I Fish the Dead: The Well’s Secret / Chapter 3: The Well That Hungers
I Fish the Dead: The Well’s Secret

I Fish the Dead: The Well’s Secret

Author: Margaret Henderson


Chapter 3: The Well That Hungers

← Prev

“Ahhhhhh! Murder! There’s been a murder!”

The scream cut through the room like a knife. I jumped to my feet, heart pounding. The air felt electric, like a storm was about to break.

It echoed off the marble, bouncing around the room until it felt like the walls themselves were crying. I felt my skin crawl.

I jumped up. A girl about my age, in a nightgown with her hair all over the place, came running down the stairs. Her face was pale, eyes bloodshot and wild.

She looked like she hadn’t slept in days—cheeks hollow, lips trembling. Her bare feet slapped against the steps, leaving faint prints on the marble.

Before I could react, several members of the staff rushed in and restrained her.

They moved fast, practiced—like this wasn’t the first time. The girl fought them, but she was no match for the two burly men. Her cries echoed in my ears.

The man’s face darkened.

He clenched his jaw, eyes cold. "What are you doing? You can’t even keep an eye on one person? Get her back to her room. Let her rest!"

His voice cracked like a whip, and the staff scrambled to obey.

“Yes, sir.”

They quickly led the girl up the stairs. She didn’t scream again, just stared at the floor. The nightgown dragged behind her, dirty at the hem. I watched her go, feeling a strange sense of dread.

Strangely, when she saw me, she stopped screaming and struggling. Instead, she gave me a cold, flat stare that made my skin crawl.

Her eyes were sharp, almost accusing. I felt a chill that had nothing to do with the drafty house. She was watching me, really watching.

This girl was trouble. She was definitely more than she seemed.

I made a mental note to keep my distance. There was something about her that set my nerves on edge. I didn’t want to get mixed up in whatever her story was.

“Your daughter…?” I started. Normally, I wouldn’t pry into someone else’s family business, but this house was too strange—I had to ask.

I tried to keep my tone gentle, but the question hung heavy in the air. The silence stretched between us.

The man let out a heavy sigh.

He looked suddenly older, shoulders slumping. "Since you’ve seen it, I won’t hide it from you."

He hesitated, glancing at Clarissa for support. She just nodded, lips pressed tight. They looked like they were carrying a weight neither could put down.

“Ever since the maids fell into the well, all sorts of strange things have started happening.”

His voice dropped even lower. "Doors slam in the night, lights flicker, and sometimes we hear voices—crying, pleading."

“Late at night, there are strange noises in the yard. My daughter’s been losing her mind, babbling nonsense.”

Clarissa dabbed at her eyes with a silk handkerchief. "She wakes up screaming, says she sees things crawling out of the well."

“We brought in a preacher. He said the dead in the well haven’t been laid to rest, and their angry spirits are causing trouble. I had no choice but to find you online.”

He looked at me, hope flickering in his eyes. "We tried prayer, salt, everything. Nothing worked."

I listened, my expression growing serious.

I leaned forward, hands clasped. This was no ordinary job, and I could feel the weight of it settling on my shoulders. I tried to steady my breathing.

If the preacher was right, this was going to be a real problem.

The stories Grandpa told about restless spirits came rushing back. I tried to remember every warning, every bit of advice. I could almost hear his voice in my head.

I might have inherited the skills to fish out bodies, but exorcisms were not my specialty.

I’d seen enough to know when I was out of my depth. This was the kind of job you called in a priest for, not a body fisher. My hands started to tremble.

I could handle drowned corpses from rivers, but ghosts… that was out of my league.

I swallowed hard, trying to keep my voice steady. "I’m no ghost hunter," I thought.

“Why didn’t you tell me all this before?” I asked, keeping my voice flat.

My patience was wearing thin. I didn’t like being blindsided. My jaw clenched.

“I… I was afraid you wouldn’t come if I told you.”

He looked genuinely ashamed, twisting his wedding ring with trembling fingers. I almost felt sorry for him.

“Please, I’m begging you! I’ll pay whatever you want!”

His voice cracked, and for a second, I saw the fear behind the bravado. He was desperate, maybe even scared for his own soul. His hands shook.

He was nearly in tears, ready to drop to his knees.

Clarissa put a hand on his shoulder, her own eyes shining with unshed tears. The room felt heavy with unspoken things. I felt the weight of their hope settle on me.

I sighed to myself. I could wait, but Grandpa’s illness couldn’t. In our line of work, once you take a job, you see it through. You don’t bail.

I remembered Grandpa’s words—"When the river calls, you answer."

“Fine. Take me to the well.”

I stood up, trying to project more confidence than I felt. The man nodded, relief flooding his face. Clarissa squeezed his hand.

He led me to the backyard. In the center stood the ancient well.

The grass was patchy, the earth around the well bare and cracked. Even the birds seemed to avoid it, the air thick with the smell of old stone and something darker. The whole place felt wrong.

Just one look, and my heart skipped a beat.

