Matched By Mistake, Loved On Repeat / Chapter 6: Breaking Point, Honest Hearts
Matched By Mistake, Loved On Repeat

Matched By Mistake, Loved On Repeat

Author: Johnny Berry


Chapter 6: Breaking Point, Honest Hearts

Mason kept taking care of me—serving food, handing me napkins.

He was so attentive, it made my heart ache. I didn’t want him to feel like he had to impress me. It wasn’t fair.

The more he did, the more guilty I felt.

The more tormented I was inside.

He was trying so hard. Mason probably misread my mood as offline awkwardness and gently changed the topic: "Autumn, want to listen to music together tonight?"

He said it softly, almost like he was afraid I’d say no.

Now, when Mason called me Autumn, it sounded strange.

It felt too familiar, too intimate, after everything that had just happened. It stung.

So I looked at him earnestly.

"How about you call me Senior Autumn? I’m already a senior."

I tried to put some distance between us, hoping it would make things less complicated.

Mason choked on his water, surprised.

He grabbed his water, eyes wide. I felt a pang of guilt watching him struggle.

Watching his eyes water from coughing, guilt hit me even harder—I really didn’t want to push him.

So I added, "You should only be 19 this year, so I’m four years older. If you don’t want to call me senior, call me big sis."

I tried to make it sound like a joke, but the words hung heavy in the air. Not funny.

After I finished, Mason suddenly leaned in—his tall figure instantly enveloping me.

He looked different—more confident, more intense. It caught me off guard.

Looking down at me, he seemed like a different person.

The puppy look was gone—now he looked more like a wolf.

"I’m 20. Why should I call you big sis? If you really want me to, I can call you that. Okay?"

He held my gaze, daring me to say otherwise. My face burned.

"Big sis?"

He said it again, this time with a teasing lilt. I felt my face go up in flames.

Mason kept calling me big sis—I really couldn’t take it.

"If you want to call me that, fine—today I’ll ‘adopt’ you as my little brother."

I tried to salvage my dignity, but it was slipping through my fingers. Nice try.

I killed the mood in one go.

He didn’t get it. I guess Mason still doesn’t understand why I seemed like a different person after the meal. Otherwise, he wouldn’t have stopped and asked me now:

"Autumn, what’s wrong? Are you uncomfortable?"

He sounded genuinely concerned. I felt like the worst person in the world.

It was crushing. At this moment, all I felt was endless regret and guilt.

Especially with Mason showing concern, I felt even worse.

My mess, I had to clean up myself.

Taking a deep breath, I decided to be a good senior and tell him to hit the books—keep grinding.

I told Mason, "No—I need to get back to studying. I’m taking the GRE this year. Busy. You should hit the books too."

He looked hurt. I hoped the formality would create some distance, but Mason just looked at me, confused.

Awkward. To make my words sound more weighty, like a teacher, I patted Mason on the shoulder.

"You’re at your most energetic age—you should study hard. If you have any questions, just ask me. I’ll do my best to help."

I tried to sound upbeat, but my voice cracked a little at the end.

Ouch. Now, Mason’s expression froze.

I guessed he was thinking about why I said that.

He didn’t miss a beat. He was smart—he immediately got to the point.

"Autumn, do you think I’m too young? You think we’re not suitable?"

His words hit me like a punch. I wanted to say no, but I couldn’t lie. He nailed it.

I admitted age was part of it, but more importantly, I didn’t want Mason to change himself to accommodate me.

So this time I stammered, avoided his gaze, trying to find words to ease the situation.

But no matter how I thought, nothing seemed right.

So I remembered the old saying: sometimes, running away is the best strategy.

Should I just run now? Tempting.

I glanced at the door, half-tempted to make a break for it. But Mason wasn’t letting me off the hook.

Now, even if I didn’t want to look at him, I had to.

Mason slowly approached.

Under the dim light, the shadows carved along his jaw, the air buzzing.

