He Arrested My Heart on Our First Date / Chapter 4: Rivals, Rumors, and Revelations
He Arrested My Heart on Our First Date

He Arrested My Heart on Our First Date

Author: Harold Hayes


Chapter 4: Rivals, Rumors, and Revelations

“Mariah Reed, what a coincidence. Are you here with a friend?”

Mason was standing at the bathroom door. I almost bumped into him. We were so close! I could smell his cologne—clean, a little woodsy, like cedar and fresh laundry. My heart skipped a beat.

My heart was pounding. For real, I could barely breathe.

I awkwardly lied, “Yeah, but my friend stood me up.”

There was a beat of awkward silence, so I quickly changed the subject, feeling my cheeks heat up.

“I saw you with a girl earlier—on a blind date?”

He looked at me thoughtfully, smiled, and nodded. “But it wasn’t a match. I turned her down. She seemed mad and left without eating.”

YES!

I was ecstatic inside. Couldn’t hide my expression. I tried to suppress my smile, but the more I tried, the weirder I looked.

I took the chance to invite him to dinner. “Just a simple meal, since both of us got stood up.” I tried to sound casual, but I was dying inside.

I regretted it as soon as I said it! Wasn’t this too obvious?

But he didn’t mind at all, just naturally asked the waiter to combine our tables. My heart beat even faster. This feeling didn’t even feel like me…

It really was just a meal. Two people, lots of dishes, eating happily. I thought it was too quiet, so I took the initiative. “By the way, I still don’t have your number.”

Mason looked up seriously. “You do.”

Me: ??

“I don’t!”

If I did, I’d be texting him nonstop!

I searched my contacts and found someone named ‘AA. Mason’ in my group chat. And we’d chatted before:

Him: “Hello.”

Me: “How much is that foundation?”

Him: “? I’ll check…”

Him: “$45.”

Me: “Same as Sephora, bye!”

Him: “?”

Hmm…

So our fate is this awkward…

“Can’t blame me, your name sounds like a shopping agent.”

“My coworker changed it for me.”

After dinner, he walked me downstairs. Me, a wild child, actually played it pure. Facing Officer Grant, I tried several times but still didn’t dare to hold his hand. I’m such a wimp!

After getting home, my mom called to ask about the blind date. I was full of question marks.

“What blind date? Wasn’t Mason on a blind date with someone else? How could I mention it! We just had a meal.”

Mom: “No, Mrs. Taylor told me she sent Mason a message after my call, saying you wanted a second blind date and you were already on your way. Mason replied ‘OK.’ I thought you two were talking about marriage already.”

Boom!

It felt like something exploded in my head. Turns out the meeting at the bathroom door wasn’t a coincidence at all. He went to find me. And he knew all along I didn’t have a friend waiting—he knew I came just to see him.

My face burned. Luckily, he saved my pride and didn’t call me out. He’s quite the gentleman.

I hummed happily while showering, then suddenly realized—

What did Mason mean by replying ‘OK’ to Mrs. Taylor? He doesn’t dislike me—does that mean he thinks we have a chance?!!!

In bed, feeling like a lovestruck teen, I carefully recorded a voice message to ‘AA. Mason.’ I listened several times, made sure I sounded sweet, then sent it.

“Mason, you there…?”

He replied right away. “Here.”

Just as I was about to keep going, he sent a screenshot.

I was instantly on guard!

Tyler Ford added Mason? How did he get his number? Even challenged him:

‘Babe just wants your looks, but she likes sweet talkers. You’re not sweet, she’ll get bored soon. I’m younger, in better shape, hit the gym every day. How can you compare?’

Damn! A direct challenge. I respect Tyler for being a man.

But what I cared about was Mason’s reply. His words were cold, but I could sense a hint of rivalry.

‘Oh? You sure?’

So, is Mason going to fight for me?

Not sure, so I asked.

Mason said: ‘Why compete with a kid? I just blocked him.’

