I Chased Him—But He Chased Me Back / Chapter 4: The Man Behind the Mask
I Chased Him—But He Chased Me Back

I Chased Him—But He Chased Me Back

Author: Alexander Church


Chapter 4: The Man Behind the Mask

← Prev

I want to ask why it has to be him loving me. But then I think, I travel through worlds, seeking 100 affection, isn’t it because I want every target to love me? Collect enough affection, and I can break free, return to normal life. I’m speechless. The journal in front of me shows his journey in this world. I recognize every word, but they’re all blurry now.

I ask, “Are others like this too?” Do the other targets travel through worlds too?

System: “Of course. It’s a special privilege for top scorers.”

“Top scorer?”

“Let’s put it this way: 100 affection is just a baseline—it means he loves you, but not how much. Some people’s affection drops after 100, some keep rising. We collect true love, so the more the better. Samuel proves 100 is just the testing peak, not his limit. For someone like that, we naturally give privileges.”

“Then how much affection does Samuel have now?”

“No idea. We’re curious too.”

I get it. The so-called top scorer is just a tool for generating love value. The system is awful, but all this started with me. If I hadn’t bound myself to the system, if I hadn’t chased him, he’d still be the high-and-mighty golden boy, not a pawn in this broken world. I ask, “Can he go back to his original world?”

System: “Of course. It’s a special privilege for top scorers.”

The system is quiet for a moment. “No. From the moment he chose to go with you, his fate was tied to yours.”

I’m lost. It all feels so absurd. My head is spinning, and I regret ever binding myself to the system. If only there were no mission.

When I arrive at the Foster family company, it’s already 5 p.m. Thanks to sticking close to Carter lately, I get to his office without trouble. My steps feel heavy. I don’t know how to open the door, or how to face him. What to say, what to do—I have no idea. The door opens from inside. Carter’s assistant comes out. He sees me, steps aside, revealing Carter at his desk. I walk forward without thinking. Carter sees me and smiles: “Checking up on me again?”

“I wanted to see you,” I say honestly. The system pings: “Male lead affection +2, current affection: 93.” What used to make me happy now just makes me sad. I look at Carter walking toward me and hug him tight.

“Looks like you really missed me.” He strokes my hair with a sigh.

“I know everything... Samuel.” I say quietly in his arms. He stiffens. “Why did you follow me? Don’t you want your family...”

Carter quickly lets go. “How do you know? Are you okay? Will the system punish you?”

“That’s not important,” I say. “I just want to know why you came.”

Carter looks at me in silence. Under my insistence, he tries to act casual: “Forgot. It’s been so long, maybe I was just a dumb kid who thought you couldn’t possibly not like me.” But he’s never been dumb or reckless, always cool-headed. I stare at him. He’s still worried: “Are you sure you’re okay?” He says, “The system says I can’t reveal who I am, can’t mess with the world’s order, can’t influence your choices...” One restriction after another, all to tie Carter’s hands. If Peyton hadn’t found his journal, if I hadn’t changed targets, how much longer would he have waited? He’s just being used for love value by the system. “Are you crazy?”

“We promised forever,” Carter says, hugging me. “If you left, where would I go for forever?”

“But I’m not worth it.” I thought he’d have figured it out by now. After I didn’t pick him for several worlds, he should have known, but he still stuck around.

“Worth or not doesn’t matter,” he says. “If I want to, it’s worth it.”

I wonder where Carter’s courage comes from.

“Let’s not talk about this,” he says. “When do you want to finish this world?” He’s a bit proud: “Anytime. The system promised me, as long as you choose me, the mission will succeed.”

I look at his face in surprise. Why is he proud of this? Why is Carter Foster proud of something so small!

“You really can’t go back?” I murmur. “Carter, I want you to go back, keep being Samuel. Isn’t that good?”

Carter is quiet for a while. He hugs me, his voice trembling in my hair: “Maddie, don’t push me away.”

“Since I was a kid, everything was planned—where to study, what hobbies, who to be friends with... all decided for me. If I hadn’t met you, I’d probably be marrying whoever my family picked. I never thought that was a problem, but now I know it is.”

“I want to have adventures with you.” He says, “Only with you do I feel like I’m really living.”

“But...” I start.

“No buts.” He says. Maybe seeing my hesitation, Carter gives up: “Anyway, we’re tied together now. You can’t get rid of me.”

He says, “Even if you don’t want me here, I’ll still follow you to the next world. Watch you chase others, or me.”

I think, he’s really a fool. How could I ever dislike him? I’m just afraid he’ll get hurt. Carter seems to read my mind. He says, “If you’re afraid I’ll get hurt, just pick me in the next world.”

I finally realize something. The first world’s target was assigned, but in later worlds, whoever I picked became the lead. I once thought this was the system’s reward, but it seems Carter arranged it for me. He hid among the targets, giving me more choices, even if I didn’t pick him.

“Do you want to go back?” I ask.

Carter says, “No.”

“If I go with you?” He changes his answer: “Then I do.”

I smile. “Then I’ll take you back.”

