I Became the Villain’s Favorite Pawn / Chapter 2: The Lady’s Ruthless Welcome
I Became the Villain’s Favorite Pawn

I Became the Villain’s Favorite Pawn

Author: Jonathan Cox


Chapter 2: The Lady’s Ruthless Welcome

That’s when everything changed. In the Whitmore Mansion, I met the Lady of the House.

The most honored, most favored, and happiest woman in the land. Or so everyone said.

She moved through the halls like she owned the air itself, every step measured, every glance calculated. People bowed their heads when she passed, afraid to meet her eyes.

The Lady was the daughter of Senator Langley. That meant money, power, and a family tree with roots deeper than most could imagine.

Her family’s reach was long. Even the staff whispered about her at night, half in awe, half in terror.

They said she was Mr. Whitmore’s first love, the woman he’d adored since he was young. Their love story was legend among the old-money set.

It was the kind of story people gossiped about over cocktails—half envy, half disbelief. Everyone wanted a love like theirs, or at least wanted to believe it was real.

Back when the previous Mr. Whitmore was alive, our current Mr. Whitmore was just the son of a housemaid—no status, no shot at inheritance. Nobody saw it coming—the bloodbath over the inheritance. Six sons, all fighting for the family fortune. It was a mess.

The old man’s will was a ticking time bomb, and when it went off, it took everyone with it. By the end, only the least likely son was left standing.

All the capable sons were gone, and so the unremarkable Whitmore became the heir, snatching up control of the family like a prize nobody wanted.

They called it fate. Fate? Please. I called it survival of the most ruthless. The world didn’t care about bloodlines—only about who was left to sweep up the mess.

As for the Lady, she was originally the fiancée of the former heir. Later, she helped the current Whitmore eliminate the former heir and became the one woman he could never let go of—his unattainable first love. So, after he took over, he made her Lady of the House.

It was a scandal, but no one dared say a word. Around here, power was the only law that mattered. You either bent the rules or got bent by them.

But five years after his ascension, the Lady still hadn’t produced a son. The family was buzzing. Three years ago, the head of the family had no choice but to order all council members of fifth rank or above (senior council) to send an unmarried daughter into the mansion.

It was like a twisted beauty pageant. Fathers wrung their hands, mothers cried in secret, daughters prayed to be overlooked.

As luck would have it, my father was a councilman and had two daughters. He had to send one.

He couldn’t bear to choose, so he made my sister and me draw lots. I can still see his hands shaking as he held out the slips of paper. My mother sobbed quietly in the corner, her face hidden in her hands.

The lot fell to me. Figures.

My heart sank. I tried to hide it, but the world felt like it was tilting right out from under me.

But on the day I was to enter the mansion, my sister drugged me and went in my place. Betrayal tastes bitter, even when it’s wrapped in love. I woke up with a pounding headache and a note pressed into my palm, my mind reeling.

She left me a letter, saying she knew I came from another world and didn’t want to share a husband with others, so she took my place. She’d always been the brave one.

Her handwriting was steady. She didn’t even sound scared. She told me to live my life, to be free in a way she never could.

My sister was smart and dignified. Everyone knew it.

She could walk into a room and own it with a single glance. People listened when she spoke—even the haters.

Once in the mansion, she caught Mr. Whitmore’s eye, and even the matriarch’s. Before long, she was on track to become a favored consort—until a string of miscarriages struck the household.

Rumors spread like wildfire. Every whispered accusation landed at her feet. She kept her head high, but I knew it was only a matter of time.

After an investigation, all the evidence pointed to my sister.

It didn’t matter if it was true. In this world, what people believed was all that mattered. The truth was just background noise.

Mr. Whitmore was furious and handed her over to the Lady for punishment. That beautiful, dignified Lady had my sister mutilated and sent home as a living corpse.

No trial, no mercy. Just a sentence carried out behind closed doors, away from prying eyes.

The Lady’s voice rang out above me: “You’re the new beauty from Silver Hollow?”

Her tone was ice-cold, but her words dripped with honey. My heart hammered in my chest as I kept my eyes glued to the floor.

