I Was His Second Choice—Now Watch Me Burn / Chapter 5: Villain Era Begins
I Was His Second Choice—Now Watch Me Burn

I Was His Second Choice—Now Watch Me Burn

Author: Michael Baker


Chapter 5: Villain Era Begins

She did it—drugged him. Because of course she did. That’s just so... Lily.

It was reckless, dangerous, and so very Lily. She always did whatever it took to get what she wanted.

But she hadn’t expected me to take it by mistake.

Fate has a twisted sense of humor. One minute, I was reaching for a drink; the next, my whole world was spinning.

And that’s how we ended up in this mess.

It was almost funny, if it hadn’t hurt so damn much.

No wonder.

Looking back, it all made sense. I was always the supporting character, never the star.

Turns out, I’m just the unlikable side character.

The realization was bitter, but freeing in a way. Maybe it was time to write my own story.

And Duane and Lily are destined to be together.

That’s what everyone wanted, wasn’t it? The golden couple, reunited at last. I was just the obstacle to be overcome.

In the club, my whole body was burning, an aching emptiness and itch taking over my body and mind.

The drug was relentless, making my skin crawl and my thoughts scatter. I pressed my fists to my thighs, trying to keep it together.

Thinking of the comments just now, a wave of grief and anger surged inside me.

Why did I have to be the one left behind? Why did my pain never matter?

Reunited after years? Sparks flying?

It sounded so romantic—until you were the one getting burned.

Her thighs all marked up from his so-called passion?

I wanted to laugh and cry at the same time. Was that really all anyone cared about?

So what does that make my three years of living like a nun?

I’d waited, hoped, believed. And for what? To be the punchline in someone else’s story?

I grabbed my phone and quickly messaged my best friend, asking her to send over three male dancers. Yeah, I know—male dancers. Don’t judge me.

If I was going to be the villain, I might as well go out with a bang. I typed out the message, hands shaking but determined.

Bestie: U sure? 3??

I could picture her face—eyebrows raised, phone in hand, ready to drop everything for me. That’s what real friends do.

Me: Girl, I got dosed and cheated on.

The words felt cathartic, like admitting the truth made it hurt less.

Bestie: ...Lily?

She didn’t need details. She knew the score.

Me: Yup.

I could almost hear her sigh on the other end of the line.

Bestie: Ugh. On it.

She always knew what to say, even when there were no words.

Soon, she sent me an OK emoji.

The little icon made me smile, just a little. It was the kind of thing only your best friend would do.

Bestie: All your type. They’ll be there in an hour. I’ll pick you up after.

She always had my back, no matter how ridiculous my requests. I knew I could count on her.

At times like this, only your best friend has your back.

It’s the American way—when love lets you down, your friends pick up the slack. I hugged my phone to my chest, grateful for her.

I closed my eyes and cried in silence.

The tears came fast and hot, soaking the blanket. I let myself feel it all—the anger, the hurt, the betrayal. For once, I didn’t try to hold it in.

Reddit threads would be blowing up:

[Whoa, is the supporting girl switching sides?]

[Is she trying to piss off the lead with this move?]

[Meh, the lead probably won’t care.]

I could almost hear the snark in their voices, the way they dismissed my pain as just another plot twist.

The drug was spreading through my body, making my mouth dry and my body ache with a shameful craving. I didn’t have the energy to pay attention to the comments anymore.

My thoughts grew fuzzy, my limbs heavy. I let myself sink into the sofa, waiting for something—anything—to change.

My blood felt like it was boiling, my whole body burning and desperate for someone with abs to cool me down.

I laughed, a little hysterically. Was this really my life? Was I really about to hook up with a stranger just to forget him?

