I Was Never His Heroine / Chapter 1: Tied Up and Torn Down
I Was Never His Heroine

I Was Never His Heroine

Author: Jonathan Lewis


Chapter 1: Tied Up and Torn Down

Next →

I’d been dating my boyfriend, who was always so distant, for three years, and he wouldn’t even let me hug him or hold his hand for more than a few seconds. I couldn’t take it anymore, so I decided to take matters into my own hands—I tied him up and was about to make my move.

Honestly, it felt like something straight out of a late-night comedy sketch. My hands shook with nerves and, honestly, a little bit of defiance as I clicked the cuffs shut. Yeah, hilarious. Except the joke was on me.

Suddenly, a flood of comments popped up in my mind, like subtitles in a bad TV show:

[Here goes the supporting character embarrassing herself again. She still doesn’t know the male lead won’t touch her because he’s saving himself for the heroine.]

[LOL, even if she gets him drunk or slips something in his drink, the male lead would rather hurt himself than let her get anywhere.]

[The male lead only dated the supporting girl to practice. Now she’s bold enough to try forcing herself on him—she’s toast, hahaha.]

[Congrats to the supporting character for leveling up on the road to self-destruction. Enjoy your future mess of family ruin and drama, teehee!]

Those comments hit me like a bucket of ice water. Ouch. I blinked, trying to shake off the chill. But those words stuck to me, buzzing in my head like static. Looking down at the man beneath me, his eyes rimmed red from holding back, my hand shook as I started unbuttoning my shirt.

"Sorry, I had too much to drink. Thought you were someone else."

The words came out in a rush, flimsy as tissue paper. My cheeks burned. Pathetic. Tonight was my third birthday with Carter Winslow. I’d gone all out: silver handcuffs, a silk blindfold, a black collar. When I cuffed him to the bed, my pale toes slid down his sculpted chest and abs—awkward, but I tried to make it sexy. He let out a low, stifled groan. His body trembled, tense. But his words still tried to stop me.

"Don’t go any further…"

His voice was rough, almost desperate. There was a flicker of panic in his eyes, the kind that made me hesitate, if only for a second.

Don’t!

Three years, and I still couldn’t even hug him. Facing this gorgeous man, all I could do was look. Seriously, did he even know how cruel that was?

It was like standing outside a bakery window, starving, watching the pastries you could never have. Honestly, I’d never felt so invisible. So unwanted. Tonight, even if I screamed my lungs out—no one would come to save him.

I flipped over and straddled him, leaning down to breathe hotly in his ear.

"Babe, do you want it?"

I let my lips brush his earlobe, feeling his whole body tense beneath me. I smirked—trying to look bold, but really, I was desperate.

"Hmm? You don’t? Are you sure? I can barely hold back myself…"

At the same time, the metal buckle on his belt clicked open. I was about to undo it—

My heart hammered. My hands were clumsy with adrenaline. I felt like I was standing on the edge of a cliff, and the ground was about to give way.

More comments flashed through my head, like subtitles in a bad TV show:

[Here goes the supporting character embarrassing herself again. She still doesn’t know the male lead hasn’t touched her all these years because he’s saving himself for the heroine.]

[The male lead only dated her to practice. Now she’s bold enough to force herself on him—she’s finished, hahaha.]

[LOL, even if she gets him drunk or drugs him, the male lead would rather hurt himself than let her succeed.]

[If I remember right, the male lead is about to bite his tongue and pass out. Once he’s out cold, he won’t be able to get it up.]

My hand froze. My stomach dropped. I stared blankly for a second, then looked up. Carter’s eyes were rimmed red, his Adam’s apple bobbing.

He looked ready to break—but not in the way I wanted. My confidence just... collapsed. All I felt was embarrassment.

"Babe, let me help you another way, okay? Otherwise, you’ll get hurt."

His voice was gentle. But the distance was unmistakable. Like he was talking to a stranger, not the girl he’d been with for three years.

[Can’t the supporting character tell the male lead is rejecting her? It’s come to this—if he really liked her, how could he resist?]

[Please, she’s already blinded by lust. She can’t tell.]

[Exactly. Not only does she ignore him, she’s going to make him do things for her, then make him kneel and call her 'master.' If there’s an award for creative self-destruction, she wins.]

[Did the supporting character forget the male lead isn’t some harmless little puppy? Remember what happened to the last person who ticked him off?]

[Got shipped off to Alaska!]

What? Sent to Alaska? Was that supposed to be a joke, or... Seriously, Alaska? For wanting to get with my own boyfriend?

For a split second, I pictured myself trudging through snowdrifts in a parka, exiled from civilization for daring to want my own boyfriend. Startled, I gripped him harder without realizing it.

He sucked in a sharp breath.

The veins in his forehead stood out. His voice was wrecked.

