My Pet Shop Ate His Monster / Chapter 1: My Shop vs. The Supernatural
My Pet Shop Ate His Monster

My Pet Shop Ate His Monster

Author: Matthew Gross


Chapter 1: My Shop vs. The Supernatural

Next →

I woke up in a supernatural hunting ground—with my pet shop, of all things.

The instant I realized where I was, I thought it had to be a fever dream. Like something out of a late-night cable show. Except I was standing in my own shop, fluorescent lights buzzing overhead, surrounded by glass tanks and the nervous chatter of anxious animals. The shelves still smelled faintly of cedar shavings and dog biscuits. But outside, the world had flipped upside down.

I kept hearing voices in my head, memories or maybe hallucinations from the last few days—

A gruff werewolf: Ma’am, where’d you get this rooster? Why’s it got so much fight in it?

A wild-eyed cultist: That venomous hellhound I spent years training—it got eaten just like that!

...

And me, trying to sound calm: Sorry, it’s not that my pets are too strong—it’s that you’re all too weak.

It sounded cocky, sure. But after everything I’d seen in the last seventy-two hours, I was starting to believe it myself. My pets had always been a handful, but here, they were practically superheroes. I tried not to grin when folks stared, but honestly, it was the first thing in this place that made me feel at home.

On the third day after winding up in this bizarre world, my generator finally ran out of gas. The pet shop lost power and water—and all the pets were howling with hunger.

What kind of backwoods nightmare is this? I thought, a hollow silence settling in after my own outburst.

The dogs’ barks echoed off the empty shelves. The parakeets fluttered their wings in the dim. I sat on the cracked counter, legs swinging, staring up at the dead bulbs and thinking about how, back in Atlanta, a blackout meant lighting some candles and ordering pizza. Here, it felt like the start of a siege.

I looked out at the thick pines and maples. It was a world away from the glass towers of downtown Atlanta I used to know.

The trees pressed in close, all tangled branches and heavy shadows. Nothing like the neat city parks I used to jog through on weekends.

I missed the sound of traffic, the constant glow of streetlights, the way the city never really let you feel alone. Honestly, out here, the silence was almost too loud.

Just as I was debating whether I should go out and forage for food for my pets, the shop door suddenly slammed open.

The bell above the door gave a frantic jingle. It was one of those old brass ones I’d picked up at a flea market. A man stumbled inside, blood streaking down his arm, leaving dark spots on the linoleum. He looked like hell, but somehow managed to make the chaos of my shop feel even more real.

His boots left muddy prints, and the air suddenly smelled like copper and sweat. The animals all went quiet, as if they sensed something even stranger than themselves had just blown in.

No kidding, he looked like he’d wandered off the set of a supernatural drama. Judging by his ripped leather jacket and the strange sigils on his shirt, he could’ve been an extra from one of those CW shows my cousin binged every fall.

The jacket was shredded at the sleeves. The symbols on his shirt glowed faintly, like someone had drawn them with glow-in-the-dark paint. I wondered if he’d picked it up at a Halloween store or if it actually meant something out here.

"Hey, man, you okay?" I called out, taking a cautious step forward.

I walked over, about to give him a nudge, when—holy crap—a centipede as long as a forearm wriggled out from his sleeve.

The thing was so big, I actually froze for a second—my brain refusing to process how something like that could even exist outside a horror movie. My hand hovered in midair, torn between helping the guy and just running for the nearest broom.

The centipede was pitch-black, its pincers snapping open and shut at me.

Its body shimmered with a weird, oily sheen. Each leg made a faint scraping sound as it hit the floor. I’d seen my share of exotic bugs in the shop, but this one looked like it could take down a raccoon. My stomach twisted.

Even the ball pythons in the back cage would’ve steered clear of this monster. My skin crawled just looking at it. Yikes. I tried to remember if I’d ever read about something like this in any of my old animal care books—nope. Nothing even close.

It was vicious, too. The moment it appeared, it scuttled straight at me.

No hesitation. No warning. Just a blur of legs and snapping pincers coming right for my sneakers.

Goosebumps shot up all over my skin, and I bolted backward in a panic. "Oh, hell no!"

I nearly tripped over a bag of dog chow. I scrambled away so fast I almost knocked over a tank of startled hamsters. My breath came out in short, panicked gasps.

