I Refused to Die His Tragic First Love / Chapter 1: A Doomed First Love’s Rewrite
I Refused to Die His Tragic First Love

I Refused to Die His Tragic First Love

Author: Alexander Church


Chapter 1: A Doomed First Love’s Rewrite

Next →

The day I got my late-stage cancer diagnosis, I dreamed I was the doomed first love—the one who never makes it past chapter ten—in some gut-wrenching American gothic novel.

It was the kind of dream that leaves you rattled when you wake up, like you’re already halfway out the door. Shadows everywhere, southern heat pressing in, big houses hiding secrets—you know, the kind of place where love never survives the last page. Even in the dream, I could feel the weight of the ending before it hit.

My childhood friend, Ethan Calloway, was walking alongside me, rambling as usual: “Savannah, let’s go get some spicy wings.”

He nudged me with his shoulder. He wore that crooked grin. The one he always got when he was trying to cheer me up, like we were still kids sneaking out to the old pier. His voice was low and familiar, packed with all those memories that made me feel safe—even on the hardest days.

I managed a smile. “Let’s try something different for once. How about Kansas City-style barbecue with extra sweet sauce?”

The words tasted like watermelon juice and porch swings, like summer evenings and laughter that stuck around. For a second, I could almost forget the hospital smell and the way my hands shook when I thought no one was looking. I wanted to hang on to the ordinary, just a little longer.

Funny thing was, in the story, the heroine couldn’t handle spicy food. But after being with Ethan—trying to be more like me—she forced herself to eat spicy food every day and ended up giving herself stomach problems.

Isn’t it strange, the things we do for love? I remembered that detail from my dream, and it made my heart ache. I didn’t want anyone, not even a dream version of me, to twist themselves into knots just to fit someone else’s world.

Since my days were numbered, I wasn’t about to let anyone else suffer because of me.

It was weird, actually. Knowing the clock was running out. I felt a strange kind of freedom. There was no point in pretending, or asking anyone to carry a burden that was always meant to be mine. I just wanted everyone to have it a little easier, even if I couldn’t.

The place was packed, but at our table, it felt like it was just the two of us. Platters of ribs, cornbread, and steaming mac and cheese crowded the booth.

The place was all neon lights, laughter echoing from the bar—sticky warmth clinging to my skin. Outside, life kept moving, but in here, it felt like time slowed for us. The smell of hickory smoke and brown sugar hung in the air. Every bite felt like a celebration.

I ate slow, smiling to myself. “Turns out sweet barbecue is even better than spicy. People should always try new things—only then can you find what’s best for you.”

I watched the sauce drip from my fork, thinking how sometimes the smallest choices can change everything. I hoped Ethan picked up on what I wasn’t saying.

He set his glass down, leaning in a little, eyes searching my face like he was trying to solve a puzzle. I could practically feel his worry pressing in. The air grew thick between us.

He lowered his voice. “Savannah, are you okay? What’s up?”

His tone was gentle, but there was an edge. Like he already knew he wouldn’t like the answer. Ethan never let things go when he thought I was hurting. That’s just who he was.

I smiled. Shook my head. Lied through my teeth. Told him it was nothing. I hadn’t told anyone about my late-stage cancer diagnosis.

I forced my smile to reach my eyes, hoping he’d let it go, at least for tonight. It left a bad taste in my mouth, but I couldn’t stand the thought of him breaking—not yet. Not because of me.

I wasn’t going to be around much longer, so why make anyone else worry?

That was the truth I held onto. It made the secrets feel lighter. If I could carry the weight alone, maybe the people I loved wouldn’t have to hurt so much when I was gone.

But then I caught sight of a girl outside. She wore a thin jacket, clutching a basket of wildflowers, her face pale and pinched—something about her made my heart ache.

Through the fogged-up glass, I could just make out her silhouette on the sidewalk. She looked like she’d wandered in from another world—one where hope was something you had to fight for, every single day. My chest tightened with a familiar ache.

Same eyebrows, same eyes, same mouth. Like we were twins. What surprised me most was how much she looked like me.

It was uncanny, like staring at a faded photograph of myself from years ago, before I learned how heavy life could get. I blinked, half-expecting her to vanish, but she stood there, real as anything, shivering in the cold.

