I Became the Villain’s Favorite Pawn / Chapter 3: Dance with Danger
I Became the Villain’s Favorite Pawn

I Became the Villain’s Favorite Pawn

Author: Jonathan Cox


Chapter 3: Dance with Danger

For the Harvest Gala, Mr. Whitmore wanted to celebrate with the household. The matriarch announced that everyone must perform a talent at the party.

The announcement sent the mansion into a frenzy. Seamstresses worked overtime, musicians tuned their instruments, and the kitchens filled with nervous laughter and whispered bets.

I heard the Lady was furious in her suite. The matriarch clearly wanted the women to compete for favor. Let the games begin.

She smashed a vase, according to the gossip, but there was nothing she could do. The matriarch’s word was law.

In this house, even the Lady had to bow to someone.

On the day of the gala, I prepared a girl-group dance.

It was risky, but I figured fortune favors the bold. I gathered a few of the younger women, taught them the moves, and tried not to laugh at their shocked faces.

Mr. Whitmore had seen every kind of traditional performance, and classic styles were hard to make truly captivating. I didn’t have other talents, so I came up with the idea of a girl group dance.

I pulled inspiration from music videos I’d watched back in my old life, blending modern pop with the elegance they expected. The effect was electric. They’d never seen anything like it.

I even drew sketches and had the seamstresses make costumes like those from the twenty-first century.

The seamstresses gossiped about the short skirts and flashy fabrics, but I just winked and told them to trust me.

I might not be the smartest time traveler, but I was still from the modern world. In a mansion full of women scheming for favor, even a few tricks from my own era were enough to catch Mr. Whitmore’s eye. Sometimes, that’s all it takes.

Besides, I was already his consort.

I had nothing left to lose.

So, at the Harvest Gala, I successfully caught his attention.

The music started, and all eyes were on me. I danced like my life depended on it—because, in a way, it did. I felt every stare.

That night, Mr. Whitmore summoned me to see him.

The summons came with a silk ribbon and a single white rose. My hands shook as I tied the ribbon in my hair. This was it.

He asked, “What kind of dance was that? I’ve never seen anything like it.”

His voice was low, curious. I could see the gears turning in his head.

Acting coy, I said, “It’s a dance from a tribe in Silver Hollow. I thought it was fun, so I learned it. Do you like it?”

I bit my lip and looked up at him through my lashes, playing the part he expected.

He said, “I do.”

He leaned in, his eyes dark. I fought the urge to flinch away.

“From now on, you’re only allowed to dance it for me!”

It was half command, half plea. I nodded, smiling sweetly.

I wrapped my arms around his neck, all innocent and flirtatious.

I could feel his pulse racing beneath my fingertips. I hated myself for it, but I didn’t let go.

“Alright, I’ll only dance for you!”

My voice was breathless, full of promise. He grinned, satisfied.

Just like that, I became Mr. Whitmore’s favorite.

Overnight.

For a whole month, he spent a third of his nights with me.

The staff started calling me the "rising star" behind my back. I pretended not to hear.

Even though I was disgusted—sick to my stomach—and took a birth control pill every day, I still fawned over him, refusing to let my sister’s death be in vain. My stomach twisted every time he touched me, but I forced myself to smile.

As long as I could make the Lady suffer, I’d do anything—no matter how revolting. Anything.

As expected, the Lady couldn’t tolerate Mr. Whitmore favoring someone she disapproved of. After his third visit, she began punishing me—making me kneel at morning greetings, copy Bible verses, or carry scalding tea. I endured it all without a single complaint in front of Mr. Whitmore.

Her punishments were creative, but I never gave her the satisfaction of seeing me break. Not once.

The autumn weather was crisp and clear, perfect for soaking up a little sun in the garden. I was looking for a quiet spot and unexpectedly ran into the Lady.

The sunlight filtered through the trees, painting golden patterns on the grass. I almost believed I could disappear into the light. Almost.

She was accompanied by several women, led by Victoria Langley.

Victoria’s laughter rang out like a bell, sharp and clear. She moved with the confidence of someone who’d never heard the word "no."

They said she was one of the few women the Lady could tolerate, and the first among the new selections to bear a child.

