He Called Me Sister—Until I Left / Chapter 5: Rewrite Our Ending
He Called Me Sister—Until I Left

He Called Me Sister—Until I Left

Author: Jonathan Lewis


Chapter 5: Rewrite Our Ending

← Prev

He stopped in front of me. I still hadn’t come back to myself when he pulled out an umbrella from who knows where, sounding helpless. “Why are you just standing there? If you get heatstroke, I’ll have to carry you back again. Come on, let’s get something to eat.”

He said it so naturally, like nothing had happened that night. Like we were still us.

I snapped out of it, said goodbye to Marissa, and quietly followed him. Out of the corner of my eye, I saw his ears turning red. That had to mean something, right?

My heart skipped—maybe, just maybe, he’d accepted it?

I got excited, carefully reaching out to cover his hand on the umbrella handle. I held my breath, waiting.

He didn’t let go, but his whole body tensed. My hopes crashed.

Seeing that, I couldn’t hide my disappointment. I guess I’d imagined it all.

Guess I was wrong—maybe he really did think I was just drunk that night. Maybe it meant nothing to him.

I pulled my hand back, but the next second, he walked out into the sunlight. What was he doing?

I blinked at him.

I turned to see him standing there, looking confused, like a puppy waiting for its owner. “Why’d you let go?”

Me: “You want me to hold on?”

He strode over, grabbed my hand with his free one, and looked straight ahead. His face turned visibly red, but he nodded, trying to act cool. “Yeah, I thought it over for a few days. I decided I can’t let someone else swoop in and steal the girl I’ve been looking out for all these years. That’d be a huge loss.”

*Thump. Thump.*

There were no words for how happy I felt in that moment. My heart was pounding so loud it hurt.

I couldn’t help myself—I grabbed his collar, made him lower his head, and kissed him. I didn’t care who saw.

His heartbeat was even faster than mine. I could feel it against my chest.

We were finally together. For real this time.

I never thought this would happen in my life. It felt like a miracle.

But once we got together, nothing really changed. He still did everything he used to—picking me up after class, bringing me water and an umbrella, giving me treats. The little things.

The only difference was, sometimes he’d kiss or hug me when we said goodbye. And every time, my heart would race.

*But that was it—nothing more.*

If I were still twenty, I might’ve been shy and satisfied, but my soul was already twenty-six. I wanted more.

Just kissing and hugging wasn’t enough. Not anymore.

I waited patiently for a long time, but when nothing happened, I had to make the first move. *Typical.*

During the summer before our junior year, we went on a trip together. He’d planned everything perfectly, packed all the essentials. He was always so thoughtful.

“Tomorrow we’ll get up early to visit the church, then have lunch, and go to the museum in the afternoon.” He sat on the hotel sofa, seriously planning out our schedule.

I stared at his lips, then let my eyes drift lower, asking out of nowhere, “Oh, then, big brother, can I touch your abs?”

“Of course—huh?” He agreed without thinking, then froze. His face turned bright red.

It was so hot when we got to the hotel that he’d already showered. He looked good. Really good.

I sat on his lap and ran my hands over his abs. I couldn’t help myself.

He was an athlete, always working out, with an amazing body. I traced the lines with my fingers.

The more I looked, the more I liked it. I wanted him. Badly.

He was burning up, trying to set me down, his voice hoarse. “Don’t mess around. You’re still young.”

I pushed him down and kissed him. “Not that young. Why don’t you find out?”

He struggled, his Adam’s apple bobbing. “I didn’t bring… you know…”

“I did.”

*….*

A summer storm raged outside late into the night. The world outside faded away.

I curled up in his arms, feeling like I was dreaming. I never wanted to wake up.

The college I never got into, the person I never got to be with—this time, I had them both. I felt like the luckiest person alive.

Suddenly, I was afraid it was all just a dream. Please, let it be real.

But then he hugged me tighter. “When we get back, let’s get engaged. After graduation, let’s get married.”

I snapped out of it and shook my head. “But I want to go to grad school. Let’s wait three more years for marriage, okay?”

I loved him, but I couldn’t let go of my studies. I wanted both.

This time, I wanted us to become better together. Not just for him—this was for me, too.

He suddenly got anxious. “Which grad school are you applying to? You can’t keep it from me again! I’ll be really mad!”

He sat up, staring at me, his voice full of lingering fear and hope—afraid we’d be separated again, but glad we’d ended up together. I couldn’t help but smile.

*I laughed out loud.*

*A jealous puppy—who could resist?*

I wrapped my arms around his neck and teased, “Not telling. Didn’t you say you’d deal with me later? I’ve been waiting forever.”

He paused, his eyes darkening. “Tomorrow’s plans are canceled!”