She had to be the heroine from my dream. But in the dream, she wore heavy makeup, looked lost, desperate. Hard to believe she’d ever been so innocent.

It felt like there were two paths ahead for her—one heartbreak, one hope. I wondered if I could change the ending, just this once.

I stepped out of the restaurant and smiled at her. “You look so much like me—guess it’s fate. I ordered too much food and can’t finish it. Instead of wasting it, why don’t you come in and eat with me? If you do, I’ll buy all your flowers.”

My breath puffed in the cold air as I spoke. I tried to make my voice warm and inviting. Like the porch lights that always stayed on at my grandma’s house. I wanted her to feel safe here, at least for tonight.

I pointed to the bustling BBQ place. Her eyes flickered—fear, hope, maybe both.

She hesitated. Looked at the door. Then at me. I could see the hunger in her eyes—not just for food, but for a little kindness. Sometimes, all it takes is one open door.

I took her hand and led her inside. Introduced her to Ethan. Then started serving her food, my heart thumping.

Her hand was cold in mine, but she squeezed back, just a little. I gave her a seat between us, piled her plate high with ribs and mac and cheese, making sure she got the best pieces. Ethan gave me a look, but kept quiet.

She ate fast, like she hadn’t had a real meal in days. Then, with nimble fingers, she wove two flower bracelets from the wildflowers in her basket and handed them to me. “Pretty lady, these are for you.”

She smiled shyly, her fingers quick and sure as she twisted the stems together. The bracelets were delicate, bright with color under the harsh lights. I slipped one onto my wrist, feeling the petals brush my skin.

I took the bracelets, kept my voice soft. “It’s freezing out—why are you out here all alone?”

I didn’t want to scare her off. Her eyes darted around, looking for a way out, but she didn’t move, just clutched her empty plate.

She looked embarrassed. “My name is Maria Reyes. I got into the University of Michigan’s business program, but my mom says we don’t have money, and that girls don’t need much education. She took my ID and forced me to quit school and work. Michigan gives scholarships to top students—just a thousand bucks a semester, so here I am, selling flowers.”

Her voice was small, but steady. The way she said ‘Michigan’—like it was a dream she refused to let go of. It made me want to fight for her, too.

She’d tried for jobs, but without an ID—and looking so young—no one would hire her.

Her shoulders slumped, the weight of the world pressing down. She’d told this story a hundred times, each time building another layer of armor. The unfairness of it all made my hands clench under the table.

So she picked wildflowers from her family’s fields. What else could she do?

I pictured her out there, in the early morning light, hands red from the cold, searching for something beautiful to bring into town. That kind of hope—I knew it well.

All I remembered from my dream was Maria’s heavy makeup and how, after losing his first love, Ethan kept her as his companion. He tormented her, over and over. After countless twists and turns, they finally fell in love and made it work.

The memory of that dream stung—how stories could twist people into villains or martyrs, never letting them just be. Maybe I could rewrite the ending. Make it a little less cruel.

"Low education, narrow-minded, a nobody trying to land a prince." That’s how Ethan’s friends described Maria. I thought of all the whispers and side-eyes I’d seen at galas and family dinners—the way people could be so small when faced with someone different. Maria didn’t deserve that. Not from anyone.

Turns out, Maria was a top student. Forced to drop out.

It made my blood boil, thinking how easy it was to judge someone without knowing the truth. She was stronger than anyone knew.

I pulled a debit card from my purse and waved it. “If a top student from Michigan’s business program comes to work at Calloway Holdings after graduation, this hundred thousand dollars is yours as a signing bonus—as long as you stick with us.”

I watched her eyes go wide, disbelief and hope flickering across her face. My voice was steady, but my heart hammered in my chest. No strings. Just her own ambition.

Maria was overjoyed, stumbling over her words. “I… I’ll never quit. I’ll help make Calloway Holdings the best.”

Her voice shook, but her eyes burned with determination. For the first time, she sat up straighter, ready to take on the world. Ethan grinned, shaking his head in quiet amazement.

I gave her the card’s PIN, left my contact info, and sent her a simple digital agreement. Once she signed, I let her go. I watched her leave, feeling something shift inside me.

I made sure she understood every word, walking her through the details with patience. When she finally clicked ‘sign,’ I felt a strange kind of relief. Like I’d managed to change the story, if only a little.

