My Pet Shop Ate His Monster / Chapter 2: A Bloody Stranger and a Feathered Secret
My Pet Shop Ate His Monster

My Pet Shop Ate His Monster

Author: Matthew Gross


Chapter 2: A Bloody Stranger and a Feathered Secret

Suddenly—oh, crap—the man lying on the ground convulsed and coughed up a mouthful of blood.

The wet, choking sound snapped me back to the present. My stomach lurched. The floor was already stained, and now it looked like a crime scene. I dropped to my knees beside him, suddenly aware of just how serious this was.

I’d been so focused on the rooster, I’d forgotten there was an injured guy here.

My cheeks burned with embarrassment. Only I could get distracted by a chicken in the middle of an emergency. I muttered a quick apology to the universe and got to work.

I hauled him onto my little rest cot and carefully cut open his shirt.

The cot creaked under his weight. I grabbed the scissors from the first aid kit and snipped through layers of fabric, careful not to jostle him too much. The wounds underneath made me wince.

Yikes—he looked skinny and frail, but he was made of tougher stuff.

His muscles were corded and lean, the kind of build you’d see on a marathon runner or someone who spent their days climbing trees. But the bruises and cuts told a different story—he’d been through hell. Wild stuff.

But his whole body was a mess of wounds. Ugh.

There were scratches, bite marks, and what looked like burns. Some of the wounds were still bleeding. Others had already started to scab over. It was a patchwork of pain, and I felt a surge of sympathy.

I could just make out that the claw marks on his chest were from some kind of wildcat, and the holes in his shoulder looked like snake bites…

I paused, tracing the jagged lines with my eyes, piecing together the story—he’d fought something fierce, and barely made it out alive. The punctures on his shoulder oozed a weird, dark fluid. Gross. Poison, maybe? I didn’t want to think about it too hard.

I grabbed the first aid kit and started disinfecting and bandaging his wounds. Deep breath, Mallory.

I worked quickly, dabbing antiseptic on every cut, wrapping gauze as best I could. You got this, I told myself. My hands shook, but I kept going, fueled by adrenaline and the stubborn hope that I could actually help.

After half an hour of work, I’d used up the last of the shop’s water. Seriously?

The final drops trickled from the bottle as I wiped down a nasty scratch on his arm. I tossed the empty jug in the trash, feeling a knot of dread tighten in my stomach. No more water—not even for myself.

"Whew…"

I wiped the sweat from my forehead, finally able to catch my breath.

I slumped against the wall, hands sticky with blood and antiseptic. Great. Just what I needed. The animals watched me with wide eyes, as if they knew I was running on fumes.

"Uh, water…"

A while later, the guy on the bed finally looked alive again.

His eyes flickered open, glassy but focused. He licked his cracked lips and tried to sit up, voice barely above a whisper. For someone who’d just survived a monster attack, he looked surprisingly lucid. Tough guy.

Honestly, his resilience was insane. All I did was disinfect his wounds and give him a couple of Tylenol. And he managed to recover on his own.

I’d seen tough customers before—guys who shrugged off bee stings and broken bones—but this was something else. Dang.

"You want water? I don’t even have any left myself," I admitted helplessly.

I gestured at the empty bottle, trying to keep my tone light. "If you find a stream out there, let me know. I’ll trade you a bag of kibble for a drink."

Looks like I really would have to go out and find some water soon. Ugh.

I glanced at the door, weighing my options. Brave the woods, or wait for a miracle? Neither sounded great.

Come on, there’s got to be a drop out there in that huge forest. Right?

I tried to convince myself, even as my nerves jangled. The forest was endless—there had to be a creek or pond somewhere. I just had to get past the fear of what else might be lurking out there.

But I was worried about running into wolves. I shuddered.

The howls I’d heard at night weren’t just my imagination. No way. Out here, wolves were real, and probably a lot weirder than the ones in nature documentaries.

"Wait, don’t hurt me—"

Suddenly, the man on the bed sat bolt upright. He moved too quickly and tumbled to the floor.