"Babe, are you trying to kill me?"

He managed a strained laugh, but it sounded more like a warning than a joke. The room felt too small, the air thick with awkwardness.

[If I were the supporting character, I’d run now—maybe then the male lead would go a little easy and not ruin her completely.]

[Too bad, her possessiveness is too much, and she’s too proud and clueless to realize any of this.]

Ruin… lose everything?

My parents' house—gone. Dad's business—done. Mom, crying at the kitchen table. My stomach twisted. This time, I didn’t hesitate at all. I scrambled off him, jumped out of bed, and started throwing on my clothes, panicked.

My hands fumbled with the buttons, heart pounding in my ears. Carter seemed stunned by my sudden escape.

"Babe, what are you doing?"

He tried to sit up, but the handcuffs yanked him back onto the bed. I grabbed my heels, ready to bolt. His words made me freeze, and I turned back, totally freaked out.

Crap. Think of a reason!

"Uh, sorry, I drank too much and thought you were someone else."

My voice barely made a sound. My eyes flicked down. I mumbled, quick: "You... handle it yourself."

Before I even finished, I spun and bolted out the door.

I didn’t even look back. My cheeks were burning, my mind racing. I just wanted to disappear.

"What did you say?"

The door slammed shut, cutting off Carter’s stunned, tight voice.

[Wow, the supporting character actually ran.]

[Don’t worry, this is the turning point for the male lead, supporting character, and heroine. After this, the supporting character senses the male lead growing cold and distant, keeps making things worse, and finally he dumps her.]

[Then the male lead slowly notices the heroine, realizes how in sync they are, and falls completely for her. Compared to the supporting character’s spoiled tantrums, the heroine is gentle and understanding—he’s helplessly drawn in!]

[When the male lead confesses, he even picks the supporting character’s favorite holiday—Christmas—just to make her give up.]

[The supporting character hides in the shadows, watching the male lead confess with thousands of drones in the city’s fanciest spot, then sees the leads kiss romantically as the crowd cheers. She goes nuts with jealousy, tries to rush in, but can’t get anywhere near, and ends up being carried out by security, haha!]

[Seriously, who’s going to make me laugh like this after the supporting character’s gone? (cry-laugh emoji)]

...