The system says, if affection reaches 1000, I can break free—that is, succeed in ten worlds. Then I can choose: return to my original world, or stay in any mission world. Now it’s the fifth world. With Carter here, I’m confident about the rest. I repeat firmly: “I’ll definitely take you back.”

Carter and I start prepping to leave the mission world. Actually, there’s nothing to prepare. Once we leave, the system will erase most people’s memories—only the lead can choose to keep them. Now I don’t have to worry about failing or Logan interfering. With Carter here, I don’t have to worry about anything. He’s kind of smug: “Now you know how important I am?”

He always gives people a sense of security, makes you feel like he’s rock solid. With nothing to do all day, I bug Carter to tell me about being a background character in past worlds. Carter says he forgot, but then complains a lot. Turns out, in the second world, he was the lead’s rival. He tried to help, hoping to make the lead jealous and raise affection, but I kept my distance to avoid upsetting the lead, filling up his journal. In the third world, he was my stepbrother. He thought being close would give him an edge, but I ignored him and went after the quarterback next door, making him mad. I listen quietly to his stories. Those days I never knew about, but he was always there. No wonder winning Carter was so easy—he knew I was coming all along. And he liked it. I hug Carter and sigh: “How did I meet you?”

He laughs: “Are you starting to like me?”

“Hmm?”

He says, “I said I’d try to make you like me, and I’d do everything to find you.”

I remember my conversation with Carter. He meant it all along. Carter asks, “So have I won you over?”

“Yes.” I kiss the corner of his smiling mouth.

He says, “Let’s go.”

I nod to the system. Soon, the system’s voice rings in my head. “Detected male lead affection is full, mission complete, enter next world?” I’m about to confirm, but the system reports: “Detected host 1011’s affection is full. Congratulations, you’ve finished the mission. You may now leave the system. Do you want to return to your original world?”

I’m stunned for a long time before I realize what the system just said. Carter is still calm. I wonder, did his hidden affection value finally show up? Is it so high I can leave the system and return to normal life? The system is still waiting for a reply. I say excitedly, “I choose to return to the first mission world!”

Birds chirp outside the window. When I open my eyes again, I’m in the room Samuel’s family prepared for me. The familiar furniture makes my nose sting. I go to the mirror and look at myself. Barefoot, no makeup, still in a white nightgown. I don’t know what time it is or if anyone outside remembers me. I brace myself, open the door, and see Samuel hurrying toward me. He sees me, breathes a sigh of relief, and stands there catching his breath. My anxious heart finally settles.

Samuel slowly walks up and asks, “How did we come back?”

“The mission’s over,” I say, wrapping my arms around his neck, full of relief. “Thank you for loving me so much.”

Samuel is still a little dazed. “No more missions from now on?”

“Yeah, it’s all over.”

“You’ll always stay with me?” He can’t believe it. “Healthy and by my side?”

He makes me laugh. “Yes, healthy.”

I say, “After all, I still have to be with you forever.”

He hugs me and sighs deeply. “That’s perfect.”

After hugging for a while, I remember to ask, “What time is it now? Did the system erase everyone’s memories? Does everyone still remember me?”

“We came back to the day you left,” Samuel says. That’s it. I look around. Oak floors, big windows, the sound of the garden fountain—everything is so familiar. Like a crazy dream. Luckily, it’s over, and the one who loves me is still here.

[End]