He looked older, more mature than I’d ever seen him. My heart hammered in my chest.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

I Loved Her Wrong, Then Lost Her
I Loved Her Wrong, Then Lost Her
4.9
He never knew her touch was a plea for help—until it was too late. When Autumn Reed dies, Logan is left with nothing but regrets and the diary that reveals every secret she hid. Grief and guilt tear him apart, until an impossible twist: he wakes up on their wedding night, staring at the woman he lost. Now, with fate handing him a do-over, Logan must break through Autumn's icy defenses and his own haunted past, even as his ex-girlfriend returns with her own desperate promises. Can he unravel the truth behind Autumn's silent suffering before history repeats itself? Or is love doomed to slip through his fingers twice?
Matched to My Nemesis: A Love Glitch
Matched to My Nemesis: A Love Glitch
4.9
Love isn’t supposed to be an algorithm—especially when your government-mandated match is the icy professor who just destroyed your dreams. When snarky, stubborn Lila Brooks gets paired with Professor Ethan Caldwell, her academic nemesis, she expects three months of misery and a quick opt-out. But the state’s new matchmaking system has other plans: from staged 'relationship tasks' to a life-or-death storm on Lake Superior, every challenge forces them closer. As Lila fakes confessions and Ethan fumbles with feelings, sparks fly, secrets unravel, and their contract’s end date looms. Is this just data-driven destiny, or something real? When the final decision comes, will they walk away—or risk everything for a love no algorithm could predict?
Married By Accident, Awkward On Purpose
Married By Accident, Awkward On Purpose
4.9
Love is supposed to be fireworks—ours is more like awkward silences and polite texts from across the hall. I married Mason on a whim, thinking we’d fake it for our parents, but every day feels like we’re just two strangers orbiting the same sun. We meet at a comic con, bond over mutual anxiety, and end up at the courthouse before we even know each other's favorite food. Now, married life is a blur of gentle requests, shared beds with a pillow wall, and wedding night lessons straight out of a textbook. But under all the shyness, something real is growing—something neither of us knows how to name. Are we destined to stay polite roommates forever, or will one of us finally cross the line? When “I love you” feels impossible to say, what happens when silence speaks louder than words?
Mistaken Kiss: Trapped Between Twin Sisters
Mistaken Kiss: Trapped Between Twin Sisters
4.7
One drunken mistake—kissing the wrong twin—spirals Derek into a nightmare of betrayal, blackmail, and forbidden obsession. Now, Nicole wants nothing to do with him, while Natalie demands he pretend to be her boyfriend or risk losing everything. Caught between sisters who look identical but want wildly different things, Derek must decide: confess, escape, or surrender to the twisted game he never meant to play.
Lipstick on His Collar, Lies in My Heart
Lipstick on His Collar, Lies in My Heart
4.9
I thought I’d married the perfect man—until I found the lipstick stain on his collar and the apartment across town he kept for her. In Maple Heights, everyone praised our union, but behind the white-picket fences, my heart was breaking. Nathaniel’s betrayals forced me to choose: play the dignified wife, or lose myself entirely. As the women around me whispered that this was just 'the way of men,' I clung to my pride, even as my marriage unraveled. But when a mysterious stranger’s smile lights up my lonely world, I begin to wonder—can I break free, or am I doomed to live a lie? When love is a game of appearances, who dares to want more?
I Loved Her Twice—She Chose Me Last
I Loved Her Twice—She Chose Me Last
5.0
He gave up his dreams for her—only to watch her heart belong to someone else. When Logan Carter sacrifices his future in the city for Mariah, the girl he’s loved since childhood, he finds himself torn between loyalty and heartbreak after she chooses another in the mountains. But fate isn’t done with him yet: a second chance rewinds the clock, giving Logan a shot at rewriting his own story. As Mariah’s world collides with his once more—this time with confessions, rivalries, and a love that refuses to die—Logan must decide: will he risk everything for her again, or finally choose himself? When the past and present crash together, whose love will survive the avalanche? What if the one you let go comes running back when you’ve finally moved on?
