He Chose Me—Not My Sister / Chapter 5: Scars, Secrets, Second Chances
He Chose Me—Not My Sister

He Chose Me—Not My Sister

Author: Lori Joseph


Chapter 5: Scars, Secrets, Second Chances

Yes, I’d known Mason before all this.

Our story goes back farther than anyone realizes.

We first met in my sophomore year of high school. He’d just transferred in, leg in a cast from a motorcycle accident. At the same time, my mom was trying to force me to drop out and marry a guy twenty years older, just for the payout. When I refused, she let him into my room at night. I put a knife to my own throat, and he backed off—at least for a while.

That was the lowest point of my life. I still have the scar—a reminder that I survived.

Back then, Mason was a rebellious, moody teen who hated his parents for caring only about money. Even with a broken leg, they stayed overseas on business, leaving him with just the housekeeper.

He’d sit by the window, scowling at the world. But when he smiled, it was like the sun finally breaking through the clouds.

Seeing he needed help at school, I offered to look after him. He asked what I wanted in return—I said I needed a place to stay, and he agreed. I couldn’t go home anymore.

We became each other’s lifelines. He let me crash in his guest room, no questions asked.

For all his temper, Mason was easy to get along with and never made things hard on anyone. When his leg healed, he didn’t make me leave, so I stayed until graduation.

We built a little world of our own—just the two of us against everyone else.

We were both starved for affection, keeping each other company through rough times. After graduation, he went abroad, and I went to college out of state. He tried to keep in touch, but I was too busy working to reply, and we lost contact. He even tried to send me money, but I couldn’t take it—not after everything he’d done for me already.

I kept every letter he sent, though. Sometimes I’d read them on lonely nights, just to remind myself someone cared.

It wasn’t until after I graduated that we crossed paths again—he’d just come back to the States. After he chased me down relentlessly, we started dating and got married.

He found me at an art show, a bouquet of sunflowers in hand. He never let go after that.

Just like Mason predicted, my mom called the next day, furious and ready to blame me for everything. Mason took the call and went to his study—I don’t know what he said, but when my mom spoke to me afterward, she was polite for the first time ever. She told me to enjoy my trip and not to worry about Lindsey’s injury—she’d recover in a few months.

It was so out of character, I almost burst out laughing.

I was dying to know what Mason had said. He told my mom he’d installed surveillance in his study and didn’t mind showing everyone what her daughter was really like. He also said Lindsey hadn’t found a job since graduation, and he could easily make sure she never did.

He’s not one to bluff, but this time, he did it for me.

"Did you really install surveillance?"

I raised an eyebrow, half amused.

"No, it’s the suite’s study. Putting cameras in there would be super creepy. But I bet your mom bought every word."

He winked, looking pretty pleased with himself.

She definitely did. My mom spoiled Lindsey so much she couldn’t bear to see her suffer. In a way, she made her own monster.

She created her own monster, and now she had to deal with it.

After two months of recovery, Lindsey came back to work—not because she still liked Mason, but because she had nowhere else to go. She’d tried every design firm in town, but once they saw her work, they all let her go. She blew through cash like it was water and was obsessed with luxury brands. The family had already drained their savings to send her abroad—she was never going to get a full scholarship. Her dad and my mom wanted to help but just couldn’t afford it.

She burned through money like it was nothing, and now there was nothing left.

She tried to seduce Mason partly because he was a catch, partly because he was loaded. Now, Mason’s company was the best job she could land, with great pay and perks. That’s why she shamelessly stuck around.

She put on a brave face, but everyone could see right through her.

For three months, she kept her head down. But it wouldn’t be Lindsey if she didn’t stir up trouble eventually.

I knew it was only a matter of time before she tried something.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