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.
← Prev

You may also like

He Posted Her, Then Begged for Me
He Posted Her, Then Begged for Me
4.6
After two years chasing the campus heartthrob, Emily is humiliated when he goes Insta-official with another girl—then blames her when she finally walks away. Labeled a homewrecker and iced out by her classmates, Emily’s only escape is to leave the country, but now he’s desperate to stop her. Will she choose her own freedom, or let his last-minute regret pull her back into heartbreak?
He Left Me, But I Paid the Price
He Left Me, But I Paid the Price
4.9
Some endings are silent, but the ache never is. I thought Eli and I were forever—until a single betrayal tore us apart, leaving me clutching memories and a cheap county fair kite. Years later, I’m called back to his side as his emergency contact, thrown into a whirlwind of old wounds and unfinished business. He’s surrounded by new admirers, but the past still claws at both of us. I want closure, maybe even forgiveness, but Eli only offers distance. My friends say I’m a fool for loving him, but they never saw the sacrifices he made, the debts unpaid. Now, as I watch him slip away for the last time, I’m haunted by one question: Was I the one holding him back—or was he always running from something he could never name? If love is letting go, why does it hurt so much to set him free?
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
I Dumped My Crush—His Roommate Craved Me
4.9
I always thought being a succubus in college would make my love life easy—until my childhood friend ghosted me for the campus queen on Valentine’s Day. Now, with the universe streaming my every move like a reality show—complete with savage floating comments—I’m stuck between Mason’s mixed signals and his brooding roommate Caleb, who’s way more than just a background character. As old hookups lose their spark and new desires heat up, I’m forced to choose: chase what’s familiar, or risk everything on the guy who sees through my every act? When the comments demand drama and the past won’t let go, can I rewrite my own story—or will I just become the villain in someone else’s feed?
Back to Him, Before the Heartbreak
Back to Him, Before the Heartbreak
4.9
He was my childhood friend, my secret crush—and, eventually, my husband in a marriage built on regret. They called us the punchline couple, a running joke among the rich, but no one saw the scars beneath our bickering. When fate throws me back to high school, I swear this time I’ll confess my feelings before tragedy can claim his future. But as old crushes return and Lucas’s secrets unravel, I’m caught between the boy I lost and the man I married. If the past and present collide, will I finally get my happy ending—or break both our hearts all over again?
Bought the Governor’s Son, Now He Owns Me
Bought the Governor’s Son, Now He Owns Me
4.7
I bought a broken man at the market, never knowing he was the governor’s son—and now the whole town wants him back. Every night, I wield the whip and the leash, but his silence cuts deeper than any blade. The real heroine is coming for him, and when she does, I’ll lose everything—unless I break him first.
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
5.0
He was supposed to fall for someone else. I was supposed to be the villain—until fate, a stubborn transmigrator, and a broken story system rewrote our lines. When I deliver a love letter for the third time to Carter Hayes, the boy I grew up with (and maybe secretly loved), I spark a confession that upends everything: Carter likes me, not the 'main girl.' But our world isn’t real—it's a story fighting to snap back into place, and every choice risks erasing us for good. As mysterious tasks, forbidden kisses, and heart-stopping resets threaten to tear us apart, I have to ask: Can love survive when the universe demands we play our roles? Or will the villain finally get her happily ever after—no matter what the script says?
He Never Touched Me—Until Now
He Never Touched Me—Until Now
4.9
Three years of marriage, and Carter Whitman has never touched me—not once. I was always just the substitute, the shadow in his perfect life. But when the loneliness grows too heavy to bear, I hatch a reckless plan: a single, scandalous text and a photo meant to blow up everything. What I don’t expect is Carter’s reaction—his cold fury, his sudden return, and the dangerous, magnetic tension that erupts between us. Now, I’m trapped in a house where trust is a weapon and every glance could be a threat or a plea. He says he believes me—but why now, after all this time? When a single whispered word can tip our fragile balance, how far will I go to force him to let me go—or will I finally make him see me? If love was never part of the deal, why does my heart race every time he draws near? What happens when the woman who wanted out becomes the only thing he can’t let go?
I Was His First, Never His Last
I Was His First, Never His Last
4.9
He was New York's golden prince. I was the first love he could never forget—and the scandal everyone wanted to see crash and burn. When I returned to the city, Mason Whitmore had already replaced me with a lookalike, showering her with everything I once had. But one viral video, one desperate plea, and suddenly the lines between past and present blur. As old wounds reopen, rivalries ignite, and secrets unravel, I'm forced to choose: fight for my own future, or let the man who broke my heart back in. In a city where love is currency and betrayal is news, can a girl with nothing left lose her heart twice? Or will I finally claim the ending they all said I’d never get?
Chained by the Boy I Betrayed
Chained by the Boy I Betrayed
4.8
I drugged Caleb to force a marriage, but he’d rather see me ruined than save me. When a coup turns me from governor’s daughter to prisoner, Caleb chains me to his bed and makes me pay for every sin—his words and silence cutting deeper than steel. After my suicide, I wake up on the day I doomed us both, given one last chance to undo the scandal that destroyed our lives.
He Sabotaged Me—Now I’m His Nightmare
He Sabotaged Me—Now I’m His Nightmare
5.0
Death wasn’t the end—it was my second shot at freedom. After years of letting Dylan, my controlling boyfriend, sabotage my dreams and erase my ambition, I wake up back at the moment everything went wrong: my college application. With memories of betrayal burning in my chest, I vow to flip the script. But Dylan’s charm hides a toxic core, and every sweet word is a trap meant to keep me small. This time, I’ll use his own game against him—turning old scars into new strength, and every manipulation into a stepping stone out of his grasp. Can I break free from the chains of my past, or will Dylan’s lies pull me back under? When revenge is the only way forward, how far will I go to reclaim my future?
Catfished by My Academic Rival
Catfished by My Academic Rival
4.9
Luke fakes being gay to trick his campus nemesis, Shane, into writing his thesis—but when Shane discovers the deception, revenge turns into an electrifying, twisted power struggle. As guilt, attraction, and betrayal spiral out of control, Luke realizes he may have unleashed a dangerous obsession. In this game of secrets, someone’s heart—or future—could be destroyed.
His Rules, My Undoing
His Rules, My Undoing
4.8
He never let anyone near—except me. In the whirlwind of Chicago, small-town Eli finds himself tangled in the intense, possessive orbit of his roommate Colton Price: campus royalty, neat freak, and heir to a legacy that casts a long shadow. The rules are simple—no one touches Colton’s things, but Eli is the glaring exception, invited into spaces and intimacies no one else is allowed. But when rumors start and lines blur, Eli discovers Colton’s affections come with a price: control, obsession, and a devotion that borders on dangerous. Every act of closeness is met with whispers, every attempt to pull away only tightens Colton’s grip. When a girl from home arrives and Colton’s jealousy explodes, Eli is forced to ask—am I loved, or just owned? How far will Colton go to keep what’s his—and can Eli break free, or is it already too late?