Her family was old money, her manners impeccable. She was the kind of woman who made enemies without even trying.

She was also one of those responsible for my sister’s suffering. I would never forget.

She entered the mansion with my sister, but was much smarter—she immediately aligned herself with the Lady and quickly became favored. The Lady, usually jealous, tolerated her because she was obedient and her family served the Langley clan.

She knew which side her bread was buttered on. Loyalty was just another bargaining chip in this house.

Once favored, she became pregnant and gave birth to a daughter, securing her status. A year ago, she was pregnant again, and at five months, the doctors started hinting it was a boy.

Everyone in the house held their breath, waiting for the next heir.

Mr. Whitmore’s first son—how precious would that be?

The answer was: priceless. The whole estate buzzed with anticipation.

He was overjoyed and promised to make her a consort if she gave birth to a son. That’s all it took.

But then she lost the baby.

The news hit the house like a thunderclap. Whispers turned to accusations in the blink of an eye.

All the evidence pointed to my sister.

It was too convenient, too neat. I knew a setup when I saw one. I’d seen it before.

My sister was accused of killing Victoria’s child, and further investigation linked her to previous miscarriages and deaths among the women.

She became the villain of the story, the scapegoat for every tragedy.

Mr. Whitmore was enraged and handed my sister over to the Lady.

His anger was cold, calculated. He never raised his voice, but everyone felt the chill.

The Lady, in her mercy, didn’t take my sister’s life—instead, she had her limbs cut off, eyes gouged out, tongue pulled out, turned her into a living remnant, and sent her home.

Mercy. The word tasted like ashes in my mouth. Mercy. Yeah, right.

Thinking of this, I clenched my fists. Victoria noticed and raised an eyebrow. “Oh, isn’t this the Silver Hollow girl who danced at the Harvest Gala?”

Her voice was syrupy sweet, but her eyes were like broken glass.

“Come on, Silver Hollow girl, dance for us and the Lady!”

She snapped her fingers, as if I were a trained monkey.

The other women laughed. “Yeah, that dance was something. Show us again!”

Their laughter was cruel, echoing off the garden walls. I kept my face blank.

“What’s so special? Just a cheap trick to seduce the boss.”

Their words stung, but I didn’t let it show.

“Exactly. Remember what she wore that day? Her waist was bare—must’ve learned it from the lowest clubs!”

They snickered, nudging each other. I could feel their eyes crawling over my skin.

I could’ve snapped. Instead… I wasn’t angry, just said, “If he likes it, I only dance for him!”

My words hung in the air, silencing them. The Lady’s eyes narrowed, her lips pressed into a thin line.

That shut them up. The Lady’s face turned cold. “The Silver Hollow girl is getting cocky!”

Her voice was like ice cracking. I felt a shiver run down my spine.

At her words, Victoria stepped forward and slapped me hard across the face. “How dare you be disrespectful in front of the Lady!”

Stars exploded behind my eyes. My cheek burned, but I didn’t flinch.

I lowered my eyes and knelt. “Please forgive me, Lady Whitmore. I deserve punishment.”

I kept my voice steady, refusing to let them see me break.

The Lady gave me a cold look and said nothing more. The other women hurried to flatter her. Desperate for approval.

They crowded around her, cooing and fawning, desperate for her approval.

“You and Mr. Whitmore have been in love since you were young—how many of us envy you! No little country girl could ever compare.”

Their words dripped with honey, but their eyes were full of poison.

“Please, don’t say that. She’s not worthy of comparison.”

The group laughed, the sound brittle and sharp.

“Yes, yes, I misspoke. The Lady is a peerless beauty—no one can outshine you.”

The flattery piled up, suffocating and relentless. I could barely breathe.

With all this flattery, the Lady’s mood improved. She raised her hand. “Oh, where’s my diamond bracelet?”

She glanced at her wrist, frowning theatrically. The others sprang into action, eager to please.

The group immediately started searching. As if they actually cared.

They combed the grass, peered into flowerbeds, their movements frantic and exaggerated.

Victoria said, “Oh dear, did it fall into the pond?”

Her voice was laced with false concern. I saw the trap a mile away.

The Lady’s maid agreed, “That’s possible!”

She clapped her hands, eyes wide with mock alarm.

