One Wrong Answer, Everyone Dies / Chapter 4: Waking From the Nightmare?
One Wrong Answer, Everyone Dies

One Wrong Answer, Everyone Dies

Author: Harold Hayes


Chapter 4: Waking From the Nightmare?

← Prev

Finality.

My phone started beeping.

The sound was shrill, insistent. I clapped my hands over my ears.

Too loud.

It felt like the whole bus exploded, the blast roaring through my mind like a tidal wave.

A blinding white light filled my vision. My body jerked, every muscle tensed.

Physicality.

My whole body jolted violently.

I gasped, heart hammering. For a second, I thought I was dead.

"What’s wrong? We’re at the stop. Time to get off."

Autumn’s voice was soft, concerned. I blinked, trying to clear my head.

Disoriented.

I forced my eyes open.

The harsh bus lights came into focus. I was back in my seat, drenched in sweat.

Autumn was looking at me with concern.

She reached out, touching my forehead. Her eyes were wide with worry.

Her concern lingered in the air.

"What’s wrong? You’re sweating buckets. Here, wipe off."

She handed me some tissues.

The paper felt rough against my skin. I wiped my face, trying to steady my breathing.

Was it really over?

I wiped my sweat away mechanically, still a little dazed.

My hands shook. The nightmare clung to me, refusing to let go.

Fake it.

Seeing the worry in her eyes, I managed a weak smile.

I forced my lips into a smile, hoping to reassure her. It didn’t quite reach my eyes.

"It’s nothing. Just had a nightmare."

The words felt flimsy, but it was all I could manage.

Autumn nodded. "If you’re fine, let’s go. The driver’s waiting for us to get off."

Relief.

She stood up, slinging her bag over her shoulder. I could see the relief in her posture.

I looked at the driver. He gave me a simple, honest smile.

Normal.

His eyes were kind, his face relaxed. He looked nothing like the monster from my dream.

He tipped his cap, nodding politely. For a second, I almost laughed at myself.

So it really was just a dream? Maybe I’ve just been too stressed lately.

The city always found new ways to wear you down. Maybe this was just my brain’s way of coping.

With Autumn’s help, I stepped off the bus, my legs shaky.

Free.

The pavement was cold beneath my sneakers. I leaned on her, grateful for her steadying arm.

Just as we were about to leave the station, I suddenly glanced back, as if sensing something.

Not over.

A chill ran down my spine. I turned, heart pounding.

I saw the bus tires were tangled with bits of flesh and two clumps of human hair.

Horror.

The sight made my stomach lurch. For a moment, I wondered if I was still dreaming.

A shiver ran down my spine.

Haunted.

I hugged myself, rubbing my arms. The night air felt colder than before.

Autumn looked even more worried.

She stepped closer, wrapping her arm around my waist. Her eyes searched my face for answers.

Comfort.

"Are you coming down with something? Let’s get home, I’ll make you some ginger tea to warm you up."

Her voice was gentle, soothing. The promise of warmth and comfort was all I wanted.

I nodded vaguely, letting her help me walk forward on unsteady legs.

Home.

My mind spun with questions, but I pushed them aside. All I wanted was to get home.

Suddenly, I saw a familiar face.

He was standing beneath the streetlight, hands in his pockets. The man with glasses.

Him.

That man with glasses!

He looked just as he had on the bus—calm, composed, slightly out of place.

"Wait! Hey, you up ahead, wait!"

I called out, my voice echoing across the empty lot. He stopped, turning slowly.

The man turned around. When he saw it was me, the confusion on his face vanished.

He knew.

Recognition flickered in his eyes. He waited, as if he’d expected me.

He didn’t seem surprised that I’d called out to him.

He smiled, just a little, as if sharing a private joke.

"Can I help you?"

His voice was calm, almost amused. He watched me patiently.

"Would you like to come over to my place?"

The words tumbled out before I could stop them. My cheeks flushed with embarrassment.

Awkwardness.

I blurted out the invitation without thinking.

I realized how weird it sounded. I barely knew this guy.

