Rivals, Rumors, and Her Secret Thoughts / Chapter 3: Reality Show, Real Feelings
Rivals, Rumors, and Her Secret Thoughts

Rivals, Rumors, and Her Secret Thoughts

Author: Ethan Ward


Chapter 3: Reality Show, Real Feelings

I had a long-term reality show gig, and suddenly, Savannah showed up as a guest.

The producers loved a surprise twist. When Savannah walked onto the set, the crew actually gasped.

She stood next to me for her introduction, but inside, she was thinking: [So happy to see Autumn baby again.]

I caught her eye and smiled, trying to play it cool. My heart fluttered anyway.

As a regular, I led the welcome.

I gave her the standard introduction, but she looked at me like I’d just handed her a bouquet of roses.

Savannah’s inner voice:

[Autumn baby is so gentle~]

I was standing close, so I smiled: "Thanks, but you could say that on camera too, since it’s a compliment."

She grinned, catching my meaning. For a moment, it felt like we were the only two people in the room.

Savannah immediately gave me a knowing look.

She winked, her eyes sparkling with mischief.

When we played games, I got paired with another male guest. Savannah suddenly cheered for me: "Autumn, you got this! You’re the best!"

The whole set went quiet. Even the cameraman looked confused. I tried not to laugh.

???

That’s not how you cheer someone on!

I shot her a look, but she just grinned wider. She was shameless.

After the game, Savannah came over and wiped the sweat from my brow: "Autumn looks even prettier when she’s sweating."

I nearly dropped the towel. She was relentless.

Could she just act normal for once?

I tried to step away, but she followed me like a puppy. The audience was eating it up.

My body stiffened for a beat.

I muttered, "Thanks, but I’ve got it." She just laughed.

Weren’t we supposed to keep things low-key in public?

Apparently, Savannah didn’t get the memo. Or maybe she just didn’t care.

The livestream audience was stunned:

[Who said they weren’t close? She’s calling her baby on air—how is that not close?]

[Maybe it’s just their fans who hate each other. The stars themselves are practically glowing with pink bubbles. That hug at the last awards show trended too.]

[Honestly, if they weren’t both women, I’d be shipping them.]

[Careful, shipping everything will only get you hurt!]

Forget bystanders—even our own fans were shocked, staring at each other:

[What’s going on? Weren’t we rivals?]

Savannah fans: [It’s fake. Savannah is just doing this for the show. Poor thing.]

Autumn fans: [Poor my ass! Your Savannah is the one trying to get close—afraid our Autumn will leave her out. Don’t worry, our Autumn is super kind and won’t ignore any guest.]

Savannah fans: [Yeah right! Savannah is way more famous than Autumn! If the show hadn’t invited her, she wouldn’t be here!]

Autumn fans: [Then don’t come! Everyone knows our Autumn is a regular—your Savannah just wants in!]

[...]

Bystander fans: [Seriously, you can fight over anything?! No wonder half the internet’s trolls are Savannah and Autumn fans!]

Even I, the person involved, was speechless.

I wanted to crawl under a table. Why did our fans have to be so dramatic?

Before I could say anything, Savannah beat me to it. She @’d me on Instagram: [My relationship with Autumn isn’t what everyone thinks. She’s a great actress and friend, and I hope we can work together more.]

She posted a photo of us laughing together, just to drive the point home.

I quickly followed up: [Yes, Savannah and I get along well. Looking forward to more collaborations. Hope everyone won’t buy into rumors.]

I added a heart emoji, just to be extra clear.

With both of us speaking up, our fans finally called a truce.

The comment sections actually calmed down for once. It was a miracle.

Savannah started openly interacting with me on camera. We went from being rivals to gradually becoming good friends.

We started posting silly TikToks together, sharing inside jokes. People began to root for our friendship instead of tearing it down.

Why did things change so fast?

Because, honestly, I liked her too. Maybe even before she liked me.

I realized I’d been looking for excuses to talk to her, to be near her. It was embarrassing, but true.

So whenever our fans fought, I was the first to explain. I never wanted to be rivals with her. I’d worked so hard to reach her level—not to be together, just to be friends.