*The End*

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.
← Prev

You may also like

His Wife Was Meant for Another
His Wife Was Meant for Another
4.7
I married Chicago’s most coveted bachelor in my sister’s place, only to become a ghost in my own marriage—unwanted, untouched, and tormented by suspicion. Every night, Jake shuts me out, his body close but his heart locked away, leaving me desperate and humiliated. But when I discover his secret online confessions—and the twisted truth behind his distance—I realize our cold war is just the beginning of a forbidden, addictive game neither of us knows how to win.
I Raised Her—Now She Calls Me Stranger
I Raised Her—Now She Calls Me Stranger
4.9
Sick, alone, and betrayed, Maya Zheng reaches out to her younger sister Wendy—only to be met with cold indifference and a demand for repayment. Years of sacrifice and sibling loyalty unravel as Maya recalls their tumultuous past: a broken home, secrets of parentage, and relentless struggle to protect the sister who would one day turn her back. When Wendy reemerges as the 'heiress' of a shady businessman at a glittering gala, Maya is forced into a public reckoning—exposing old debts, demanding justice, and choosing her own worth over toxic family ties. As fortunes shift and betrayals are laid bare, Maya discovers that sometimes the family you choose is worth more than the one you’re born with. But when Wendy’s world collapses, will Maya finally be free—or haunted by the sister she can’t save? If love isn’t enough, what’s left to hold onto?
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.
She Chose My Brother, Left Me to Die
She Chose My Brother, Left Me to Die
4.9
She used my love to get to my brother—and left me to die when I was no longer useful. When the world turned on me and the woman I trusted most framed me for crimes I didn’t commit, I lost everything: my marriage, my family, and my reputation. But as the lies closed in and betrayal stung deeper than any wound, I discovered the only way to survive was to burn it all down. With nothing left to lose, I made a move that would change everything. In the end, will I finally break free—or did loving her doom me forever?
He Betrayed Me for My Sister's Honor
He Betrayed Me for My Sister's Honor
4.8
On the night of our engagement, my perfect fiancé was found in bed with my younger sister, destroying both our reputations in front of the entire town. He claimed to have taken advantage of her, choosing her honor over the love he promised me—leaving me to face the shame, heartbreak, and whispers alone. But the real truth is darker, and in Savannah, betrayal is a family tradition.
He Chose My Sister Over Me
He Chose My Sister Over Me
5.0
Jenna spent high school invisible, mocked for her weight and crushed when her secret crush chose her perfect sister. Eight years later, Jenna returns to her hometown—transformed and married—only to confront old betrayals, family jealousy, and the man who once broke her heart. But revenge tastes sweeter when the tables turn and a new love steps out of the shadows.
He Chose My Half-Sister as His Bride
He Chose My Half-Sister as His Bride
4.7
Morgan’s engagement to Evan shatters when he humiliates her and demands her perfect half-sister as his real wife. Betrayed and branded as 'damaged goods,' Morgan is exiled to the South, forced to rebuild her life while her childhood love claims her sister. But Evan isn’t done with her—and now, Morgan must decide: will she remain his discarded side piece, or fight for her own worth, no matter the cost?
The Night He Chose My Sister
The Night He Chose My Sister
4.6
Natalie has always lived in her golden sister’s shadow—until the night she catches Caleb, the boy she’s loved in secret, kissing Aubrey on the rain-soaked rooftop. As her family ignores her triumph and clings to old favorites, Natalie’s hidden brilliance finally explodes into the spotlight, threatening to upend everything they know. But can she ever escape being the girl left behind, or will loving Caleb always mean losing herself?
Traded as the Heir’s Secret Bride
Traded as the Heir’s Secret Bride
4.8
For three years, I was forced to slip into the Callahan heir’s bed, a shadow of his fragile wife—my own identity erased in the darkness. When I begged for a place in his world, he offered only cold rejection and cruel truths: I was nothing but a servant, never worthy of love or status. Desperate to save my sister from a worse fate, I offered myself as a widow bride to a dying man—trading one gilded cage for another, as the man I secretly loved watched in stunned silence.
I Chose Me—And Left Them Behind
I Chose Me—And Left Them Behind
4.8
Sometimes, the only way to find home is to walk away from the one that broke you. When Ellie Brooks returns to her wealthy birth family after years in the shadows, she’s desperate for a place to belong—but all she finds is a perfect house built on cold shoulders and invisible walls. Her sister Savannah wears the crown, her brother Carter guards the door, and her parents are masters of polite indifference. This time, Ellie won’t beg for scraps of love. Instead, she claims the smallest room, hides her pain, and quietly plans her escape. But as family secrets unravel and old betrayals come roaring back, Ellie must choose: fight for the family that never wanted her, or finally fight for herself? If survival means walking away, can she leave the past—and their twisted love—behind for good?
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
4.7
Sam gave up his dreams and moved to Rachel’s hometown, only to become the outsider in his own marriage—her childhood ‘brother’ Jake always comes first. Every boundary Sam sets is laughed off, but when he brings his own female friend to dinner, Rachel’s jealousy explodes. As their marriage unravels, Sam realizes he’s just a guest in Rachel’s perfect family sitcom—and he’s finally done playing the fool.
My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
My Sister’s Soul, My Life on Loan
4.9
Sometimes, the person you love most comes back as someone else. When my sister wakes up convinced she's a debutante from another century, my family is thrown into chaos—and I'm the only one who sees the truth behind her haunted eyes. As Lila stumbles through smartphones and SAT prep, I teach her about freedom, love, and the world that should have been hers. But when a car crash swaps our souls across time, I wake up in a past where women are prisoners and my real sister is a ghost. To survive, we must outwit cruel fathers, possessive cousins, and the rules of two different worlds—until a desperate ritual offers one last shot at home. What will we lose to return—and what if the girl we saved is the one we can never let go? When fate gives you a second chance, can you rewrite your own story?