“What now? That’s her favorite bracelet!”

The panic was staged, but convincing enough for anyone watching.

Victoria said, “That’s easy. The Silver Hollow girl was just begging forgiveness—why not have her fish it out of the pond?”

She looked at me, a sly smile curling on her lips.

“Surely she won’t refuse?”

The challenge hung in the air. I knew I couldn’t back down.

All eyes turned to me—some resentful, some amused, some icy cold. Each gaze was chilling.

I could feel their hatred, their hunger. They wanted to see me break.

I knew there was no way out. No choice.

So I lowered my eyes. “I’m willing.”

My voice was steady, but inside, I was screaming.

The autumn pond was already cold. As soon as I entered the water, a chill swept over me. Someone shoved me, hard.

I gasped, arms flailing, as icy water closed over my head. Panic clawed at my throat.

With a splash, I fell in.

The shock of the cold stole my breath. I kicked wildly, desperate to reach the surface.

Panic and terror surged through me. I struggled desperately, begging for help from the Lady and her entourage.

My cries echoed across the water, but no one moved. Their faces were blank, watching me sink. They didn’t care.

But they just watched coldly, as if I were already dead.

It was like being trapped in a nightmare. I wondered if this was how my sister felt, in her final moments.

They wanted me gone that day.

I saw it in their eyes—the calculation, the satisfaction. I was just another problem to be solved.

I started to sink. Suddenly, someone pulled me out and into a warm embrace. I coughed violently, barely conscious. A lifeline.

Strong arms wrapped around me, hauling me onto the bank. I gasped, water streaming from my hair, my vision swimming.

I heard the Lady, Victoria, and the others greeting Mr. Whitmore: “Good afternoon, sir.”

Their voices were smooth, practiced. I wanted to scream. I bit my tongue.

Mr. Whitmore looked at me, shivering and coughing on the ground, his face darkening. “What’s going on here?”

His tone was deadly calm. The women fell silent, shifting nervously.

No one dared speak, so the Lady stepped forward. “My bracelet fell in. The Silver Hollow girl was helping me retrieve it. Why are you angry, darling?”

She smiled sweetly, but her eyes were hard as flint.

He scolded, “Nonsense!”

His voice cracked like a whip. The Lady’s smile faltered.

He might not love me, but I was still the daughter of the Mayor of Silver Hollow. That made me useful.

Silver Hollow was far from the city—if the mayor rebelled, the city would be helpless. That’s why Mr. Whitmore rebuked the Lady.

Politics was a dirty game, and he played it better than anyone. I knew the rules.

I understood, but the Lady didn’t.

She saw only betrayal. Her face twisted with rage.

She was upset. “You’re scolding me for this tramp?”

Her voice shook, but she didn’t back down.

Mr. Whitmore’s brow twitched. “She was brought here to appease Silver Hollow. If anything happened to her and Silver Hollow rebelled, what then?”

He spelled it out, slow and careful, as if talking to a child.

“Don’t be unreasonable!”

The words hung in the air, sharp as broken glass.

The Lady was so angry she trembled and stormed off.

Her heels clicked furiously on the stone path. The rest of the women scattered, leaving me alone with Mr. Whitmore. I was still shaking.

Mr. Whitmore, still furious, muttered, “Unbelievable. Someone take the Silver Hollow girl back to her quarters.”

His voice was tight, barely controlled. I nodded, too exhausted to speak.

“Yes, sir!”

A maid appeared, hovering at my elbow. I leaned on her, my legs weak and unsteady.

Dazed, I glimpsed a shadowy figure in the distance before passing out. When I woke, I heard the couple had quarreled. Someone had saved me.

The memory flickered at the edge of my mind—a flash of dark hair, a whisper of perfume. I wondered who had saved me, and why.

I asked around and learned the Lady not only refused to admit fault, but also took it out on Emily, who had served Mr. Whitmore since he was a young man.

Emily’s name came up in hushed tones, always with a hint of respect. She was the only one the Lady seemed to fear, even a little.

When Mr. Whitmore took over, she should’ve been made a consort, but to avoid upsetting the Lady, all those women were only given the rank of companion.

It was a small mercy, but a mercy nonetheless. Emily kept her head down, never asking for more than she was given.