You may also like

He Followed Me Into the Flames
He Followed Me Into the Flames
4.9
He followed me into the flames—now he hands me divorce papers. Autumn Lane’s life was built on ruthless ambition, heartbreak, and the one man who never let go. When fate grants her a second chance, she swears to finally love Cole Whitaker with all she has—only to discover he’s colder than ever and ready to walk away. Betrayed by family, haunted by guilt, and watching her perfect sister steal everything, Autumn is left with nothing but pride and old scars. But when a desperate deal turns deadly and only Cole’s footsteps can save her, she’s forced to confront the truth: some wounds never heal, and some loves refuse to die. Will she risk her soul to win him back—or is her second chance already in ashes? What if the man who would have died for you now wants you gone forever?
I Was Never His First Choice
I Was Never His First Choice
5.0
He was never supposed to be my forever—but I made him my whole world anyway. From high school’s shadowed hallways to city lights and heartbreak, I chased Dylan Hart through years of longing, betrayal, and almosts. I built his dream bar, I gave him my heart, and when his first love came back, I lost everything. Now I’m left picking up the pieces, determined to build something of my own—until Noah Brooks, the quiet photographer who always saw me, steps into the light and offers a love that feels real. But letting go of old ghosts isn’t easy when the past won’t stay buried. With my career on the line, my heart torn between what I wanted and what I deserve, I have to choose: do I keep orbiting someone who never chose me, or risk everything for the man who’s waited in the wings? When love is a second chance and healing means finally seeing yourself—will I be brave enough to reach for it?
I Refuse to Be Her Second Choice
I Refuse to Be Her Second Choice
4.9
I got a second chance the day my wife died for another man. Haunted by her secret love letters and the neighbor’s final words, I’m thrust back ten years—before our doomed marriage, before heartbreak destroyed us all. This time, I refuse to be anyone’s consolation prize. As I watch Savannah chase the only man she’s ever loved, I finally see how settling for half a heart left us both empty. But letting go doesn’t erase the ache, and starting over means facing the past I tried to outrun. Now, as our lives tangle again—different choices, same faces—I wonder if fate is giving us one more cruel twist, or a shot at real happiness. If love can shatter so easily, can it ever be rebuilt? In a world where second chances come at the price of old wounds, what would you sacrifice to stop history from repeating itself?
I Was His First, Never His Last
I Was His First, Never His Last
4.9
He was New York's golden prince. I was the first love he could never forget—and the scandal everyone wanted to see crash and burn. When I returned to the city, Mason Whitmore had already replaced me with a lookalike, showering her with everything I once had. But one viral video, one desperate plea, and suddenly the lines between past and present blur. As old wounds reopen, rivalries ignite, and secrets unravel, I'm forced to choose: fight for my own future, or let the man who broke my heart back in. In a city where love is currency and betrayal is news, can a girl with nothing left lose her heart twice? Or will I finally claim the ending they all said I’d never get?
He Forgot Our Divorce—Now He Wants Me Back
He Forgot Our Divorce—Now He Wants Me Back
4.8
He claimed me as his wife—on the world’s biggest stage—right after forgetting our divorce. Now Hollywood’s golden boy is chasing me through viral headlines, a mess of lies and longing, while the world roots for a fairytale I know is broken. I was never his first choice; I was just the stand-in for his real love, and when his memory returned, he shattered me all over again. But now Evan will risk everything—his fame, his pride, even his life—to win me back, no matter what the world thinks. Can a love built on betrayal ever become real, or is forgiveness the one role I’ll never play? When the final curtain falls, whose heart will survive?
He Was Cold—So I Burned Us Down
He Was Cold—So I Burned Us Down
4.9
Love was a game, and I lost myself chasing him. Autumn Reed spent years simping for Grant Whitmore—the cold, perfect golden boy of Silver Hollow—only to marry him when his family’s empire collapsed. Now, their loveless union is cracking under the pressure of secrets, jealousy, and public humiliation. She parties with pretty college boys; he follows her like a shadow, desperate and undone. In a town where power is everything and betrayal is currency, Autumn must decide: is she breaking free, or just burning down what’s left of her heart? When obsession turns dangerous and truth finally shatters the lies, will either of them survive the fallout—or are some loves too toxic to escape? If you’ve ever wondered what happens after “happily ever after” goes wrong, this story will leave you breathless. What would you do if the person you wanted most became the one you feared?
After the Dare: I Chose Myself
After the Dare: I Chose Myself
4.9
One dare shattered my perfect love story—and forced me to choose between heartbreak and a second chance. When Carter, the boyfriend everyone envied, kissed another girl in a drunken game, I realized my boundaries meant nothing to him. Public humiliation, whispered gossip, and a campus confession page spiral turned my world upside down. Carter’s apologies grew emptier as the drama deepened, while Brooke—the girl he kissed—seemed all too eager to take my place. But just when I thought I’d lost everything, Jack, the boy I once rejected, reappeared with quiet strength and a promise of real devotion. Suddenly, I was forced to confront what I truly wanted—and what I refused to settle for. Was love worth fighting for, or was I just clinging to a fantasy? If you had to choose between the boy who broke you and the one who’d wait forever, who would you trust with your heart?
She Burned Me for His Touch
She Burned Me for His Touch
4.9
Betrayal tastes like smoke and gasoline—especially when you catch your wife tangled up with her ex, plotting your downfall on the lakeshore you once called paradise. Madison used to say I saved her; now she laughs in another man’s arms, her eyes glittering with greed and secrets. I gave her everything—money, trust, a future—only to watch her torch it all for a cheap thrill and a bigger payday. But I’m done being the fool in her games. With a private investigator on my side and a web of lies ready to snap, I set the stage for a showdown neither of them will see coming. When the mask slips and the real predators circle, who’ll be left standing in the ashes—her, her lover, or the man she thought was too weak to fight back? What do you do when revenge is your only way out?
He Chose Her—So I Chose Myself
He Chose Her—So I Chose Myself
4.9
Sometimes, the only way forward is to start over—especially when your husband chooses your rival over you, and your second chance comes with a thirst for vengeance. Savannah Carter dies betrayed and alone, only to awaken as her eighteen-year-old self, memories intact and fury burning. With heartbreak as her fuel, she shatters the old bonds of love, rejects the boy who doomed her, and forges an unlikely alliance with Caleb, the quiet genius hiding his own scars. As Savannah claws her way to the top—outsmarting her enemies and rewriting her fate—every victory risks a new heartbreak, and every kindness could cost everything. But with the SATs looming and her future at stake, can she trust herself to love again, or will the past repeat itself? The price of a second chance is steep—will she pay it, or burn it all down?
He Chose His Assistant Over Me
He Chose His Assistant Over Me
4.8
When my husband Marcus betrayed me with his bright-eyed assistant, my heartbreak went viral—turning my plea for a new husband into a national sensation. As the world watched, I spiraled through illness, betrayal, and the agony of being replaced by the very woman I once pitied. Now, with nothing left to lose, I’m ready to reclaim my light—even if it means burning down the life we built together.