He Lied, So I Fell Harder / Chapter 4: Birthday Truths and Sisterly Bonds
He Lied, So I Fell Harder

He Lied, So I Fell Harder

Author: Frederick Harrell


Chapter 4: Birthday Truths and Sisterly Bonds

That day was Julian’s grandma’s birthday, and I was invited for dinner.

I spent the afternoon picking out a dress and rehearsing polite greetings in my head. Meeting the family was a big deal.

Since Julian was busy helping, I offered to go by myself and have him pick me up outside.

He texted me updates every few minutes, making sure I wasn’t lost or nervous. It was sweet.

I was about to buy a gift, but before I reached the mall, I saw a crowd gathered, pointing and talking.

People were murmuring, craning their necks to see what was going on. I edged closer, curiosity getting the better of me.

“You gold-digging woman! I spent all my savings on you, and you took the money and ran—even left the kid! Now that I’ve found you, come home with me!”

A man was dragging a woman, with a middle-aged woman beside him.

They looked angry, shouting accusations. The woman being dragged looked terrified.

“I’m not, I didn’t, you’ve got the wrong person!” The woman struggled, but was too weak and was being pulled away.

She tried to twist free, but the man’s grip was too strong. My fists clenched at my sides.

The crowd gossiped, but no one stepped in.

People just watched, some filming on their phones. I couldn’t believe no one was helping.

“You heartless woman! That was all our savings, and you left our little boy who cries for you every day—how could you!”

The woman tried to slap the girl, but I caught her wrist.

My reflexes kicked in. I stepped between them, holding the woman’s arm firmly.

“Who are you?” she snapped. “Are you with her? Are you a scammer too?”

She glared at me, but I didn’t flinch. I glanced at the girl and recognized her immediately.

I glanced at the panicked girl—sure enough, it was Chloe. This girl really had some bad luck.

I sighed inwardly. Chloe was a magnet for trouble, apparently.

I pulled the man off and threw him to the ground, then pinned the woman on top of him and put my foot on her back.

It was over in seconds. The crowd gasped, some people cheering quietly.

Ignoring the crowd, I pulled out my phone and called the police.

I kept my voice calm, giving them the details. I could feel everyone’s eyes on me.

“Hi, I need to report an assault by Maplewood Mall. Please send someone.”

I made sure to speak loudly, so everyone knew help was on the way.

Hearing me, the crowd stopped moving.

People started whispering, unsure what to do next.

I raised my voice. “Everyone here’s a witness. No one leaves until the police get here.”

I gave them my best coach’s stare, daring anyone to argue.

“There are cameras everywhere. Anyone who leaves now looks suspicious.”

I pointed to the security cameras overhead, making my point crystal clear.

After that, no one left. We waited until the police arrived—the same officer as before.

He recognized me, giving me a tired smile. “You again?” I just shrugged.

After giving statements, it was already afternoon. I packed up and hurried to Julian’s house.

I checked my phone—dozens of texts from Julian, making sure I was okay.

“Sis, are you going to Julian’s house?” Chloe caught up to me.

She jogged over, out of breath but smiling.

“Yeah.”

I tried to sound casual, but I was still a little shaken from earlier.

“Were you going to buy a gift? Sorry for delaying you because of me. I just bought something—you can use it.”

She handed me a gift box. I glanced—it was a box of vitamins for seniors.

I tried not to laugh. It was practical, at least.

“No, no,” I quickly waved her off.

I didn’t want to take her gift, but she insisted, pressing it into my hands.

“Take it,” she insisted, shoving it into my hands before hopping in a car and leaving.

She waved as the car pulled away, leaving me standing there, gift in hand.

I scratched my head. Oh well, it’ll do for now—I’ll return it next time.

I tucked it into my bag, making a mental note to buy something more personal next time.

By the time I arrived at Julian’s house, I was over two hours late.

His mom met me at the door, waving off my apologies. “Family first, honey. Come on in.”

But I’d called him on the way, and his family was very welcoming.

They ushered me inside, making sure I had a plate of food and a seat at the table.

An hour later, the doorbell rang and Chloe came in.

She looked a little nervous, but Grandma Carter greeted her warmly.