He crashed to the ground with a groan, clutching his side. Ouch. I rushed over, worried he’d reopened his wounds, but he just looked around, wild-eyed and confused.

Only then did he notice his surroundings. He blinked, taking it all in.

His gaze darted from the parakeet cages to the wall of dog food, and then to me, as if trying to piece together how he’d ended up in a place like this. Poor guy. I almost laughed.

"Where… where am I?"

"Welcome to Soft & Fluffy Pet Shop. I’m the owner, Mallory Grant," I said, trying to sound like I had my act together.

My voice came out steadier than I felt. I gave him a small, reassuring smile, the same one I used on nervous customers back home. Fake it till you make it, right?

He took a while to collect himself, then suddenly gave me a formal nod. "I’m Lucas DeWitt, junior member of the Moonridge Pack—thank you, ma’am, for saving my life."

He said it with a kind of old-school seriousness, like he was pledging allegiance or something. I tried not to laugh, but it was oddly charming.

"Saving a life matters more than any big project. It was nothing, really—I didn’t do much."

I shrugged, trying to play it cool. Not sure what else to say.

"You’re too modest. To run a shop in dangerous Ridgewood Forest, you must be incredibly strong."

His tone was earnest, and I could tell he meant every word. My cheeks heated up again—compliments like that weren’t exactly common in my old life. Weird, but… kind of nice.

"Uh, if you say so."

No one had ever complimented me like that—I felt a little embarrassed. Awkward.

I fiddled with a loose thread on my sleeve, unsure how to respond. The animals seemed to sense my discomfort and settled down, as if giving me space to process it all.