The well felt wrong—like it was waiting for me. My palms started to sweat, but I forced myself to keep moving. I took a deep breath, steeling myself.

This well was nothing like any I’d seen before.

Most wells were narrow, lined with brick. This one was massive, ringed with moss and spiderwebs, the stone slick with age. It looked ancient and hungry.

The mouth was huge—ten feet across. Eight stone pillars circled it, each with a thick iron chain as wide as a wrist, stretching down into the darkness below. The chains were rusted, clearly over a century old.

The pillars were carved with strange symbols, worn smooth by wind and rain. The chains clinked softly, swaying in the breeze like they were breathing. I shivered.

“This is the well,” the man said, standing fifteen feet away. They didn’t dare come closer, their faces stiff with fear.

Clarissa clung to the man’s arm, knuckles white. I could see their breath in the air, even though it wasn’t that cold. Their eyes were wide, locked on the well.

I tried to steady my nerves, reminding myself that fear was just another part of the job. I clenched my fists, took another breath.

I’d seen plenty of corpses in my time. I walked right up and peered inside. My heart hammered in my chest.

The edge was slick, and I had to brace myself to keep from slipping. The darkness inside seemed to swallow the light. I leaned over, careful not to fall in.

The well was pitch black. Every so often, a deep, gurgling sound echoed up, like something was churning below.

It sounded almost alive, like the river itself was breathing. My skin crawled.

A second later, a wave of stench hit me so hard I staggered back, gagging. My stomach churned, my head spinning. I covered my mouth, trying not to throw up.

It was like a thousand dead things rotting in the sun, mixed with the sharp tang of rust and old water. I doubled over, fighting the urge to throw up. My eyes watered.

I knew the smell of corpses—bodies rotting in water give off a stench that seems almost alive, creeping into your nose and lingering for days.

But this was different—thicker, heavier. It clung to my skin, seeping into my clothes. My stomach lurched.

It was the kind of stench that makes you question your life choices. I wiped my mouth, trying to clear my head. I wondered if I should’ve just stayed home.

“Has it always smelled this bad?” I asked, pinching my nose.

I glanced back at the couple, hoping for some kind of explanation. Maybe they could tell me what the hell was going on here.

“Bad? I don’t smell anything. Clarissa, do you?”

The man looked genuinely confused, and Clarissa shook her head, eyes wide. Whatever was in that well, it seemed I was the only one who could sense it.

Whatever was down there wanted me, not them.