I bowed my head obediently. “Yes.”

My voice was barely above a whisper, but it carried in the silent room. I could feel every eye on me, weighing, judging. I fought the urge to run.

She spoke: “Lift your head.”

The command left no room for argument. I swallowed hard and raised my chin, forcing myself to meet her gaze.

So I did, and saw the legendary Lady Whitmore. She truly was a stunning beauty—no wonder she was so adored. I got it, instantly.

Her features were sharp, almost regal. There was a coldness in her eyes that made me shiver, even as she smiled.

Even after marrying the former heir, she became Lady to the new head of the family.

She’d survived more than anyone knew. I wondered what it cost her.

She had the pedigree. Born into power, married into more. She wore her status like armor.

The Lady looked down at me as if I were an ant. When she saw my face, her expression flickered, then she smiled, but it never reached her eyes. “The Silver Hollow girl really does have a beautiful face.”

It was the kind of compliment that could cut you to pieces. I didn’t flinch.

I lowered my eyes. “Next to you, I’m nothing but background, my Lady.”

The words tasted strange in my mouth, like lines from a fairy tale. But it was the sort of thing people expected to hear in a house like this.

My sister and I looked nothing alike.

She was all soft lines and gentle smiles, while I was sharp angles and restless energy. People used to joke we couldn’t possibly be related.

She took after our father. I looked like our mother—sharp brows, striking, gorgeous.

My mother’s beauty was the kind that made people talk. She hid it away, hoping the world would forget.

Not the kind of looks considered proper in this world. After marrying my father, my mother rarely went out, afraid of gossip, and kept me at home too.

She said it was for my own good, but I always wondered if she was just trying to protect herself. Maybe both.

So hardly anyone in the city had seen us. Even those who had didn’t know I was Judge Harper’s second daughter. I had no reason to worry the Lady would recognize me.

It was a small mercy, one I clung to with both hands.

My obedient attitude pleased her. She didn’t make things hard, just waved me away. As I was about to leave, Mr. Whitmore arrived.

His footsteps echoed in the marble hallway, slow and deliberate. You could feel the temperature drop as soon as he entered. The air prickled with tension.

The Lady immediately greeted him: “Darling, what brings you here at this hour?”

Her voice softened, her whole demeanor shifting. She moved toward him like a moth to a flame.

He replied, “Have you forgotten? I promised to have lunch with you.”

He smiled, the kind of smile that never quite reached his eyes. I wondered how many times he’d used that same line before.

The Lady brightened. “I thought you’d forgotten!”

She laughed, a sound that was almost genuine. For a moment, I saw the girl she must have been, before all of this.

He pinched her cheek. “How could I forget something like that?”

It was a practiced gesture, but she ate it up. The room seemed to shrink around them.

Then his gaze landed on me. “Who’s this?”

His eyes were sharp, missing nothing. I felt like a bug under a microscope.

The Lady looked annoyed that I was interrupting her time with her husband, but she had to answer: “Just a new girl.”

She waved a dismissive hand, as if I were a stray cat that had wandered in by accident.

He said, “Oh, from Silver Hollow?”

He turned to me, waiting for my answer. I kept my head down, careful not to meet his gaze.

I bowed my head respectfully. “Yes, sir. I’m Savannah Lin, daughter of Mayor Lin of Silver Hollow. It’s an honor to meet you.”

My voice was steady, but my heart was pounding so loud I was sure they could hear it.

I’d entered the estate as Savannah Lin, daughter of the Mayor of Silver Hollow.

The name fit like a borrowed coat—strange at first, but comforting in its own way. I barely recognized myself.

Silver Hollow was remote—mountains and rivers far from the city. Mr. Whitmore was wary of rebellion there, so during the last selection, he ordered Mayor Lin to send his daughter to the mansion.

People whispered that Silver Hollow was a world apart, a place where the old rules didn’t apply. I hoped that distance would keep me safe, at least for a while.

At the time, Savannah Lin was too young to enter, so they thought they’d escaped. But Mr. Whitmore decreed she’d be sent in as soon as she came of age.

