost to my own? When all truths are revealed and love is tangled with betrayal, who will truly choose me—and will I ever belong anywhere?
After the Dare: I Chose Myself
After the Dare: I Chose Myself
4.9
One dare shattered my perfect love story—and forced me to choose between heartbreak and a second chance. When Carter, the boyfriend everyone envied, kissed another girl in a drunken game, I realized my boundaries meant nothing to him. Public humiliation, whispered gossip, and a campus confession page spiral turned my world upside down. Carter’s apologies grew emptier as the drama deepened, while Brooke—the girl he kissed—seemed all too eager to take my place. But just when I thought I’d lost everything, Jack, the boy I once rejected, reappeared with quiet strength and a promise of real devotion. Suddenly, I was forced to confront what I truly wanted—and what I refused to settle for. Was love worth fighting for, or was I just clinging to a fantasy? If you had to choose between the boy who broke you and the one who’d wait forever, who would you trust with your heart?
I Chose Him—But He Chose Her
I Chose Him—But He Chose Her
4.7
He was my childhood promise, but I was never his first choice. Anna spends years quietly shaping her future around Tyler—her best friend, her secret love—only to watch him choose someone else when it matters most. As college acceptances arrive and old loyalties fracture, Anna is forced to confront the cost of loving someone who only saw her in the background. Every moment at reunions and family tables reminds her of what she’s lost, and what she’s finally ready to let go. With her parents’ hopes weighing heavy and Tyler’s betrayal fresh, Anna faces a crossroads between repeating old mistakes or daring to start anew. But when she chooses her own path, can she find freedom in letting go, or will the past keep calling her back? What’s left when your childhood dream shatters—can you ever truly move on?
Queen of Tides: I Chose My Own Fate
Queen of Tides: I Chose My Own Fate
4.8
Three centuries of love, and he left me for a human girl. When Lucas abandoned me for a fleeting shore romance, my heart shattered and I chose a new path—one that led me to the palace’s dazzling queen selection and the mysterious, magnetic Sterling. As I rose from heartbreak to the edge of the throne, every challenge forced me to decide what mattered more: power, revenge, or risking my heart again. The ocean teemed with secrets, and my every choice was watched by friend and rival alike, with my family’s future and my own dignity at stake. But when love and ambition collide in a test that demands an impossible sacrifice, will I finally claim the crown—and dare to choose the one who sees me, scars and all? If you had to choose between the throne and the one who’d risk everything for you, which would you trust your heart to?
Shattered Vows, Stolen Hearts
Shattered Vows, Stolen Hearts
4.9
Lillian thought her bond with Harrison Whitmore was unbreakable—until a cunning rival rewrote the rules of their world. Betrayed and erased from her own story, Lillian must fight for the truth and her own future, even as everything she loves slips away. Will she reclaim her place, or discover a new path beyond heartbreak?