“Chloe, you’re here.” Grandma Carter held my hand and greeted her. “Come, let me introduce you—this is Julian’s girlfriend, Savannah.”

She squeezed my hand, her eyes twinkling with approval. I felt my nerves settle a bit.

“Grandma Carter, happy birthday.” Chloe handed over her gift—a scarf, the classic present.

It was beautifully wrapped, and Grandma Carter beamed as she opened it.

“Thank you, Chloe. Have some fruit,” Grandma Carter said, inviting her to sit.

She patted the seat beside her, making room for both of us.

“Sis, thank you for earlier,” Chloe said to me.

She leaned in, her voice barely above a whisper. I nodded, smiling.

“Hm?” Grandma Carter looked at her, then at me, confused. “You two know each other?”

She raised an eyebrow, clearly curious.

“I was in trouble earlier, and Savannah helped me. That’s why she was late.”

Chloe spoke up, her tone earnest. I could see Grandma Carter’s eyes widen in surprise.

“Oh?” Grandma Carter’s eyes lit up, and she smiled, patting my hand. “Savannah is amazing.”

She squeezed my hand again, pride shining in her eyes. I felt a rush of warmth.

After dinner, I saw Chloe alone in the yard. I was about to thank her for the gift when I saw Julian walk over.

He looked serious, his hands shoved in his pockets. I hung back, curious about what would happen.

I leaned against the porch railing, pretending to check my phone.

“Chloe, I remember making it clear—I don’t like you. Please stop pestering me,” Julian said first.

His voice was gentle but firm. I could tell he hated confrontation, but he was determined to be honest.

Chloe replied slowly, without turning around, “I don’t like you anymore, and I’m not pestering you.”

She sounded tired, like she’d rehearsed this line a hundred times.

“Then why did you come to my house today?”

He sounded genuinely confused, not angry.

“Savannah was late. I had to explain, or the elders might misunderstand her.”

She spoke quietly, her voice steady. I felt a pang of gratitude.

“You’re that kind-hearted?” Julian sounded skeptical.

He raised an eyebrow, clearly not convinced.

Chloe turned, looked him up and down. “To be honest, I think you’re pretty ordinary now. I don’t like you at all.”

She grinned, a little mischievous. I had to hide a smile.

She lowered her eyes and chuckled. “But Savannah is very interesting.”

She glanced at me, her eyes sparkling with something like admiration.

“You...” Julian started, but Chloe cut him off.

She waved him off, turning her back on him.

“Sis.” She ran over and took my arm.

She linked her arm through mine, pulling me away from Julian.

“Sis, don’t worry. I don’t like Julian, and I won’t bother him.”

She said it with a little pout, but I could tell she meant it.

“Mm.” I nodded, not sure what else to say.

I patted her hand, feeling a little awkward but grateful.

“Sis, I promised to treat you to barbecue. Let’s go tomorrow,” Chloe said sweetly, making me want to pinch her cheeks.

She looked up at me, eyes wide and hopeful. I couldn’t say no.

“Okay.” I nodded. She’d lent me a gift, so I couldn’t refuse a meal.

I smiled, already thinking about what to order.

“Julian, girls’ gatherings shouldn’t include you, right? Even if we’re dating, girls need their own space,” Chloe said, turning to Julian.

She stuck her tongue out at him, making me laugh.

Wait, I’m not that close with her—eating alone would be awkward.

I bit my lip, wondering if this was a setup.

Julian closed his eyes, pursed his lips, glanced at Chloe, and said softly, “Of course. Have fun.”

He gave me a reassuring smile, as if to say he trusted me.

So when I went out with Chloe the next day, I was still a bit confused.

I fiddled with my napkin, trying to think of conversation starters.

I didn’t know much, and we weren’t close.

I wondered if we’d have anything to talk about besides Julian.

“Sis, how did you and Julian meet?” Chloe asked, seeing I was uneasy.

She leaned forward, genuinely curious. I relaxed a little, happy to tell the story.

That, I knew. So I chatted away, telling her how I met Julian.

I got animated, gesturing with my hands as I described our first meeting at the gym.

Chloe narrowed her eyes thoughtfully. “Is that so?”