Emily was frail and had been recovering in the mansion. I’d never met her. I heard the Lady slapped her, and she fainted, sending the house into chaos and infuriating Mr. Whitmore.

The staff buzzed with gossip. Some said Emily’s collapse was the first real crack in the Lady’s armor.

I couldn’t help but sneer. So much for Mr. Whitmore’s great love for the Lady—what he really cared about was his power. Otherwise, why hold a selection?

It was all a game, and we were just the pieces.

But thinking of the shadow I saw before fainting, I realized Emily must have brought Mr. Whitmore to the garden to witness what happened. She’d saved me.

Was she helping me?

The question nagged at me, but I kept it to myself. For now.

But why?

Maybe she saw something of herself in me. Maybe she just wanted to see the Lady fall.

Once I recovered, I tried to thank her, but her people turned me away. I didn’t push it.

I left a small bouquet of wildflowers outside her door, hoping she’d understand.

You may also like

I Became the Villainess—He Became Obsessed
I Became the Villainess—He Became Obsessed
4.9
Death wasn’t my ending—it was my messed-up beginning. One moment, I’m a slacker picking a side role in a romance novel’s system; the next, I’m the villainess who’s supposed to die at the hands of a broken, beautiful male lead. To survive, I bluff my way into hiring him as my art model—only to find myself swept into moonlit road trips, secret wishes, and a slow-burn obsession neither of us can escape. Every sketch I draw peels back a layer of his pain, but when his wish is revealed, I realize the line between love and possession is razor thin. The system says his darkness is off the charts. I thought I could change the story—but now I’m trapped in his. Will I become the heroine he can’t let go, or just the next victim of his twisted devotion?
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
4.9
Falling for America’s sweetheart was never part of the script—but neither was waking up as the villain girl on a live gaming reality show. Now, every move I make is under the world’s microscope, every glance with Savannah (the girl I’m supposed to hate) becomes a viral ship, and my biggest rival is her gorgeous, mysterious brother. As alliances shift and the internet explodes with rumors, I have to decide: chase the win, protect my new friends, or risk it all for a love that’s as unexpected as my sudden fame. But with a possessive “lone wolf” prince and a meddling future mother-in-law in the mix, will my real happy ending survive the spotlight—or will I lose everything the moment the cameras stop rolling?
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
4.9
Waking up as the notorious villainess in a brutal historical romance novel was never part of my five-year plan. My job? Torment the wild heroine Nora and win over the cold-hearted male lead, Carter. With a mind-reading perk and my office-honed instincts, I thought I could outplay everyone—but Nora’s stubborn warmth and Carter’s hidden cruelty flip the script. As secrets unravel at glittering galas and county fairs, I realize the stakes are more than reputation or romance: it’s about rewriting fate itself. When my sabotage puts everyone in danger, loyalty and love collide in a final, fiery showdown. Can a mean girl rewrite her story—or is she doomed to play the villain forever?
I Was the Villain—Until I Woke Up
I Was the Villain—Until I Woke Up
4.9
I was supposed to be the villain—until I woke up in someone else’s story. Quinn Mason’s life is a borrowed dream: fake friends, borrowed luxury, and a script where she’s destined to fall. But when she discovers her rival Maddy is rigging the game with mind control and a supernatural support rating, Quinn realizes the only way to survive is to flip the script—before Maddy turns the world against her. With every move watched, every rumor weaponized, and every friend a potential traitor, Quinn’s only hope is to expose the truth without losing herself. But when the lines between reality and fiction blur, who decides who’s the real villain? In a world where popularity is power and the rules are always changing, can Quinn become the hero—or is she just another pawn in someone else’s Everworld?
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
5.0
Some stories are written for someone else, but what if you refused to follow the script? Autumn Sinclair has spent seven years as the villainous supporting girl in a world ruled by fate, heartbreak, and a heroine with supernatural luck. She’s loved the hero in silence, fought schemes she was never meant to win, and watched her every move become fuel for someone else’s glory. But when betrayal, murder, and the unraveling of every role collide at the center of Maple Heights, Autumn is forced to choose: stay trapped as a pawn, or break free and claim her own ending. With enemies lurking in plain sight and love hanging by a thread, can Autumn rewrite her story—or will she lose everything, including herself? When the script shatters, whose story survives?