Too much.

When I saw him start to frown, I realized I was being a bit abrupt.

He hesitated, glancing at Autumn, then back at me. I cleared my throat, trying to recover.

I tried to laugh it off, but the awkwardness hung in the air.

Awkward.

Autumn caught up, puzzled. "What are you doing?"

She looked from me to the man, eyebrows raised.

I smiled awkwardly.

What was I doing?

I rubbed the back of my neck, searching for the right words.

"Just felt like we had a connection. How about we grab a meal together?"

I tried to sound casual, but my voice wavered. The invitation felt important, somehow.

Intuition.

The man with glasses studied me for a moment.

He looked me up and down, weighing his options. The silence stretched.

After a long pause, he finally replied.

He nodded, almost imperceptibly. "All right, if you insist. There’s a diner around the corner—let’s go there."

Autumn still looked uneasy. "But aren’t you feeling sick? Maybe you should just exchange numbers and meet up another time?"

She touched my arm, concern etched on her face. I shook my head, determination settling in.

Resolve.

"No, I’m fine now."

I managed a real smile this time, feeling lighter than I had in hours.

Even though there were no more floating comments, I had a powerful hunch:

It was more than a feeling—it was certainty, deep in my bones. I couldn’t explain it, but I knew.

If I didn’t have this meal with the man in glasses today, I’d regret it for the rest of my life.

For the first time all night, I felt like maybe, just maybe, I'd found the way out.

