He Loved Her, But Not Me / Chapter 3: Promises Across Lifetimes
He Loved Her, But Not Me

He Loved Her, But Not Me

Author: Martin Graves DVM


Chapter 3: Promises Across Lifetimes

But no one knew that this was actually the second time Mason and I had met in this life. Would anyone believe me if I told them?

It was a secret I carried alone, tucked away like a pressed flower in a forgotten book. Sometimes, I wondered if it was real—or just a dream I couldn’t wake up from. Maybe I was crazy.

In our previous life, I didn’t want to be just another piece in the family game, so I ran away.

I left in the middle of the night, suitcase in hand, heart pounding. I thought I was being brave, carving out my own destiny. Turns out, running is easy—what comes after is the hard part. No one tells you about the after.

After three years of hiding in a small town under a fake name, I was kidnapped by criminals demanding ransom. I never thought it could happen to me.

It was the kind of story you see on the news, never expecting it to happen to you. One minute I was blending in, the next I was a headline waiting to happen. I was just another missing girl.

Everything spiraled, and the kidnappers dragged me deep into the woods.

The forest was thick and dark, every branch a threat. I remember the smell of pine, the crunch of leaves underfoot, the terror that never let up. I was so scared.

I was beaten, insulted, utterly humiliated. They took everything.

They took everything—my dignity, my hope, my voice. I learned how to disappear, even when someone was looking right at me. I became invisible.

Later, Mason saved me. He always did.

He showed up like a ghost, silent and determined. I barely recognized him at first, but I’d know those eyes anywhere. He looked different. Older. Harder.

He’d become a sheriff’s deputy, going undercover alone. He even lost an arm in the process. All for me.

I still remember the blood, the panic, the way he gritted his teeth and kept going. He never once complained, not even when the pain must have been unbearable. He was stronger than anyone.

I recognized him instantly, but didn’t dare speak, pretending to be mute. I was too ashamed.

I was scared—of what he’d think, of what I’d done. It was easier to stay silent, to pretend I was someone else. I hid behind silence.

Being rescued by the man I’d once run away from marrying made me want to disappear.

I couldn’t meet his eyes. Every kindness felt like a debt I’d never repay. I owed him everything.

But Mason was good to me. To hide from the kidnappers, we holed up in an old ranger’s cabin. He gave me all the food, helped me drink water, bandaged my wounds. He took care of me. No questions asked.

He was gentle, patient. He hummed old country songs under his breath, trying to keep my spirits up. Sometimes, I caught him staring at the stars through the window, lost in thought. I wondered what he was thinking.

He spoke gently, telling me not to be afraid, that someone would find us.

His voice was steady, a lifeline in the darkness. I clung to his words, even when I didn’t believe them. They were all I had.

The kinder he was, the more bitter I felt inside. Kindness hurt.

It was a strange kind of pain, being cared for by someone you’d hurt. I wanted to apologize, but the words stuck in my throat. I couldn’t say a thing.

So when the kidnappers caught up to us, I threw myself in front of him and took a knife for him. Mason’s face was filled with shock. I’d do it again.

He shouted my name, voice cracking. I’d never seen him look so scared. He looked broken.

I saw panic and anger and something else in his eyes, but he quickly subdued the kidnapper and calmly stopped my bleeding.

Even in chaos, Mason was all action—never panic. He tore his shirt, pressed it to my wound, whispered that I was going to be okay. He made me believe it.

My voice was barely there. “Mason, can you promise me one thing?”

My voice was weak, barely a whisper. I could feel the world fading around the edges. Everything was slipping away.

I coughed up blood, feeling my life slipping away. So cold.

The metallic taste filled my mouth, sharp and bitter. I was so cold, but Mason’s hands were warm. I held on.

“Say it. You saved my life—I’ll do anything.”

He leaned in close, eyes shining. I could see the tears he tried to hide. He never cried.

I tried to smile, but couldn’t lift the corners of my mouth. “Next life, I hope I can meet you again. I hope you’ll give me another chance.” That’s all I wanted. Another chance.

It was all I could think to ask for. A do-over, a shot at getting things right. Maybe I didn’t deserve it.

I shouldn’t have selfishly run away and let Mason be ridiculed. Shouldn’t have run south and gotten him hurt trying to save me. (I ran away—left town, changed my name, hid as far south as I could go.)

Regret is a heavy thing. I wanted to make it right, even if it was too late. I owed him that much.

I hoped that in the next life, I’d meet you again. To make up for my mistakes, to redeem myself. Maybe then I’d be braver.

Maybe then, things would end differently. Maybe I’d be brave enough to stay. Maybe.

But now I finally understood—fate loves to toy with you, and it’s cold as ice.

No matter how hard you wish, some stories just aren’t meant to change. Fate is stubborn, and heartbreak is its favorite punchline. I learned that the hard way.