No one ever really escaped. The past always caught up, one way or another.

Last year was the right time, but she broke both legs in an accident and couldn’t go. Her father reported this, delaying for another year.

I’d heard the story from the maids—how she’d thrown herself down the stairs, desperate to avoid the mansion. It made me like her, just a little.

But everyone knew they couldn’t keep stalling. Savannah Lin was wild—so wild she broke her own legs to avoid the mansion. That took guts.

In another life, we might have been friends.

So I showed up in Silver Hollow, took her identity, and entered the mansion as a consort.

It wasn’t the first time I’d stepped into someone else’s life, but it was the first time it felt like I was trying to save someone, not just myself.

I had to find out why the Lady was so ruthless—why she’d tortured my sister so horribly.

I repeated it like a mantra every night before I slept. I owed my sister that much.

I had to avenge my sister!

No matter what it cost me. No matter how long it took. I whispered it to myself, over and over.

As soon as I finished speaking, I felt a cold, sharp gaze on me. Then the Lady said, “Darling, I had your favorite pan-fried trout prepared.”

Her words snapped the tension, but the chill lingered in the air. It didn’t help.

Mr. Whitmore smiled. “Really?”

He sounded almost surprised, as if he’d forgotten what it was like to be cared for.

“Let’s go see what you’ve made.”

She slipped her arm through his, her smile bright and brittle. Together, they left the room, leaving me standing in their wake.

One of the Lady’s maids sneered, “Shameless little vixen, trying to seduce Mr. Whitmore right in front of the Lady.”

Her voice was sharp, meant to wound. I bit my tongue, refusing to give her the satisfaction of a reaction. Not today.

She shoved me roughly. “Get out of here. Are you trying to interrupt their meal?”

I stumbled, catching myself on the edge of a table. I kept my head down and walked away, my cheeks burning.

I said nothing, just quietly left the Whitmore Mansion’s grand hall.

The echo of their laughter followed me down the hallway, but I kept my back straight and my steps even.

Though I’d just entered the estate, I knew the Lady, for all her rank, was extremely jealous. Otherwise, why would Mr. Whitmore have waited five years before holding another selection?

Jealousy got into everything here. I’d seen it before, but never so raw, so unchecked.

As a girl raised in the modern world, I could understand the Lady’s feelings. What woman doesn’t want to have her beloved all to herself?

I’d watched enough soap operas to know how these stories ended. But living it was something else entirely.

But if that’s what she wanted, she shouldn’t have allowed the selection, or fed her own jealousy so much.

It was like lighting a match and then complaining about the fire. No one in this house was truly innocent—not even me.

My sister, and all the other women forced into the mansion—how innocent were they, to be caught up in the couple’s emotional games?

We were all pawns, shuffled and sacrificed at someone else’s whim.

After my sister entered the mansion for me, she told me she understood the bond between Mr. Whitmore and the Lady, had no intention of vying for favor, just wanted to survive quietly.

She’d written it in her letter, the ink smudged from her tears. She never wanted to be a threat. She just wanted to live. She just wanted peace.

She said dozens of women entered the mansion that time, and she wasn’t the most outstanding. As long as she was careful, she wouldn’t offend the Lady.

She tried so hard to stay invisible, to be just another face in the crowd. It wasn’t enough.

Besides, Mr. Whitmore had agreed to the selection; as Lady, she should be gracious.

It was the unspoken rule—if you open the door, you can’t complain about who walks through it.

She often paid respects to the matriarch, and there were plenty of other ambitious, exceptional women in the mansion. The Lady didn’t notice my sister until news of her pregnancy came out. Even then, though my sister wasn’t favored, she became a thorn in the Lady’s side.

Pregnancy changed everything. Suddenly, she was a rival, whether she wanted to be or not. That’s how it worked here.

But with the matriarch’s protection, there was nothing the Lady could do. My sister only gave birth to a daughter, which eased the Lady’s mind.

A daughter wasn’t a threat—not in this world. The Lady relaxed, for a while.