Ethan, who’d been silent all this time, finally spoke. “Calloway Holdings isn’t short on talent, Savannah. You’re just too kind.”

He said it like it was a flaw, but I could see the pride in his eyes. Ethan never missed a chance to tease me, but this time, there was something softer behind his words.

I just smiled. Maybe now, no one would dare mock her for being with Ethan.

I wanted to give her a shield, something that would let her stand tall in any room. I hoped, maybe, that would be enough to change the ending for both of them.

With Maria backing Calloway Holdings, its future was secure. Aside from the whole dying thing, everything else seemed just fine.

It was a strange comfort, knowing the company would be in good hands. I let myself relax for a moment. Pretending the future wasn’t already written in stone.

Next →

You may also like

I Refused Him—This Time, For Me
I Refused Him—This Time, For Me
5.0
Death didn’t free me—it just sent me back to the moment my life fell apart. In Maple Heights, I was the girl who 'tricked' her way into the Whitmore family after a scandalous fall in the river, never believed, always alone. But now I’m reliving my past with memories of every betrayal—especially from my jealous half-sister and the husband who never truly saw me. This time, I won’t let the same lies define me. When Harrison, the town’s golden boy, tries to claim me again, I refuse to play the grateful wife. But as my old rivalries reignite and new suitors emerge, I face one impossible question: can I finally choose my own happiness, or will the past repeat itself? What if the man who once saved me is the one I must save myself from?
I Died Hating Him—Now I Love Him
I Died Hating Him—Now I Love Him
4.9
Death gave me clarity, but a second chance gave me courage. When I awoke in my old life, I discovered my quiet, patient husband Shane was anything but simple—his love ran deeper and darker than I ever knew. Now back at the night that changed everything, I’m haunted by regrets and faced with a choice: repeat my mistakes or fight for the man I once overlooked. Family pressure, small-town whispers, and old wounds threaten to pull us apart, but this time, I’m determined to make him see how much he matters. Can I rewrite our story before fate repeats itself—or will my confession arrive too late for us both?
Ruined By My First Love
Ruined By My First Love
5.0
After being betrayed by the girl he once saved, Derek's world spirals into tragedy and poverty. Years later, when fate throws Natalie back into his life, old wounds bleed and new temptations threaten to destroy what little is left of his soul. He must choose between revenge, forgiveness, and a shot at reclaiming his stolen future.
I Died, But He Couldn't Let Me Go
I Died, But He Couldn't Let Me Go
4.9
Death was supposed to set me free—so why am I still haunting the man who broke me? Five days after my funeral, Nathaniel Holloway parades his new bride in the dress I bled to sew, never knowing my ghost lingers in every shadow. Trapped between worlds, I watch the man I once loved spiral into obsession and violence, wielding my memory as a weapon in his ruthless quest for power. Betrayed by blood, bound by a locket’s curse, and hunted by secrets that refuse to die, I must choose: forgive, revenge, or finally break the chains that bind us. Will Nathaniel’s regret set me free—or will our love destroy us both, even beyond the grave?
I Died, But I Stayed for Him
I Died, But I Stayed for Him
5.0
Death didn’t end my story—it set the stakes. I woke as a ghost, memories erased, bound to the man I once loved: Dr. Harrison, the forensic pathologist tasked with unraveling my brutal murder. As he examines my ruined body, I drift helplessly beside him, piecing together the truth of my death—and the life we almost shared. But the clock is ticking: seven days to reclaim my memories or disappear forever. Each revelation brings heartbreak, rage, and the aching hope that love might survive even death. When Harrison is abducted by my killer, I must make an unthinkable sacrifice—trading my own afterlife for a chance to save him. Will justice or love win, or will I vanish before I can say goodbye?
I Died the Night He Married Her
I Died the Night He Married Her
4.9
Death was supposed to be my ending—but the night Eli married someone else, my story truly began. As Autumn Jennings, I was never meant to be the heroine—just the shadow, loving from the sidelines, destined to die in a blaze for someone else’s happy ending. But when fate rewrites the script, I’m thrust back into a world of tangled family loyalties, forbidden longing, and a love that won’t stay buried. As the Midwest’s first female commander, I gave everything for the man I could never have—until a single bullet, a lost memory, and a chance encounter years later threaten to unravel destiny itself. If I can’t break free from the story written for me, will I lose Eli forever? Or is some loves strong enough to defy fate—even if it costs us everything?