The Villain Queen Claimed the Prisoner Prince
The Villain Queen Claimed the Prisoner Prince
4.8
Feared as the governor’s ruthless daughter, I chose the city’s most dangerous prisoner as my plaything—Marcus, the wild prince chained and muzzled beneath city hall. My half-sister begs for mercy, but I only want to break the man who threatens my family’s power. When I force a kiss on the caged beast, I know I’m tempting fate—and when he escapes, his revenge will be as savage as his love.
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
4.9
Being the villainess was never part of my plan—especially not in a small Southern town where everyone knows your secrets. When I wake up as Savannah Whitaker, the spoiled princess doomed to a tragic end, I decide to rewrite my fate: play matchmaker for the main couple, keep my head down, and maybe, just maybe, survive this story. But the plot has other ideas. The cold, dangerously handsome Mr. Carter isn't just my teacher—he’s the man I’m supposed to avoid, and he’s suddenly paying way too much attention. The gentle heroine, Elena, is as cunning as she is sweet, and every move I make only entangles me deeper in their world. Can I outsmart fate and claim my own happy ending, or will my attempts to change the story write my downfall? When the script flips, who gets to decide the ending?
Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
5.0
I always thought I was the heroine—until I watched the real one fall into the lake, and my memories snapped into place. Turns out, I’m Autumn Whitlock: the villainess doomed to destroy her own family, locked away by the man she loves, and forgotten by everyone. But this time, I’m rewriting my ending. When a staged tragedy nearly frames me, I risk everything to save my rival—only to be rescued myself by Sebastian Carter, the cold and powerful heir with secrets of his own. Now, as old alliances shift and the threat to my family grows, I must outwit the story’s script, bargain with the enemy, and confront a marriage proposal that could save—or ruin—us all. Can a villainess steal back her fate, or am I destined to lose everything I love, one calculated move at a time?
I’m the Villain Dad in Her Story
I’m the Villain Dad in Her Story
4.7
Everyone thinks I’m the cold, controlling father ruining my daughter’s life and my wife’s happiness. No one sees the years I spent sacrificing everything—until the voices in my head start cheering for my downfall. When my family finally pushes me too far, I decide to stop being their villain and walk away, but what happens when the ‘heroine’ daughter and ‘princess’ wife have to face the real world without their scapegoat?
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
5.0
Waking up as the tragic villain’s muse in a gothic romance, I thought I could dodge heartbreak and survive as a footnote. But when a cruel system ties my fate to Marcus Hawthorne—the brooding, misunderstood heir—I’m forced to play a deadly game where every wound he takes, I suffer. To survive, I must rewrite my doomed story, outsmart the hero and heroine, and win the villain’s trust without losing my heart. With assassins, poison, and forbidden secrets lurking in every shadow, every move could be my last. But as the line between enemy and lover blurs, I face an impossible choice: betray the man who could save me, or risk everything for a love that was never meant to exist. If you could rewrite your ending, would you dare to trust the villain?
Villain by Comment: I Quit Her Script
Villain by Comment: I Quit Her Script
4.9
Betrayal isn’t just a twist—it’s the script of my life. I thought I was the hero, sacrificing everything for my girlfriend’s family, until floating comments revealed the ugly truth: I’m just the villain in her story. When my girlfriend and her new lover vanish with my life savings, I’m left broken, blamed, and forced to confront the lies I called love. But this time, I’m done playing the fool. As public outrage explodes and secrets unravel on livestream, I fight to reclaim my future—even if it means tearing up the script and exposing the family that ruined me. Will walking away finally set me free, or is there one last twist waiting in the wings?
Rejected by My Alpha Wife, Reborn as the Villain
Rejected by My Alpha Wife, Reborn as the Villain
4.8
I married the ice-cold Alpha of Savannah to save her family, only to discover I was just a disposable villain in her twisted love story. After years of humiliation and heartbreak, I learn the shocking truth: my fate is to be betrayed and destroyed while she chases her true Omega. But this time, I refuse to play the fool—instead, I’ll rewrite the ending and make her regret ever casting me aside.