But there was no way I could outrun the thing—it caught up to me in no time.

My heart hammered as I heard its legs ticking against the linoleum, closing the gap with terrifying speed. I didn’t even have time to scream for help—who would hear me out here, anyway?

Just as it was about to grab my pant leg, there was a split second of silence—then a rooster flew over my head, its talons pinning the centipede to the floor.

What the—? The whoosh of wings overhead made me duck on instinct. The rooster landed with a thud, claws outstretched, pinning the monster right where it was. For a split second, I couldn’t believe what I was seeing—my own bird, going full action hero.

*Cock-a-doodle-doo—*

The rooster held its head high, its comb shaking with pride. Show-off.

Its feathers fluffed up, and it let out a crow so loud it rattled the glass tanks. I swear, if there’d been an audience, the little guy would’ve taken a bow.

I gagged. Then it lowered its head and, with its sharp beak, cracked open the centipede’s skull and started feasting.

The crunch was sickening and weirdly satisfying at the same time. The rooster tore into the bug like it was Sunday brunch, not even pausing to look at me for approval.

Whoa. I rushed over to stop it.

My mind snapped back to reality—this wasn’t just any barnyard chicken. Oh, jeez.

I reached for it, trying to remember every warning I’d ever read on poultry forums. Roosters could be stubborn, but this one was downright fearless. I felt a pang of pride, mixed with worry.

But before I could pull it away, it swallowed the whole centipede in one gulp.

I gaped as it tossed its head back and gulped the thing down, legs and all. The sound it made was almost cartoonish, like a garbage disposal chomping through leftovers.

"Oh my god, are you nuts? You’ll eat anything, huh?"

I hesitated, then scooped it up and checked to see if it was feeling off.

I cradled the rooster against my chest, running my hands over its feathers, checking for any signs of distress. Its heart was beating fast, but otherwise, it seemed as chipper as ever.

Thank God—nothing seemed wrong.

I let out a shaky breath, relieved. The rooster blinked up at me, looking for all the world like it hadn’t just taken down a creature straight out of a nightmare.