She tapped her chin, looking like she was plotting something.

“Hm?” I looked at her, puzzled.

I tilted my head, waiting for her to explain.

“Sis, so you’re a great martial arts coach!” Her eyes sparkled with admiration.

She looked genuinely impressed. I felt my cheeks heat up.

Embarrassed, I scratched my head. “Ah, just average.”

I waved her off, trying to downplay it.

“Sis, I want to learn martial arts from you!” She grabbed my hand.

Her grip was surprisingly strong. I blinked, surprised by her enthusiasm.

“Uh... that might not be the best idea.” She looked so delicate.

I glanced at her sundress, imagining her trying to spar. It was a funny picture.

“Sis, look at me—I’m so unlucky. If I can’t defend myself, what if I get in trouble again?”

She gave me puppy eyes, and I felt my resolve crumble.

She shivered, eyes brimming with tears.

She really knew how to play the sympathy card.

“Sure, sure, you can learn!” I nodded, patting her shoulder.

I gave in, unable to resist her pleading.

“Sis, you’re so nice,” Chloe said, leaning her head on my shoulder.

She snuggled up, and I patted her awkwardly. This was definitely new territory for me.

Uh... this felt a little weird.

I glanced around, hoping no one was watching us.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

I Loved Her, Then I Let Go
I Loved Her, Then I Let Go
4.9
He always did the right thing—even when it broke his heart. Dylan Brooks, the self-proclaimed 'honest guy,' thought marrying Savannah—the city’s most notorious heartbreaker—would finally make him enough. But Savannah’s beauty hides cold indifference and a string of betrayals, and Dylan’s loyalty is tested past its breaking point. When a midnight confrontation exposes the final lie, Dylan is forced to decide: does honesty mean staying true to her, or finally to himself? In a world obsessed with appearances, can the man who never lied learn to keep one secret of his own? What happens when the honest guy walks away first?
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
4.7
I thought we were planning our future, but behind my back, my girlfriend was sneaking around with her high school crush. I uncovered their affair one photo, one deleted message at a time—while she played the perfect fiancée, he played the doting fiancé to someone else. Now I’m left with the truth: I was just her cover story, and their betrayal cuts deeper than any lie.
Lipstick on His Collar, Lies in My Heart
Lipstick on His Collar, Lies in My Heart
4.9
I thought I’d married the perfect man—until I found the lipstick stain on his collar and the apartment across town he kept for her. In Maple Heights, everyone praised our union, but behind the white-picket fences, my heart was breaking. Nathaniel’s betrayals forced me to choose: play the dignified wife, or lose myself entirely. As the women around me whispered that this was just 'the way of men,' I clung to my pride, even as my marriage unraveled. But when a mysterious stranger’s smile lights up my lonely world, I begin to wonder—can I break free, or am I doomed to live a lie? When love is a game of appearances, who dares to want more?
He Loved Her, Not Me
He Loved Her, Not Me
4.9
He loved her—just not me. On the night of our fourth anniversary, I watched Carter Langley slip further away, his heart claimed by another while our marriage became nothing but a headline. I was supposed to smile, play the perfect wife, and pretend not to notice the pitying looks or the silence that suffocated our home. But pain demands a witness. When betrayal cuts deeper than bone, how far will a woman go to make her absence felt? Carter’s indifference is legendary—until my final act leaves him with a haunting question and a secret he can never bury. If love is dead, what’s left for the living to regret?
I Loved Him—Then He Shattered Me
I Loved Him—Then He Shattered Me
4.9
He was always supposed to be the boy who protected me—but on the night I finally confessed, I learned just how fragile love can be. When Noah, my childhood fiancé, betrays me with the prom queen, my world shatters overnight. Forced to break our engagement and leave everything behind, I vow never to look back. But fate—and one stolen cat—pulls me into a final showdown I never wanted. Now, with heartbreak and hope warring inside me, I have to decide: can I ever trust him again, or is this goodbye forever? When the person you love most is the one who hurts you deepest, is a second chance ever worth the risk?
He Paid Me to Break His Heart
He Paid Me to Break His Heart
4.9