You may also like

He Loved Her, Not Me
He Loved Her, Not Me
4.9
He loved her—just not me. On the night of our fourth anniversary, I watched Carter Langley slip further away, his heart claimed by another while our marriage became nothing but a headline. I was supposed to smile, play the perfect wife, and pretend not to notice the pitying looks or the silence that suffocated our home. But pain demands a witness. When betrayal cuts deeper than bone, how far will a woman go to make her absence felt? Carter’s indifference is legendary—until my final act leaves him with a haunting question and a secret he can never bury. If love is dead, what’s left for the living to regret?
He Loved Me, But Never Said It
He Loved Me, But Never Said It
4.5
For seven years, Natalie loved Caleb—a brilliant, deaf scholarship boy who always kept her at arm’s length, no matter how hard she tried to bridge the silence. Humiliated at reunions, left out of weddings, and ignored by the man she thought was her forever, Natalie discovers the ring he never gave her and the secret he always hid: he was never sure he deserved her love. Now, standing on the edge of heartbreak, Natalie must decide if love can survive when the words are never spoken.
He Left Me, But I Paid the Price
He Left Me, But I Paid the Price
4.9
Some endings are silent, but the ache never is. I thought Eli and I were forever—until a single betrayal tore us apart, leaving me clutching memories and a cheap county fair kite. Years later, I’m called back to his side as his emergency contact, thrown into a whirlwind of old wounds and unfinished business. He’s surrounded by new admirers, but the past still claws at both of us. I want closure, maybe even forgiveness, but Eli only offers distance. My friends say I’m a fool for loving him, but they never saw the sacrifices he made, the debts unpaid. Now, as I watch him slip away for the last time, I’m haunted by one question: Was I the one holding him back—or was he always running from something he could never name? If love is letting go, why does it hurt so much to set him free?
He Loved Me When I Let Go
He Loved Me When I Let Go
4.9
Love isn’t supposed to feel like a fight for survival—unless the person you can’t let go is the one tearing you apart. Savannah married Mason at his lowest, believing loyalty could heal everything. But as he claws his way back to power, Mason’s coldness grows, and his fragile stepsister Grace becomes a weapon in their war of hearts. Every cut, every rumor, every silent night pushes Savannah closer to breaking—until she signs up to disappear, and he barely notices. But the games aren’t over. When heartbreak turns to scandal and every memory burns, Savannah must choose: keep fighting for a man who only looks back when she’s gone, or finally walk away for good. Will Mason chase her into the storm—or let her vanish forever?
He Loved My Sacrifice, Not Me
He Loved My Sacrifice, Not Me
4.7
Natalie gave up everything—even her Olympic dreams—to protect Caleb, only to discover years later that he never loved her, only repaid a debt. Betrayed by the boy she trusted most and humiliated by his cruel friends, she finally reads the journal that shatters her last hope. Now, with his first love back in town, Natalie must choose: cling to the ghost of his gratitude, or walk away and reclaim her pride before she loses herself forever.
He Loved Me—For Someone Else
He Loved Me—For Someone Else
5.0
Love should heal, not destroy—but Chris learns the difference too late. On the night he hopes to share life-changing news with Ethan, betrayal shatters everything: a devastating accident, a truth that cuts deeper than any wound, and a loss that leaves him hollow. Five years of devotion collapse in a single moment, forcing Chris to burn every bridge and rewrite his future. But when a chance encounter with a mysterious, wounded pianist sparks something unexpected, Chris must decide if hope is worth the risk—or if he’s too broken to try again. Can a heart that’s been used and discarded ever truly trust again? Or is Chris destined to haunt the ruins of his past, while love plays on without him?
I Loved Her Twice—She Chose Me Last
I Loved Her Twice—She Chose Me Last
5.0
He gave up his dreams for her—only to watch her heart belong to someone else. When Logan Carter sacrifices his future in the city for Mariah, the girl he’s loved since childhood, he finds himself torn between loyalty and heartbreak after she chooses another in the mountains. But fate isn’t done with him yet: a second chance rewinds the clock, giving Logan a shot at rewriting his own story. As Mariah’s world collides with his once more—this time with confessions, rivalries, and a love that refuses to die—Logan must decide: will he risk everything for her again, or finally choose himself? When the past and present crash together, whose love will survive the avalanche? What if the one you let go comes running back when you’ve finally moved on?
I Loved Him First, But She Stayed
I Loved Him First, But She Stayed
4.9
Some heartbreaks go viral. When Ellie stumbles upon a brutal online confession from the 'other girl,' she realizes her boyfriend Noah—the boy who once crossed continents for her—might not be hers anymore. A promise ring tossed in the trash, a hometown gym filled with whispers, and a new girl glowing in his orbit: Ellie is forced to watch the life she built unravel in real time. But as she retraces every stolen glance and summer vow, she’s haunted by one question: Did she lose Noah to fate—or to the girl who showed up too late? In a world where love can vanish with a single post, can Ellie reclaim her ending, or will she always be the girl who came first—and lost anyway?
His Heart Belonged to Her First
His Heart Belonged to Her First
4.7
Everyone in Maple Heights knew Caleb Hart never kept a girl for long—and I was no exception. I thought I was different, until I learned I was just a stand-in for his first love, the girl he never let go. When she returns, I have to decide: stay and be second best, or walk away before I lose myself completely.
He Hates Me, But I Stay
He Hates Me, But I Stay
4.9
Natalie has spent three years trying to save Tyler, a brilliant artist trapped in darkness, but his coldness is breaking her spirit. When the charming Mia enters Tyler’s life, Natalie faces a gut-wrenching choice: let him go and risk losing herself, or fight for a boy who might never want her in his corner. One message could end everything—or start something neither of them expects.
He Chose Her Over Me
He Chose Her Over Me
5.0
Natalie always believed her childhood love with Derek would last forever—until a wild outsider named Aubrey crashes into their lives, stealing his affection and her family's loyalty. Betrayed and replaced, Natalie must fight for her place in a small town where secrets, jealousy, and heartbreak simmer beneath the surface. She’s about to prove she’s nobody’s backup plan.
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
5.0
He was supposed to fall for someone else. I was supposed to be the villain—until fate, a stubborn transmigrator, and a broken story system rewrote our lines. When I deliver a love letter for the third time to Carter Hayes, the boy I grew up with (and maybe secretly loved), I spark a confession that upends everything: Carter likes me, not the 'main girl.' But our world isn’t real—it's a story fighting to snap back into place, and every choice risks erasing us for good. As mysterious tasks, forbidden kisses, and heart-stopping resets threaten to tear us apart, I have to ask: Can love survive when the universe demands we play our roles? Or will the villain finally get her happily ever after—no matter what the script says?