← Prev

You may also like

The Well That Swallowed My Childhood
The Well That Swallowed My Childhood
4.9
A well at the edge of an Appalachian town hides more than bones—it holds the narrator’s lost childhood, a town’s silent conspiracy, and the string of beads that tie it all together. When a remote-controlled robot dredges up a battered water dipper and a familiar string of beads, old nightmares awaken. The narrator’s journey home unravels a decades-old trafficking ring, a murdered bride, and a matriarch whose power runs deeper than the river. As memories blur with horror and hope, the truth waits at the bottom of the well—where every secret sinks, but not all stay buried. What happens when the evidence is yours—and the only way out is to face the ghosts you tried to forget?
The Pond Eats Those Who Dig
The Pond Eats Those Who Dig
4.9
Some warnings are more than old wives’ tales. When seven-year-old Mason glimpses eerie green eyes in the town’s forbidden pond, his grandfather’s fear turns their home into a fortress of superstition and dread. But nothing can stop Carter Dean—a city slicker with a million-dollar contract and a hunger for secrets—from digging deeper, no matter the cost. As family greed and outsider ambition collide, ancient rituals and whispered threats resurface, unleashing a terror that won’t stay buried. When the line between the living and the dead is crossed, will Mason’s family survive the night—or become the pond’s next secret? What really lurks beneath the surface…and who will be left to tell?
Fed to the Fish: Campus Justice
Fed to the Fish: Campus Justice
4.9
Death doesn’t stay buried at Brantley College. When a campus koi pond turns into a gruesome crime scene, a lowly security guard stumbles onto a chilling secret: every dead fish is stuffed with human flesh. The authorities scramble for answers, but the trail leads not to a missing person, but a student no one dares to mourn. Lucas Frost—rich, untouchable, and rumored to have destroyed a girl who wouldn’t give in—vanishes without a trace. As rumors twist and justice is denied, suspicion falls on the one woman with nothing left to lose: the murdered girl’s mother. But when airtight alibis and campus silence block every lead, the investigation spirals into a web of power, revenge, and betrayal. Who really fed Lucas to the fish—and what will the truth cost those left behind? At Brantley, even justice has a price. Will anyone pay it?
His Dead Wife Waits in Our Bed
His Dead Wife Waits in Our Bed
4.9
When a haunted widower begs for help, a streetwise tarot reader must confront the furious ghost of his wife—risking everything to break the curse before it claims them both. But the dead don’t let go easily, and one secret could doom them all.
Heirless: The Catfish Queen's Revenge
Heirless: The Catfish Queen's Revenge
4.9
Revenge isn't always loud—sometimes it simmers. When a six-fingered woman loses her adopted daughter to the ruthless Whitaker dynasty, she finds her child dead and discarded, fueling a vendetta that cuts deeper than any blade. Armed with nothing but grit and a food cart, she charms the town—and the powerful Harrison Whitaker—into letting her inside their fortress of secrets. But beneath every flirtation and every perfectly sliced fish lies a hidden agenda: to make the Whitakers pay for every stolen life and broken promise. As the mansion fractures under her rising influence, and forbidden alliances threaten to explode, one question remains: when the past is weaponized, can any of them survive the reckoning to come?
Everyone Here Is Dead But Her
Everyone Here Is Dead But Her
4.9
Death isn’t the end in Maple Hollow—it’s where secrets begin. Stripped of his power, a young exorcist scrapes by in a haunted mountain town, helping locals with petty hauntings and living in the shadow of his mentor’s mysterious death. But when two desperate spirits beg him to save their daughter—possessed and chained in a ghost-filled town—he’s forced to face an evil that blurs the line between the living and the dead. With a vengeful ghost as his only ally and a preacher whose faith runs deeper than blood, the exorcist must unravel the mystery behind a girl who feeds on his blood and a town where everyone but her is dead. As dawn breaks and the shadows shift, he must decide: can he save the innocent, or will he join the ranks of the haunted? When every ghost wants mercy, who dares to be the reckoning?
Buried Alive by My Childhood Friends
Buried Alive by My Childhood Friends
4.7
Twenty years ago, Caleb and his friends sealed the mayor’s grandson inside a forgotten well—and swore never to speak of it. Now, as developers threaten to unearth their secret, his old friends turn on him, trapping him in the same well to keep the past buried. Betrayed, tortured, and left for dead, Caleb claws his way back for revenge, ready to make them pay for every scar.
Brother, Who Did You Bury?
Brother, Who Did You Bury?
4.9
Death was only the beginning for Silver Hollow’s wildest souls. When Big Mike dies with a drumstick in his mouth, it sets off a chain of betrayals, heartbreak, and supernatural reckonings no one saw coming. Nate—once the town’s troublemaker, now a preacher—wrestles with his own salvation as old friends turn into enemies and secrets bubble up from the grave. A stolen treasure, a cursed envelope, and a relentless manhunt force the narrator to choose between loyalty and survival. But when a portal to hell opens, the true cost of brotherhood—and the real identity of the preacher—will be revealed. In a world where redemption has a price, will any soul make it out whole? Or will Silver Hollow’s ghosts claim them all?
She Returned, But Not Alone
She Returned, But Not Alone
4.9
A mother’s worst nightmare begins when her eight-year-old daughter vanishes into the depths of Blackwater Lake—only to return weeks later, silent, cold, and pregnant with something that should not exist. As the town of Maple Hollow closes ranks and ancient whispers resurface, the truth behind generations of missing men, haunted waters, and the forbidden Lake God Chapel comes crashing into the present. Secrets unravel, family bonds are tested, and the line between human and monster blurs as the mother races against the rising tide of superstition, betrayal, and supernatural revenge. In a town where the lakes keep their dead and every answer breeds a new horror, how far will a mother go to save her child—and what will she become to do it? When the fire rises and the curse breaks, who will survive the final reckoning in Maple Hollow?
Dead Man’s Office: The Corpse Scandal
Dead Man’s Office: The Corpse Scandal
4.6
I thought middle management in the Afterlife would be boring—until a viral ghost forum dragged the Old Corpse of Pine Hollow into Sam Walker’s crosshairs. Now, with the toughest enforcer in the underworld found dead and my team one mistake from annihilation, I’m scrambling to hide the truth before the next headline is my obituary. In the Afterlife, one wrong move and even a Reaper King can get erased forever.
Last Catch: I Survived the Angler Killer
Last Catch: I Survived the Angler Killer
4.9
‘People make the best bait.’ That’s what the killer said, and now Marty—the last victim to make it out alive—can’t shake those words. In a small Midwestern town where fishing is life, a string of disappearances has shattered the peace, turning anglers into prey and friends into suspects. As fear infects every riverbank and diner booth, Marty finds himself caught between suspicion and survival, desperate for answers while old bonds are tested and secrets surface. When even the sheriff is out of leads, and the group chat whispers, ‘What if the killer is one of us?’, Marty must risk everything to uncover the truth before someone else vanishes. But with every line cast and every trust betrayed, the real question is—will he catch the killer, or become the bait once again? Who’s really hiding behind the next big catch—and what happens when the hunter becomes the hunted?
My Dead Wife Lives in Our House
My Dead Wife Lives in Our House
4.9
After her father vanishes, Lillian Harper inherits his strange small-town antique shop—and his secret supernatural business. When a desperate, wealthy client begs her to solve the chilling mystery of his haunted mansion, Lillian is drawn into a family riddle where one room—and one soul—shouldn’t exist. The truth will force her to risk everything, even her own sanity, for a shot at finding her missing dad.