Other women began having children, and a single daughter didn’t matter. The Lady ignored my sister and targeted others—until my sister quietly rose in rank and Mr. Whitmore started visiting her more often. Then the Lady finally saw her as a threat.

Favor was a dangerous thing. It could turn friends into enemies overnight. Nobody was safe.

That’s when the accusations started.

It started with whispers, then outright accusations. The walls seemed to close in, the air growing thick and heavy, pressing down on her.

All the evidence pointed to my sister harming other women and their children.

It was a setup—too neat, too perfect. But no one cared about the truth.

Truth is, if you want to frame someone, you’ll always find an excuse. People will believe whatever suits them. Always.

Sis, just wait. I’ll make that wretched woman pay for what she did to you!

I clenched my fists, heart pounding. This wasn’t over—not by a long shot.

You may also like

I Became the Villainess—He Became Obsessed
I Became the Villainess—He Became Obsessed
4.9
Death wasn’t my ending—it was my messed-up beginning. One moment, I’m a slacker picking a side role in a romance novel’s system; the next, I’m the villainess who’s supposed to die at the hands of a broken, beautiful male lead. To survive, I bluff my way into hiring him as my art model—only to find myself swept into moonlit road trips, secret wishes, and a slow-burn obsession neither of us can escape. Every sketch I draw peels back a layer of his pain, but when his wish is revealed, I realize the line between love and possession is razor thin. The system says his darkness is off the charts. I thought I could change the story—but now I’m trapped in his. Will I become the heroine he can’t let go, or just the next victim of his twisted devotion?
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
4.9
Falling for America’s sweetheart was never part of the script—but neither was waking up as the villain girl on a live gaming reality show. Now, every move I make is under the world’s microscope, every glance with Savannah (the girl I’m supposed to hate) becomes a viral ship, and my biggest rival is her gorgeous, mysterious brother. As alliances shift and the internet explodes with rumors, I have to decide: chase the win, protect my new friends, or risk it all for a love that’s as unexpected as my sudden fame. But with a possessive “lone wolf” prince and a meddling future mother-in-law in the mix, will my real happy ending survive the spotlight—or will I lose everything the moment the cameras stop rolling?
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
4.9
Waking up as the notorious villainess in a brutal historical romance novel was never part of my five-year plan. My job? Torment the wild heroine Nora and win over the cold-hearted male lead, Carter. With a mind-reading perk and my office-honed instincts, I thought I could outplay everyone—but Nora’s stubborn warmth and Carter’s hidden cruelty flip the script. As secrets unravel at glittering galas and county fairs, I realize the stakes are more than reputation or romance: it’s about rewriting fate itself. When my sabotage puts everyone in danger, loyalty and love collide in a final, fiery showdown. Can a mean girl rewrite her story—or is she doomed to play the villain forever?
I Was the Villain—Until I Woke Up
I Was the Villain—Until I Woke Up
4.9
I was supposed to be the villain—until I woke up in someone else’s story. Quinn Mason’s life is a borrowed dream: fake friends, borrowed luxury, and a script where she’s destined to fall. But when she discovers her rival Maddy is rigging the game with mind control and a supernatural support rating, Quinn realizes the only way to survive is to flip the script—before Maddy turns the world against her. With every move watched, every rumor weaponized, and every friend a potential traitor, Quinn’s only hope is to expose the truth without losing herself. But when the lines between reality and fiction blur, who decides who’s the real villain? In a world where popularity is power and the rules are always changing, can Quinn become the hero—or is she just another pawn in someone else’s Everworld?
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
5.0
Some stories are written for someone else, but what if you refused to follow the script? Autumn Sinclair has spent seven years as the villainous supporting girl in a world ruled by fate, heartbreak, and a heroine with supernatural luck. She’s loved the hero in silence, fought schemes she was never meant to win, and watched her every move become fuel for someone else’s glory. But when betrayal, murder, and the unraveling of every role collide at the center of Maple Heights, Autumn is forced to choose: stay trapped as a pawn, or break free and claim her own ending. With enemies lurking in plain sight and love hanging by a thread, can Autumn rewrite her story—or will she lose everything, including herself? When the script shatters, whose story survives?