Next →

You may also like

I Was Never the Heroine Here
I Was Never the Heroine Here
4.9
I thought sharing the heroine’s name meant I’d get the happy ending—but waking up in a romance novel doesn’t guarantee a love story. For two years, I chased Carter Hayes, convinced fate owed me the spotlight, only to find out I was just a stand-in for the real star. When a new girl with my almost-name steps into my world, the truth shatters everything: I was never the protagonist. As betrayal, jealousy, and heartbreak swirl, Carter’s touch turns desperate and his love grows dangerous—forcing me to choose between running away or risking everything for a role I never truly owned. If you woke up in someone else’s story, how far would you go to rewrite the ending? Or is some heartbreak written in the stars?
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
4.9
Waking up as the notorious villainess in a brutal historical romance novel was never part of my five-year plan. My job? Torment the wild heroine Nora and win over the cold-hearted male lead, Carter. With a mind-reading perk and my office-honed instincts, I thought I could outplay everyone—but Nora’s stubborn warmth and Carter’s hidden cruelty flip the script. As secrets unravel at glittering galas and county fairs, I realize the stakes are more than reputation or romance: it’s about rewriting fate itself. When my sabotage puts everyone in danger, loyalty and love collide in a final, fiery showdown. Can a mean girl rewrite her story—or is she doomed to play the villain forever?
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
He Was Meant for Her—But Chose Me
5.0
He was supposed to fall for someone else. I was supposed to be the villain—until fate, a stubborn transmigrator, and a broken story system rewrote our lines. When I deliver a love letter for the third time to Carter Hayes, the boy I grew up with (and maybe secretly loved), I spark a confession that upends everything: Carter likes me, not the 'main girl.' But our world isn’t real—it's a story fighting to snap back into place, and every choice risks erasing us for good. As mysterious tasks, forbidden kisses, and heart-stopping resets threaten to tear us apart, I have to ask: Can love survive when the universe demands we play our roles? Or will the villain finally get her happily ever after—no matter what the script says?
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
5.0
Some stories are written for someone else, but what if you refused to follow the script? Autumn Sinclair has spent seven years as the villainous supporting girl in a world ruled by fate, heartbreak, and a heroine with supernatural luck. She’s loved the hero in silence, fought schemes she was never meant to win, and watched her every move become fuel for someone else’s glory. But when betrayal, murder, and the unraveling of every role collide at the center of Maple Heights, Autumn is forced to choose: stay trapped as a pawn, or break free and claim her own ending. With enemies lurking in plain sight and love hanging by a thread, can Autumn rewrite her story—or will she lose everything, including herself? When the script shatters, whose story survives?
I Refused to Be the Villainess
I Refused to Be the Villainess
4.9
Waking up as the villainess in a soap opera life should have been Autumn Caldwell’s worst nightmare—especially with Nathan Pierce, the dangerously hot revenge-obsessed hero, gunning for her heart and her fortune. But Autumn’s got a plan: rewrite the script, dodge the heartbreak, and never, ever fall for the boy who’s supposed to destroy her. As family secrets unravel, rivalries spark, and one wrong move could cost her everything, Autumn discovers that destiny isn’t set in stone—and sometimes, your greatest enemy is your only shot at love. Will she escape her villainess fate, or has Nathan already stolen the ending? When your second chance means rewriting every rule, how far would you go to win your own happy ever after?
Rescued by the Broken Heroine
Rescued by the Broken Heroine
5.0
Disguised as a man to survive, the narrator risks everything to rescue a legendary war heroine shattered by betrayal and violence. Hunted across the Southwest, she hides in a church where a second fallen woman waits, her own secrets locked behind suspicion and scars. If trust fails tonight, both women—and the narrator’s last hope—will be lost forever.
I Was His Test—Now I’m His Exit
I Was His Test—Now I’m His Exit
4.8
Betrayal doesn’t whisper—it screams in neon. For three years, I sacrificed everything to care for my comatose husband, only to start seeing a barrage of floating comments that expose every secret, every lie, and every humiliation I was never meant to know. Each step I take, the invisible audience mocks my devotion and cheers for the woman stealing my life. When an accident proves their predictions true, and my so-called best friend is unmasked as the ‘heroine’ in their twisted story, I realize I was never the main character in my own marriage. But what happens when the side character finally breaks the script? Is it too late for me to rewrite my ending—or will the world keep rooting for my downfall?
Kept by the Villain, Cast Aside by Fate
Kept by the Villain, Cast Aside by Fate
4.8
I’m the disposable rich girl—destined to be a side character, never the heroine. But when I pay the campus outcast to fake-date me, I discover he’s the secret villain the system wants me to fear…and the only one who ever truly sees me. As my family crumbles and the main couple’s love story devours my future, I must choose: betray my role, or risk everything for the boy I was supposed to ruin.
I Refuse to Be the Villainess
I Refuse to Be the Villainess
4.9
Fate always cast me as the villain, but what if I could rewrite the ending? The night my mother vanished, she warned me: when the beloved heroine enters our home, my world will collapse—and I’ll be the one blamed for every heartbreak and scandal that follows. Now, with Savannah dazzling my father and brother, I’m forced from my room, my reputation ruined, and my heart shattered by those I once trusted. But when a historic opportunity for women emerges in our town, I see a glimmer of freedom beyond the story’s script. If I refuse to play the villain, can I escape the fate written for me—or will jealousy and betrayal destroy my last chance at happiness?
I Was Doomed—Then He Chose Me
I Was Doomed—Then He Chose Me
5.0
Falling for the Side Character was never in the script. When Emily wakes up in the background of a melodramatic romance novel, she’s not the heroine—she’s the girl destined to die, a bystander with no plot armor and no second chances. Her only hope? Avoiding the tortured second male lead, Nathan Calloway—the boy everyone fears and the novel says will kill her. But as Emily gets tangled in Nathan’s real-life struggles, she discovers a broken soul desperate for kindness, not another tragedy. Each act of compassion pulls her deeper into a story she was never meant to change, and soon, her survival—and Nathan’s redemption—hang on one impossible choice. Can Emily rewrite her fate and save them both, or is she doomed to play the expendable side character forever? One confession could change everything—but will it come too late?
My Daughter Is the Reborn Heroine
My Daughter Is the Reborn Heroine
4.7
When my rebellious daughter suddenly became obedient, begging for private school tuition, I thought she’d finally changed. But pop-up comments only I can see reveal she’s the heroine of a second-chance romance, scheming to run away with her bad boy boyfriend—and in her last life, I was the villain who ruined her happiness. Now, as she plots behind my back and strangers invade my home, I must decide: fight for her future, or let her go and risk losing everything—including my own life.
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
5.0
Waking up as the tragic villain’s muse in a gothic romance, I thought I could dodge heartbreak and survive as a footnote. But when a cruel system ties my fate to Marcus Hawthorne—the brooding, misunderstood heir—I’m forced to play a deadly game where every wound he takes, I suffer. To survive, I must rewrite my doomed story, outsmart the hero and heroine, and win the villain’s trust without losing my heart. With assassins, poison, and forbidden secrets lurking in every shadow, every move could be my last. But as the line between enemy and lover blurs, I face an impossible choice: betray the man who could save me, or risk everything for a love that was never meant to exist. If you could rewrite your ending, would you dare to trust the villain?