Rejected 100 Times: His Bride’s Final Mission
Rejected 100 Times: His Bride’s Final Mission
4.8
Rachel only needs one more rejection from Jason to escape this loveless world—but on the eve of her freedom, he proposes instead. Trapped in a fake engagement and haunted by his first love, Rachel sacrifices everything in a deadly hostage swap, only to die forgotten and unloved. When Jason finally realizes what he lost, it’s too late: the woman he took for granted is gone forever, and her secret mission is complete.
She Was My Forever—Until He Was
She Was My Forever—Until He Was
4.9
First love isn’t always a fairytale—sometimes, it’s the storm that ruins everything. I was supposed to go to Stanford with Autumn Reyes; we were childhood sweethearts, inseparable, until the day she chose the school’s new heartthrob and left me in the shadows. Her wild love story with Mason burned through our town, leaving rumors, heartbreak, and broken promises in its wake. I tried to save her—tried to save us—but my loyalty only led to betrayal. When Autumn’s trust shattered and my dreams were locked away, I was left with a question I can’t stop asking: how do you forgive the person who turned your first love into your deepest wound?
I Refused the Proposal—Now Bury Me
I Refused the Proposal—Now Bury Me
4.9
Death isn’t the end—sometimes, it’s the beginning of your own villain story. After her father’s mysterious fall, Lila Langley faces a hometown proposal from Mason, the golden boy everyone expects her to marry. But when snarky, all-seeing text flashes before her eyes—casting her as the cursed side character doomed to die for the hero’s happy ending—Lila refuses to play along. As secrets unravel and old wounds resurface, she battles her own fatal illness, a manipulative would-be mother-in-law, and a legacy of guilt that might kill her first. With her family’s fortune at stake and a chilling ultimatum on the table, Lila’s next move will decide who ends up in the coffin—and who finally gets to write their own ending. Is she the villain they all hate, or the heroine of her own survival? When the line between love and revenge blurs, how far will Lila go to break the script?
I Refuse to Die for His Regret
I Refuse to Die for His Regret
4.9
She thought pregnancy would save her marriage—instead, it forced Autumn to see the truth: she was living someone else’s story, and it always ended in heartbreak. As her husband Ryan chases ambition and her mother controls every move, Autumn’s world unravels with one blue plus sign. Haunted by a vision of her own tragic future—a loveless marriage, a fatal accident, and regret too late to matter—she finally asks the unthinkable: What if she chose herself? With divorce looming, old betrayals resurfacing, and a rival waiting in the wings, Autumn must decide if love is worth the price of her freedom. Can she rewrite her fate, or is she doomed to be loved only after she’s gone?
I Died for Him—Now He’s Mine
I Died for Him—Now He’s Mine
4.8
Death was supposed to be the end—until I woke up in my own skin, staring down the man I’d once sworn to protect. I’m Mason: the mob boss’s right hand, the muscle who died for his loyalty, and now, somehow, I’ve got a second chance. But the city’s colder, my enemies sharper, and Jamie—the snake who betrayed us all—is closer to my boss than ever. Every step I take risks exposing the truth: I remember the betrayal, the blood, the night the boss shoved me onto a lifeboat to save my life. Now, I’ll do anything to keep him safe—even if it means seducing our deadliest rival, Marcus, or confessing feelings I never meant to share. But in a world where trust is a weapon and love is a liability, who will break first: the boss, the traitor, or me? If loyalty is fatal, can I survive loving him twice?
I Was His First, Never His Last
I Was His First, Never His Last
4.9
He was New York's golden prince. I was the first love he could never forget—and the scandal everyone wanted to see crash and burn. When I returned to the city, Mason Whitmore had already replaced me with a lookalike, showering her with everything I once had. But one viral video, one desperate plea, and suddenly the lines between past and present blur. As old wounds reopen, rivalries ignite, and secrets unravel, I'm forced to choose: fight for my own future, or let the man who broke my heart back in. In a city where love is currency and betrayal is news, can a girl with nothing left lose her heart twice? Or will I finally claim the ending they all said I’d never get?