I Loved Him, He Was Allergic to Me
I Loved Him, He Was Allergic to Me
4.9
He was the campus genius—untouchable, magnetic, and literally allergic to every girl except his destined soulmate. I was the girlfriend who tried too hard, only to watch the world turn my heartbreak into a live-streamed meme. When a single touch sends him to the ER, the comments start scrolling: I’m the villainess, the obstacle, the punchline. Now, with his new fiancée flaunting her perfect love and his obsession burning out of control, I’m forced to ask: Am I doomed to be the side character in someone else’s story, or can I rewrite my own ending? When betrayal hits and every secret is exposed, will I finally choose myself—or let him destroy us both?
I Loved Him, Then Time Rewound
I Loved Him, Then Time Rewound
4.9
Love isn’t supposed to come with a reset button—or a ten-year time jump. When Savannah wakes up in her old high school, her memories are sharper than ever: heartbreaks, betrayals, and the night Eli Whitaker lost everything chasing someone else. Now, with her marriage in ruins and her heart still tied to a boy she never confessed to, Savannah faces the wildest chance of all—to rewrite the ending. But in a world where every glance is gossip, and rivals lurk behind perfect smiles, can she risk her heart again? Or will history repeat itself, breaking her all over? What if your second chance at love means risking the only friendship you’ve ever known?
Caught Kissing the Wrong Roommate
Caught Kissing the Wrong Roommate
4.8
On her anniversary, Rachel slips into lace for her perfect boyfriend—only to end up passionately kissing his cold, mysterious roommate in the dark. When she catches her boyfriend cheating days later, the humiliation burns hotter than any heartbreak. Now, with her secrets tangled and her heart on the line, she must decide: will she let betrayal define her, or rewrite her own rules with the last man she ever expected?
He Loved Me—For Someone Else
He Loved Me—For Someone Else
5.0
Love should heal, not destroy—but Chris learns the difference too late. On the night he hopes to share life-changing news with Ethan, betrayal shatters everything: a devastating accident, a truth that cuts deeper than any wound, and a loss that leaves him hollow. Five years of devotion collapse in a single moment, forcing Chris to burn every bridge and rewrite his future. But when a chance encounter with a mysterious, wounded pianist sparks something unexpected, Chris must decide if hope is worth the risk—or if he’s too broken to try again. Can a heart that’s been used and discarded ever truly trust again? Or is Chris destined to haunt the ruins of his past, while love plays on without him?
He Forgot Me—But I Remember Everything
He Forgot Me—But I Remember Everything
4.9
A divorce built on lies. A marriage forged in cold ambition. Savannah Lin and Caleb Whitaker were always strangers—until the day he forgot her. When Caleb’s convenient memory loss collides with Savannah’s twisted game of truth and dare, their careful business truce explodes into chaos. A lost hair tie, a locked closet, and one forbidden night unravel the secrets they both swore to bury. Now, with jealous rivals circling and their families’ legacies on the line, Savannah must decide: will she walk away with nothing, or risk everything for a love that was never supposed to exist? When the pawn refuses to be played, who will end up broken? What’s left when the marriage contract is torn—and what if the only thing he can’t forget… is her?
I Fell for the Wrong Bad Boy
I Fell for the Wrong Bad Boy
4.9
Falling for a bad boy is risky—falling for the wrong bad boy, thanks to face blindness, is total chaos. Josie Monroe can’t recognize faces, turning her college days into a minefield of mistaken identities and viral disasters. When she mixes up the campus rebel and the top valedictorian, she triggers a rivalry that turns her into the prize—and the punchline—of the entire school. But as embarrassing meet-cutes become real connections, Josie discovers that what makes her different might just be what makes her unforgettable. With one boy’s loyalty and another’s secrets on the line, can Josie run toward her own happy ending—or will she keep tripping over the faces she can’t see? Who will she finally choose, and will he recognize the girl who’s been right there all along?