You may also like

Claimed by the Monster Groom
Claimed by the Monster Groom
4.9
Abandoned, scapegoated, and used as bait, Jason Reed is the team’s unwanted outcast—until a fatal leap delivers him into the arms of a monstrous suitor. As betrayal deepens and the poison in his veins spreads, Jason must decide whether to fight for survival or surrender to a love that’s not quite human. In this deadly game, who will save Jason’s soul: the team that never wanted him, or the monster who calls him bride?
My Grandma’s Cat Is Internet Famous
My Grandma’s Cat Is Internet Famous
4.6
Abandoned by the city, I became Grandma’s reluctant sidekick—until a viral talent show turned me into the internet’s favorite ‘Boss Cat.’ But even as #WhiskersTheBoss trends worldwide, my biggest battles are at home: a stubborn old lady, a heartbroken grandson, and a country full of chickens who want revenge. When the boy suddenly hears me talk, everything changes—because in this family, even the cat has secrets.
My Cat Is Plotting My Death
My Cat Is Plotting My Death
4.6
After catching her cat planting a thumbtack under her pillow on home security footage, a lonely office worker realizes her cuddly companion might be a criminal mastermind. As paranoia spirals, every innocent purr and midnight cuddle starts to feel like a threat—and even her friends warn her that cats are never truly tamed. But when her cat fakes an injury to stay, the chilling truth emerges: this isn’t just a pet, it’s a predator with unfinished business.
Stolen Hope, Loyal Hearts
Stolen Hope, Loyal Hearts
4.8
When the neighborhood’s most beloved dog, Peanut, is stolen by pet traffickers, his devoted owner teams up with a gang of strays, a fierce calico cat, and a determined little girl to launch a daring rescue—uncovering a world of animal heroics, unexpected friendships, and the power of never giving up.
Varsity Monsters: I Refused the Coach's Pill
Varsity Monsters: I Refused the Coach's Pill
4.8
When Tommy is recruited to elite Silver Hollow Academy, the 'miracle kid' discovers the school's star athletes owe their powers to parasitic worms hidden inside a 'supplement' pill. Refusing to swallow the horror, he fakes his way through tryouts—until he learns his hometown was slaughtered by the very teammates he trusted. Now hunted and haunted, Tommy must choose: become a monster to survive, or die fighting the truth everyone else is too afraid to see.
Buddy's Grin
Buddy's Grin
4.9
Haunted by tragedy, Eli’s rural childhood unravels into a chilling blend of memory and nightmare after his beloved raccoon, Buddy, mimics a deadly act. As suspicion, loss, and guilt fracture his family, Eli’s grip on reality blurs—forcing him to confront the horrifying possibility that his memories may be hiding something even darker. With every revelation, the line between innocence and monstrosity grows perilously thin.
My Ex Is a Peacock, My Boyfriend’s a Snake
My Ex Is a Peacock, My Boyfriend’s a Snake
4.9
Jealous birds, talking snakes, and a reality show gone wild—my life was weird enough before a viral peacock turned me into America’s favorite underdog. When my animal co-stars start acting suspiciously human, I realize I’m caught between a shape-shifting junior who loves me, a rival with secrets, and a dangerous backstage betrayal that could end it all. Fame, friendship, and forbidden romance collide as I race to save my animals—and my own heart. But when the cameras stop rolling, who can I really trust: the snake at my side, or the peacock I never truly left behind? Will my wildest love story survive the spotlight—or will it unravel in the shadows?
He Smiled—But He Wasn't a Child
He Smiled—But He Wasn't a Child
4.9
A child’s smile can hide the darkest secrets. When Morgan agrees to watch her best friend’s nephew, she expects a quiet week of cartoons and playtime—not a series of chilling requests and a set of child-sized dentures hidden in her guest room. As her neighbor is murdered and the clues point to someone—or something—small and innocent, Morgan’s reality unravels. Who is the boy in her care, and what happened to the real Tyler? When the lights go out and escape seems impossible, Morgan must confront the terrifying truth: the greatest threat may be the child she let in. Will she survive the night—or is she already too late to lock the monster out?
Eaten Alive by Monsters for Immortality
Eaten Alive by Monsters for Immortality
4.8
With only months left to live, a cancer-stricken man leaps to his death—only to wake up in a world of monsters hungry for his flesh. To survive, he must outwit demons who believe eating a 'preacher' brings immortality, using nothing but his chemistry smarts and a desperate will to live. Every lie, every scheme, is a gamble: if he fails, he'll end up roasted on their spit.
I Ate Their Secret—Now I Hunt Them
I Ate Their Secret—Now I Hunt Them
4.9
One bite changed everything. When a haunted detective is forced back to work in famine-ravaged 1946 Chicago, he finds a gruesome crime scene—two powerful men butchered and a cryptic message scrawled in blood. As whispers of missing children and forbidden feasts swirl, Detective Price chases a killer known only as the Weed Puller—a legend who punishes monsters the law can’t touch. But the deeper he digs, the more Price realizes the city’s elite are hiding unspeakable sins, and the only clues lie in a meal he can never forget. Trapped between loyalty, guilt, and vengeance, Price faces a choice: uphold a broken law, or become a monster to stop even greater evil. When friend turns to foe and every ally might be a traitor, can Price escape his own darkness—or is he destined to finish the work of a killer who shares his face?
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
Rooming With the Horror Boss I Seduced
4.8
I thought I was gaming my way home—until I realized I’d seduced the wrong man: Chase Milton, the infamous horror boss who hates men like me. Now I’m trapped as his college roommate, desperate to hide my secret and survive a year without losing my head… or my heart. But when the truth comes out, will he destroy me, or is the real danger falling for the monster I unleashed?
Benny Said Jump—And I Watched
Benny Said Jump—And I Watched
4.9
A child’s cartoon obsession turns into a waking nightmare when a father catches his son nearly leaping from an upstairs window—claiming a talking bear is calling him to a honey waterfall. As other neighborhood kids begin showing mysterious wounds and sharing the same impossible story, the line between hallucination and haunting blurs. No adult can see the grinning bear with a chainsaw, yet the evidence keeps piling up: cryptic codes, secret scars, and a circle of children bound by a game with deadly rules. Can a parent uncover the truth behind Benny the Bear before another child vanishes—or will the forest cabin claim them all? What really happens when only the chosen can see what's coming?