He Chose My Sister Over Me
He Chose My Sister Over Me
5.0
Jenna spent high school invisible, mocked for her weight and crushed when her secret crush chose her perfect sister. Eight years later, Jenna returns to her hometown—transformed and married—only to confront old betrayals, family jealousy, and the man who once broke her heart. But revenge tastes sweeter when the tables turn and a new love steps out of the shadows.
He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
He Chose Her—So I Chose Me
4.9
A car ride was all it took to shatter twenty years of sacrifice. When I, a devoted single mother, dared to sit beside my son, his girlfriend unleashed accusations that turned my world upside down—and my own child sided with her. I’d saved, planned, and dreamed for his future, only to be cast out and humiliated. As family lines blur and loyalty is tested, I’m forced to make a choice: cling to the son who betrayed me, or finally put myself first. Will my heartbreak become my freedom, or will the past pull me back in? When love turns to war, who gets the front seat in your life?
My Husband Chose My Sister Over Me
My Husband Chose My Sister Over Me
5.0
Helen spent her life sacrificing everything for a husband who always put his sister-in-law first. Now, with a second chance at life, she’s done playing the victim—ready to fight for her dignity, her children, and everything that was stolen from her. But as secrets spill in their small town, Helen’s bold defiance threatens to shatter the Whitaker family forever.
I Chose Myself, They Chose Her
I Chose Myself, They Chose Her
4.9
Betrayal tastes bitter when it’s family. When Casey learns she’s the only one who can save her sister’s life, she tests her family’s love with a single devastating lie. But in her parents’ home, loyalty is a one-way street—and Casey is about to be cast out for good. Surrounded by indifference and favoritism, she faces a choice between saving herself or sacrificing everything for those who never chose her. As secrets unravel and accusations fly, Casey must decide: will she cling to the hope of belonging, or finally walk away to protect the new life growing inside her? When blood is just another weapon, can she survive the cut?
Swapped at the Altar: My Sister Stole My Groom
Swapped at the Altar: My Sister Stole My Groom
4.8
On the day of my wedding, I let my conniving half-sister take my place at the altar—giving my childhood fiancé exactly what he wanted. But when he realizes the bride in his arms isn’t me, all hell breaks loose, and the secrets that tore us apart threaten to ruin us all. Betrayed by blood and love, I’ll finally choose my own destiny—even if it means shattering the lives of everyone who ever doubted me.
He Chose My Half-Sister as His Bride
He Chose My Half-Sister as His Bride
4.7
Morgan’s engagement to Evan shatters when he humiliates her and demands her perfect half-sister as his real wife. Betrayed and branded as 'damaged goods,' Morgan is exiled to the South, forced to rebuild her life while her childhood love claims her sister. But Evan isn’t done with her—and now, Morgan must decide: will she remain his discarded side piece, or fight for her own worth, no matter the cost?
The Night He Chose My Sister
The Night He Chose My Sister
4.6
Natalie has always lived in her golden sister’s shadow—until the night she catches Caleb, the boy she’s loved in secret, kissing Aubrey on the rain-soaked rooftop. As her family ignores her triumph and clings to old favorites, Natalie’s hidden brilliance finally explodes into the spotlight, threatening to upend everything they know. But can she ever escape being the girl left behind, or will loving Caleb always mean losing herself?
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
My Wife Chose Her 'Brother' Over Me
4.7
Sam gave up his dreams and moved to Rachel’s hometown, only to become the outsider in his own marriage—her childhood ‘brother’ Jake always comes first. Every boundary Sam sets is laughed off, but when he brings his own female friend to dinner, Rachel’s jealousy explodes. As their marriage unravels, Sam realizes he’s just a guest in Rachel’s perfect family sitcom—and he’s finally done playing the fool.
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
My Sister Stole My Life, But I Stole Her Husband
4.9
Betrayed and murdered by my jealous sister, I wake up back at the day of our fateful marriage choices. This time, I claim the powerful Army major she stole from me—while she’s left to rot in the bed of the Foster brothers. But as old secrets and new passions ignite, I realize my sister may have been reborn too... and she’ll stop at nothing to ruin my second chance.
Stolen by My Sister’s Groom
Stolen by My Sister’s Groom
4.9
Annie Chen never planned on marrying Ethan Carter, Maple Heights’ most coveted bachelor—until a twist of fate and her sister’s wild warning tie their lives together. But with secrets from a past life, a new rival, and a rugged stranger stirring her heart, Annie must choose between repeating old heartbreak or seizing a chance at forbidden happiness. One man wants her, another saves her, and everyone in town is watching.
She Chose My Brother, Left Me to Die
She Chose My Brother, Left Me to Die
4.9
She used my love to get to my brother—and left me to die when I was no longer useful. When the world turned on me and the woman I trusted most framed me for crimes I didn’t commit, I lost everything: my marriage, my family, and my reputation. But as the lies closed in and betrayal stung deeper than any wound, I discovered the only way to survive was to burn it all down. With nothing left to lose, I made a move that would change everything. In the end, will I finally break free—or did loving her doom me forever?
I Was His Safe Choice—Now I’m Gone
I Was His Safe Choice—Now I’m Gone
4.9
He called me ‘marriage material’—but not worth loving. On the eve of our wedding, I discovered Mason’s spreadsheet: every woman ranked, every feeling reduced to a checklist, and my own column stamped ‘suitable for marriage.’ His heart still belonged to Jordan, the wild first love he’d never dare choose. My world collapsed, but instead of breaking, I ran—straight into the life I’d buried, the mother I’d lost, and the courage I thought I’d forgotten. As family secrets and old wounds ignite a public showdown, I must decide: will I keep living for someone else’s rules, or finally claim my own story? If you were chosen for convenience, can you ever become someone’s first choice—or is the bravest thing to walk away?