Oh…

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

She Was My Forever—Until He Was
She Was My Forever—Until He Was
4.9
First love isn’t always a fairytale—sometimes, it’s the storm that ruins everything. I was supposed to go to Stanford with Autumn Reyes; we were childhood sweethearts, inseparable, until the day she chose the school’s new heartthrob and left me in the shadows. Her wild love story with Mason burned through our town, leaving rumors, heartbreak, and broken promises in its wake. I tried to save her—tried to save us—but my loyalty only led to betrayal. When Autumn’s trust shattered and my dreams were locked away, I was left with a question I can’t stop asking: how do you forgive the person who turned your first love into your deepest wound?
Chasing My Crush’s Cold Heart
Chasing My Crush’s Cold Heart
4.7
Aubrey’s relentless, cringe-worthy pursuit of her high school crush Carter goes viral when their chat logs leak on campus. Humiliated but undeterred, she fights for his affection—only to be haunted by his secrets, his silence, and a rival girl from his past. Will she ever break through his icy walls, or is she setting herself up for heartbreak?
I Was His First, Never His Last
I Was His First, Never His Last
4.9
He was New York's golden prince. I was the first love he could never forget—and the scandal everyone wanted to see crash and burn. When I returned to the city, Mason Whitmore had already replaced me with a lookalike, showering her with everything I once had. But one viral video, one desperate plea, and suddenly the lines between past and present blur. As old wounds reopen, rivalries ignite, and secrets unravel, I'm forced to choose: fight for my own future, or let the man who broke my heart back in. In a city where love is currency and betrayal is news, can a girl with nothing left lose her heart twice? Or will I finally claim the ending they all said I’d never get?
His Heart Belonged to Her First
His Heart Belonged to Her First
4.7
Everyone in Maple Heights knew Caleb Hart never kept a girl for long—and I was no exception. I thought I was different, until I learned I was just a stand-in for his first love, the girl he never let go. When she returns, I have to decide: stay and be second best, or walk away before I lose myself completely.
I’m His Fiancée, But He’s Her Secret
I’m His Fiancée, But He’s Her Secret
4.9
He was my first heartbreak—and now, as the fiancée of a wealthy man with too many secrets, I’m about to meet the ghosts I thought I’d buried. I was always the 'good girl,' the safe choice, until a proposal ring and a scandalous pregnancy upended my carefully planned life. Carter offers security, but his world is full of women I’ll never measure up to—and tonight, he’s inviting me into his circle for the first time. But nothing prepares me for who’s waiting there: Tyler, the wild love I never got over. When midnight falls and old wounds resurface, will I cling to the future I chose, or risk everything for the boy who broke me? When your heart is split between comfort and chaos, which do you betray?
His Heart Was Never Mine
His Heart Was Never Mine
4.9
Mariah spent years chasing Ethan’s passion, only to realize his devotion belonged to someone else. Now, as she faces a new engagement and Ethan’s world unravels, she must choose between longing for what’s lost and embracing a future she never imagined. Betrayal, heartbreak, and forbidden desire collide in this gripping tale of love and letting go.
Back to Him, Before the Heartbreak
Back to Him, Before the Heartbreak
4.9
He was my childhood friend, my secret crush—and, eventually, my husband in a marriage built on regret. They called us the punchline couple, a running joke among the rich, but no one saw the scars beneath our bickering. When fate throws me back to high school, I swear this time I’ll confess my feelings before tragedy can claim his future. But as old crushes return and Lucas’s secrets unravel, I’m caught between the boy I lost and the man I married. If the past and present collide, will I finally get my happy ending—or break both our hearts all over again?
He Fed Me Ice, Then Melted My Heart
He Fed Me Ice, Then Melted My Heart
4.8
An ice cube shouldn’t make your heart race—unless it’s your roommate feeding it to you, one chilling dare at a time. Charlie’s small-town mumble is the perfect excuse for Carter’s strange, intimate lessons—but what’s really behind the ritual? As college life swirls with longing and confusion, Charlie’s desire to fit in collides with Carter’s secret motives, and the line between practice and something more blurs with every touch. When rumors ignite and boundaries crack, Charlie must decide if he’s ready for the truth—and for the feeling that’s melting more than just his accent. Will Carter’s next lesson finally cross the line, or is this just the start of something neither of them can control?
He Broke My Heart on My Birthday
He Broke My Heart on My Birthday
5.0
On her seventeenth birthday, Natalie’s world shatters when Caleb, her lifelong protector and expected fiancé, betrays her for another girl. Caught between old promises and new beginnings, Natalie must choose between clinging to the past or claiming her own future. But in small-town Maple Heights, every decision is a risk—and the stakes are nothing less than her heart.
He Never Touched Me—Until Now
He Never Touched Me—Until Now
4.9
Three years of marriage, and Carter Whitman has never touched me—not once. I was always just the substitute, the shadow in his perfect life. But when the loneliness grows too heavy to bear, I hatch a reckless plan: a single, scandalous text and a photo meant to blow up everything. What I don’t expect is Carter’s reaction—his cold fury, his sudden return, and the dangerous, magnetic tension that erupts between us. Now, I’m trapped in a house where trust is a weapon and every glance could be a threat or a plea. He says he believes me—but why now, after all this time? When a single whispered word can tip our fragile balance, how far will I go to force him to let me go—or will I finally make him see me? If love was never part of the deal, why does my heart race every time he draws near? What happens when the woman who wanted out becomes the only thing he can’t let go?
He Dared Me to Marry Her
He Dared Me to Marry Her
4.9
Love isn’t supposed to start with a dare—but when Trevor barges into my kitchen and hands me a rain-soaked stranger, my quiet life explodes. Suddenly, I’m hosting a wedding dinner for a girl who can’t speak, hiding her from the law, and falling for her gentle, secret smile. In a town where secrets travel faster than rumors, we build a fragile happiness—until betrayal rips it all away. When the woman I love is dragged off on our daughter’s birthday, I’m forced to choose: obey the law, or risk everything to keep our family whole. Will love survive the borders that divide us—or will I lose her forever to the river’s cold embrace?
Her Heart Belongs to Another
Her Heart Belongs to Another
4.7
Alex finally wins the campus ice queen—only to discover, in bed, that her body and soul are locked for someone else. As cruel online rumors swirl and her true feelings for her childhood protector ignite, Alex is forced to play the villain in a love story he can never win. When betrayal, heartbreak, and desire collide on one stormy night, he must decide: fight for a girl who was never his, or walk away shattered forever.