Next →

You may also like

Claimed by the Monster Groom
Claimed by the Monster Groom
4.9
Abandoned, scapegoated, and used as bait, Jason Reed is the team’s unwanted outcast—until a fatal leap delivers him into the arms of a monstrous suitor. As betrayal deepens and the poison in his veins spreads, Jason must decide whether to fight for survival or surrender to a love that’s not quite human. In this deadly game, who will save Jason’s soul: the team that never wanted him, or the monster who calls him bride?
My Grandma’s Cat Is Internet Famous
My Grandma’s Cat Is Internet Famous
4.6
Abandoned by the city, I became Grandma’s reluctant sidekick—until a viral talent show turned me into the internet’s favorite ‘Boss Cat.’ But even as #WhiskersTheBoss trends worldwide, my biggest battles are at home: a stubborn old lady, a heartbroken grandson, and a country full of chickens who want revenge. When the boy suddenly hears me talk, everything changes—because in this family, even the cat has secrets.
My Cat Is Plotting My Death
My Cat Is Plotting My Death
4.6
After catching her cat planting a thumbtack under her pillow on home security footage, a lonely office worker realizes her cuddly companion might be a criminal mastermind. As paranoia spirals, every innocent purr and midnight cuddle starts to feel like a threat—and even her friends warn her that cats are never truly tamed. But when her cat fakes an injury to stay, the chilling truth emerges: this isn’t just a pet, it’s a predator with unfinished business.
Stolen Hope, Loyal Hearts
Stolen Hope, Loyal Hearts
4.8
When the neighborhood’s most beloved dog, Peanut, is stolen by pet traffickers, his devoted owner teams up with a gang of strays, a fierce calico cat, and a determined little girl to launch a daring rescue—uncovering a world of animal heroics, unexpected friendships, and the power of never giving up.
Varsity Monsters: I Refused the Coach's Pill
Varsity Monsters: I Refused the Coach's Pill
4.8
When Tommy is recruited to elite Silver Hollow Academy, the 'miracle kid' discovers the school's star athletes owe their powers to parasitic worms hidden inside a 'supplement' pill. Refusing to swallow the horror, he fakes his way through tryouts—until he learns his hometown was slaughtered by the very teammates he trusted. Now hunted and haunted, Tommy must choose: become a monster to survive, or die fighting the truth everyone else is too afraid to see.
Buddy's Grin
Buddy's Grin
4.9
Haunted by tragedy, Eli’s rural childhood unravels into a chilling blend of memory and nightmare after his beloved raccoon, Buddy, mimics a deadly act. As suspicion, loss, and guilt fracture his family, Eli’s grip on reality blurs—forcing him to confront the horrifying possibility that his memories may be hiding something even darker. With every revelation, the line between innocence and monstrosity grows perilously thin.
My Ex Is a Peacock, My Boyfriend’s a Snake
My Ex Is a Peacock, My Boyfriend’s a Snake
4.9
Jealous birds, talking snakes, and a reality show gone wild—my life was weird enough before a viral peacock turned me into America’s favorite underdog. When my animal co-stars start acting suspiciously human, I realize I’m caught between a shape-shifting junior who loves me, a rival with secrets, and a dangerous backstage betrayal that could end it all. Fame, friendship, and forbidden romance collide as I race to save my animals—and my own heart. But when the cameras stop rolling, who can I really trust: the snake at my side, or the peacock I never truly left behind? Will my wildest love story survive the spotlight—or will it unravel in the shadows?
He Smiled—But He Wasn't a Child
He Smiled—But He Wasn't a Child
4.9
A child’s smile can hide the darkest secrets. When Morgan agrees to watch her best friend’s nephew, she expects a quiet week of cartoons and playtime—not a series of chilling requests and a set of child-sized dentures hidden in her guest room. As her neighbor is murdered and the clues point to someone—or something—small and innocent, Morgan’s reality unravels. Who is the boy in her care, and what happened to the real Tyler? When the lights go out and escape seems impossible, Morgan must confront the terrifying truth: the greatest threat may be the child she let in. Will she survive the night—or is she already too late to lock the monster out?
Eaten Alive by Monsters for Immortality
Eaten Alive by Monsters for Immortality
4.8
With only months left to live, a cancer-stricken man leaps to his death—only to wake up in a world of monsters hungry for his flesh. To survive, he must outwit demons who believe eating a 'preacher' brings immortality, using nothing but his chemistry smarts and a desperate will to live. Every lie, every scheme, is a gamble: if he fails, he'll end up roasted on their spit.
I Ate Their Secret—Now I Hunt Them
I Ate Their Secret—Now I Hunt Them
4.9
One bite changed everything. When a haunted detective is forced back to work in famine-ravaged 1946 Chicago, he finds a gruesome crime scene—two powerful men butchered and a cryptic message scrawled in blood. As whispers of missing children and forbidden feasts swirl, Detective Price chases a killer known only as the Weed Puller—a legend who punishes monsters the law can’t touch. But the deeper he digs, the more Price realizes the city’s elite are hiding unspeakable sins, and the only clues lie in a meal he can never forget. Trapped between loyalty, guilt, and vengeance, Price faces a choice: uphold a broken law, or become a monster to stop even greater evil. When friend turns to foe and every ally might be a traitor, can Price escape his own darkness—or is he destined to finish the work of a killer who shares his face?
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
4.8
I thought I was gaming my way home—until I realized I’d seduced the wrong man: Chase Milton, the infamous horror boss who hates men like me. Now I’m trapped as his college roommate, desperate to hide my secret and survive a year without losing my head… or my heart. But when the truth comes out, will he destroy me, or is the real danger falling for the monster I unleashed?
Benny Said Jump—And I Watched
Benny Said Jump—And I Watched
4.9
A child’s cartoon obsession turns into a waking nightmare when a father catches his son nearly leaping from an upstairs window—claiming a talking bear is calling him to a honey waterfall. As other neighborhood kids begin showing mysterious wounds and sharing the same impossible story, the line between hallucination and haunting blurs. No adult can see the grinning bear with a chainsaw, yet the evidence keeps piling up: cryptic codes, secret scars, and a circle of children bound by a game with deadly rules. Can a parent uncover the truth behind Benny the Bear before another child vanishes—or will the forest cabin claim them all? What really happens when only the chosen can see what's coming?