← Prev

You may also like

The Exam That Kills You
The Exam That Kills You
4.9
The first question on the exam was supposed to be easy—until the proctor melted into the chalkboard and kids who broke the rules rotted away before my eyes. Now, every answer could mean death. Trapped in a classroom where the only way out is to survive a series of twisted, logic-bending questions, I’m forced to lead terrified classmates, unravel deadly rules, and choose who lives or dies. Secret alliances form, trust is a weapon, and every second brings us closer to the next impossible test. Can I keep us alive when the rules change with every breath—or will the next answer be my last?
I Died on SAT Day—And She Waited
I Died on SAT Day—And She Waited
4.9
Waking up in my old high school classroom on SAT day—a decade after graduation—I’m surrounded by classmates who should be strangers, and haunted by the ghost of Autumn Reese, the girl I once loved and lost. Blood-red questions ooze across the whiteboard, and every wrong answer means death in new, horrifying ways. The proctor’s grin is too wide, the rules keep changing, and the only person who seems to know what’s happening is Autumn, who’s both a lifeline and a mystery. As classmates vanish one by one and the classroom warps into a nightmare, Autumn reveals a chilling truth: we’re trapped in a time loop, and the only way out is to survive the tests—together. But can I trust a ghost with secrets of her own? And what happens when the next question is about me?
The Exam That Wouldn't Let Us Leave
The Exam That Wouldn't Let Us Leave
4.9
One moment, Autumn Reed was just another anxious senior staring down the final practice exam—then her teacher exploded in front of the entire class. Sealed in their classroom by unbreakable doors and a cold, omnipotent voice, the students are forced to obey twisted exam rules where every mistake means death. When the first question demands that Autumn judge herself, she realizes survival means more than just getting the right answer—it means understanding the darkness inside her classmates, and herself. As terror builds and the rules grow crueler, who will break first: the test, the system, or Autumn? When the next question arrives, will anyone be left to answer?
Death Loop: Livestreamed for Their Amusement
Death Loop: Livestreamed for Their Amusement
4.9
Every choice is broadcast. Every mistake is fatal. After a long shift, I stumble across an old man collapsed on the sidewalk—only to find my life hijacked by a cruel, anonymous chat that predicts my death with chilling accuracy. Help, and I’m scammed and murdered; run, and I die faster. Each death resets the night, with thousands of unseen viewers critiquing my every move. As I spiral through endless loops—stabbed, run over, ambushed—I realize the rules are rigged, and the only way out is to outsmart the bloodthirsty Carl Mason and his trap. But with every rebirth, the stakes grow higher, the watchers more vicious, and the line between reality and performance blurs. How do you survive when the world wants you dead—and your choices are just part of the show?
Choose Who Dies: The Ghost’s Game
Choose Who Dies: The Ghost’s Game
4.7
Every text you answer becomes reality, and now you must pick who dies: your mom, your best friend, or yourself. When your prank-loving friend is attacked by a rotting ghost on FaceTime, you realize this is no joke—and your family’s darkest secret is locked in the basement. With a haunted contract in hand and your mother acting strangely, can you survive the night, or will the next choice be your last?
Seven Days to Survive: Hospital Hell
Seven Days to Survive: Hospital Hell
4.9
Trust the wrong doctor, and you die. That’s the one rule Avery clings to after being yanked into a horror survival game disguised as a hospital—where every patient is terminal, every line is a death sentence, and the only way out is to outsmart a system built to break you. With his best friend Connor at his side, Avery battles the desperate, the ruthless, and the mercilessly efficient staff—where one mistake means a brutal, public end. But as the hospital’s twisted rules tighten their grip, Avery realizes survival isn’t about following orders—it’s about breaking them. Can he rally strangers, defy the guards, and escape before the clock runs out, or will hope be the next thing to die in these halls? When the line between patient and prey vanishes, who do you trust with your life?
Trapped With a Monster: The Amtrak Test
Trapped With a Monster: The Amtrak Test
4.7
A routine train ride turns to terror when a killer disguised as a passenger starts hunting in plain sight—leaving bodies sliced in half and no way to call for help. As armed agents storm the train and force everyone to answer chilling, inhuman questions, I realize one wrong answer could mark me as the next victim. My only ally is Uncle Ben, but even he’s hiding secrets about the thing hunting us… and why it wants me most.
Mall of Death: Survive the Blood-Red Rules
Mall of Death: Survive the Blood-Red Rules
4.7
A Saturday at Willowbrook Mall turns into a nightmare when a sinister voice traps everyone inside, forcing them to play a deadly shopping game—break the rules and you die. Natalie must outwit twisted store challenges, choose who to trust, and risk everything for a chance to survive. But with every receipt earned, the line between victim and executioner blurs, and one wrong move means joining the bodies piling up on the tile.
Burned Alive, Sent Back Home
Burned Alive, Sent Back Home
4.9
Death should have been the end—so why did I wake up right before my aunt poured boiling oil over my head? When Eli tries to save his entitled cousin from a shady warehouse job, he’s blamed, betrayed, and killed by the family he tried to protect. But fate grants him a cruel gift: a second chance to survive the same toxic kitchen, the same manipulations, and the same doomed choices. This time, every word and action could spark another explosion—or finally break the chains of blame. Can Eli rewrite his family’s fate, or will he burn all over again? When the truth goes live, who will survive the fallout?
Trapped in Time: The Genius Nobody Knows
Trapped in Time: The Genius Nobody Knows
4.7
Every time Alex Carter fails a test, he’s yanked back a week, forced to relive his life until he masters every answer. But perfection comes at a cost: years stolen, sanity fraying, and a hollow victory no one else can see. When the loop shifts to control his future, Alex must choose between surrendering to fate—or risking everything to break free, even if it means losing himself.
Only One Killer Gets Out Alive
Only One Killer Gets Out Alive
4.8
Fifteen years after Rachel's 'suicide,' a mysterious blackmailer resurfaces, threatening to expose Caleb and Jason's darkest secret: they pushed her off the roof to save themselves. Now, with their lives and families on the line, Caleb must decide—betray his only friend, or become a killer again to keep the truth buried. In this small-town Midwest nightmare, only one of them will survive the final reckoning.
Seven Days Trapped With My Enemy
Seven Days Trapped With My Enemy
5.0
When a mysterious lockdown traps six college friends on campus, one text message with 25 chilling rules is the only thing standing between them and unspeakable horrors. As classmates die and the dead return, trust crumbles and survival means risking everything—including betraying those closest to you. In a game where breaking the rules is fatal, who will make it out alive?