The Villain Queen Claimed the Prisoner Prince
The Villain Queen Claimed the Prisoner Prince
4.8
Feared as the governor’s ruthless daughter, I chose the city’s most dangerous prisoner as my plaything—Marcus, the wild prince chained and muzzled beneath city hall. My half-sister begs for mercy, but I only want to break the man who threatens my family’s power. When I force a kiss on the caged beast, I know I’m tempting fate—and when he escapes, his revenge will be as savage as his love.
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
4.9
Being the villainess was never part of my plan—especially not in a small Southern town where everyone knows your secrets. When I wake up as Savannah Whitaker, the spoiled princess doomed to a tragic end, I decide to rewrite my fate: play matchmaker for the main couple, keep my head down, and maybe, just maybe, survive this story. But the plot has other ideas. The cold, dangerously handsome Mr. Carter isn't just my teacher—he’s the man I’m supposed to avoid, and he’s suddenly paying way too much attention. The gentle heroine, Elena, is as cunning as she is sweet, and every move I make only entangles me deeper in their world. Can I outsmart fate and claim my own happy ending, or will my attempts to change the story write my downfall? When the script flips, who gets to decide the ending?
Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
5.0
I always thought I was the heroine—until I watched the real one fall into the lake, and my memories snapped into place. Turns out, I’m Autumn Whitlock: the villainess doomed to destroy her own family, locked away by the man she loves, and forgotten by everyone. But this time, I’m rewriting my ending. When a staged tragedy nearly frames me, I risk everything to save my rival—only to be rescued myself by Sebastian Carter, the cold and powerful heir with secrets of his own. Now, as old alliances shift and the threat to my family grows, I must outwit the story’s script, bargain with the enemy, and confront a marriage proposal that could save—or ruin—us all. Can a villainess steal back her fate, or am I destined to lose everything I love, one calculated move at a time?
I’m the Villain Dad in Her Story
I’m the Villain Dad in Her Story
4.7
Everyone thinks I’m the cold, controlling father ruining my daughter’s life and my wife’s happiness. No one sees the years I spent sacrificing everything—until the voices in my head start cheering for my downfall. When my family finally pushes me too far, I decide to stop being their villain and walk away, but what happens when the ‘heroine’ daughter and ‘princess’ wife have to face the real world without their scapegoat?
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
5.0
Waking up as the tragic villain’s muse in a gothic romance, I thought I could dodge heartbreak and survive as a footnote. But when a cruel system ties my fate to Marcus Hawthorne—the brooding, misunderstood heir—I’m forced to play a deadly game where every wound he takes, I suffer. To survive, I must rewrite my doomed story, outsmart the hero and heroine, and win the villain’s trust without losing my heart. With assassins, poison, and forbidden secrets lurking in every shadow, every move could be my last. But as the line between enemy and lover blurs, I face an impossible choice: betray the man who could save me, or risk everything for a love that was never meant to exist. If you could rewrite your ending, would you dare to trust the villain?
Villain by Comment: I Quit Her Script
Villain by Comment: I Quit Her Script
4.9
Betrayal isn’t just a twist—it’s the script of my life. I thought I was the hero, sacrificing everything for my girlfriend’s family, until floating comments revealed the ugly truth: I’m just the villain in her story. When my girlfriend and her new lover vanish with my life savings, I’m left broken, blamed, and forced to confront the lies I called love. But this time, I’m done playing the fool. As public outrage explodes and secrets unravel on livestream, I fight to reclaim my future—even if it means tearing up the script and exposing the family that ruined me. Will walking away finally set me free, or is there one last twist waiting in the wings?
Rejected by My Alpha Wife, Reborn as the Villain
Rejected by My Alpha Wife, Reborn as the Villain
4.8
I married the ice-cold Alpha of Savannah to save her family, only to discover I was just a disposable villain in her twisted love story. After years of humiliation and heartbreak, I learn the shocking truth: my fate is to be betrayed and destroyed while she chases her true Omega. But this time, I refuse to play the fool—instead, I’ll rewrite the ending and make her regret ever casting me aside.