A public confession, a thousand-dollar challenge, and a year-long contract: when Autumn, the overachieving tutor, turns the tables on her school's notorious bad boy, their fake relationship explodes into a high-stakes game of power, pride, and betrayal. With every payment, Jason’s grades soar—but so does the risk, as rumors swirl and secrets threaten to unravel everything. When a cruel prank exposes Autumn’s deepest humiliation, she refuses to play the victim, vowing to rewrite the ending of her own story. But as their rivalry turns to something more—and a dangerous race pushes them both to the edge—Autumn must decide: can she trust the boy who once broke her, or is winning the only way to survive senior year? Who will walk away with their heart—and who will be left behind?
I Broke His Heart to Save Him
I Broke His Heart to Save Him
4.6
Natalie knows she’s just a side character destined to lose everything—the boy she loves, her family’s future, even her own dignity. To protect Caleb from a fate worse than heartbreak, she stages a brutal betrayal, forcing him to hate her before destiny tears them apart. But every lie she tells cuts deeper than the truth, and no one can ever know the real reason she let him go.
His Secret Girlfriend for Seven Years
His Secret Girlfriend for Seven Years
4.8
For seven years, I loved America’s hottest pop star in silence—always his secret, always called by another woman’s name. On my birthday, he humiliated me in front of Hollywood’s elite, making it clear I was just a stand-in for his first love. But now, with my hearing restored and my heart shattered, I’m ready to expose every lie and take back the life—and the music—he stole from me.
She Lied on Our Anniversary Night
She Lied on Our Anniversary Night
4.9
Betrayal doesn’t knock—it crashes through the door on the night you need love most. Tyler’s seventh anniversary ends in heartbreak as he discovers his longtime girlfriend entangled with a powerful stranger, shattering every illusion he’s clung to for years. Now stripped of family, fortune, and trust, Tyler faces a cruel game where his mother’s only keepsake is the prize and his own dignity is on the line. As lies multiply and enemies close in, he must decide: will he confront the people who broke him, or walk away from the ruins of his past for good? When everything you loved becomes a weapon—what’s left to fight for?
He Left Me, But I Paid the Price
He Left Me, But I Paid the Price
4.9
Some endings are silent, but the ache never is. I thought Eli and I were forever—until a single betrayal tore us apart, leaving me clutching memories and a cheap county fair kite. Years later, I’m called back to his side as his emergency contact, thrown into a whirlwind of old wounds and unfinished business. He’s surrounded by new admirers, but the past still claws at both of us. I want closure, maybe even forgiveness, but Eli only offers distance. My friends say I’m a fool for loving him, but they never saw the sacrifices he made, the debts unpaid. Now, as I watch him slip away for the last time, I’m haunted by one question: Was I the one holding him back—or was he always running from something he could never name? If love is letting go, why does it hurt so much to set him free?
He Died for the Lie She Told
He Died for the Lie She Told
4.9
He lost his son to a lie—and now, he’s got nothing left to lose. When Mark Grant’s only child is branded a predator and driven to suicide, the world shrugs and moves on. But Mark can’t let go—not when he overhears the golden girl’s chilling confession: it was all a setup for a college spot. Facing the rich and ruthless Taylors, Mark crashes through grief and rage, demanding justice in a world that only cares about connections. When hush money is thrown at his feet and the police look the other way, Mark’s fury threatens to explode—unless he can prove his son’s innocence before the truth is buried for good. How far will a father go when the whole system is rigged against him?
I Was Her Backup—Until I Broke
I Was Her Backup—Until I Broke
4.9
I was always her backup plan—until she asked me to take the fall for a mistake that wasn’t mine. When Lila, my childhood friend and the girl I secretly loved, showed up sobbing and pregnant, I was supposed to save her like always. But this time, I’m done being the background character in my own story. In a high school ruled by secrets and SAT scores, reputations are everything and rumors spread faster than wildfire. When Lila’s new boyfriend pushes me too far, old loyalties snap and I’m left with nothing but the truth: I can’t keep fixing what’s broken, not when I’m the one left shattered. But as Lila’s world unravels and she begs me to step up, I’m forced to decide—will I finally fight for myself, or let her drag me down one last time? What happens when the backup refuses to play along?