It was never about beating her. I just wanted to stand beside her, as an equal.

But it seemed she didn’t feel the same. I slowly gave up, accepting that the person I liked didn’t like me back.

I told myself to move on, to focus on my career. But my heart wouldn’t listen.

Later, when I started hearing her thoughts, I’d rather believe I was hallucinating than accept she liked me too.

It was easier to pretend it was all in my head. Safer, too.

Every time she got closer, I panicked and pulled away. I was scared. I’d been disappointed too many times—terrified that this would be another heartbreak.

I’d been burned before. I didn’t want to risk it again.

But this time, she was serious.

She didn’t give up, no matter how many walls I put up. Slowly, I let myself hope.

Still, I decided to keep my feelings hidden a little longer. Even brave people get cautious after being hurt.

I needed time to trust her—and myself.

If she hadn’t caught me and realized I liked her, I wouldn’t have admitted it so soon.

I’m stubborn like that. Sometimes, I need a push.

I kind of enjoyed seeing her obsessed with me but unable to get me—she was adorable that way.

Watching her flustered was a guilty pleasure. She deserved a little payback for all the times she’d driven me crazy.

Savannah, frustrated, pinned me against the door and kissed my cheek. "Baby, you should’ve told me you liked me. I was afraid I’d scare you."

Her voice was soft, almost shy. I’d never seen her like this before.

Once she realized I was playing hard to get, Savannah dropped the act and showed her true colors.

She became bolder, more affectionate. It was like a switch flipped inside her.

But I pushed her onto the bed: "Who’s scaring who? We’ll see."

I grinned, feeling braver than ever. If she wanted a challenge, I’d give her one.

Savannah froze, then smirked, hooked her arms around my neck, and pulled me down.

She pulled me close, her eyes sparkling. "Oh? I’d like to see that."

You may also like

He Posted, I Roasted: Rival Hearts
He Posted, I Roasted: Rival Hearts
4.9
Rivalry was supposed to be fun—until he confessed where only I could see. Ava Collins just survived the SATs, but her relief is short-lived when Carter Brooks—the school’s golden boy and her accidental arch-nemesis—drops a cryptic Instagram confession that sends her heart and social feed into chaos. Their battle of wits spills from the digital world to the classroom, where sarcastic taunts, embarrassing test scores, and one humiliating height scandal threaten to tip their rivalry into something much more complicated. As pride, jealousy, and a secret history simmer beneath every comeback, Ava’s determined to reclaim her crown—even if it means playing Carter’s game. But when the lines between enemy and something else start to blur, who’ll score first: her heart or his? Will a single “I like you” ruin everything—or is it the start of the biggest twist yet?
Confession Wall: Stolen by the Valedictorian's Rival
Confession Wall: Stolen by the Valedictorian's Rival
4.6
Aubrey’s life shatters when a vicious rumor and a humiliating slur appear on her desk, painting her as the enemy of the school’s queen bee—and the target of every anonymous confession. The new transfer, Mallory, will do anything to reclaim her throne and the valedictorian, even if it means destroying Aubrey’s reputation. But when Noah steps in to defend her, the lines between love, loyalty, and betrayal ignite a war that the whole school is watching.
Rivals & Roses: Love’s Wicked Game
Rivals & Roses: Love’s Wicked Game
5.0
Mariah Jennings has always played second fiddle—overshadowed by the perfect Savannah Lee and desperate for the love of the unattainable Julian Carter. But as jealousy, schemes, and unexpected kindness blur the lines between rivalry and obsession, Mariah faces a choice: cling to old grudges or risk everything for a love she never saw coming. In this high-stakes web of betrayal and longing, who will claim the spotlight—and who will be left in the shadows?
Three Years His Secret, One Night His Threat
Three Years His Secret, One Night His Threat
4.8
Love isn’t supposed to feel like a secret sentence—until you’re three years deep and nobody knows your name. Riley Lane is Jackson Whitmore’s hidden obsession, trapped in a penthouse world of midnight rendezvous, bruised hearts, and rules she never wrote. But when an old yearbook photo—and a reunion with the boy she once loved—forces her to choose between habit and hope, the stakes turn lethal. Is Jackson just a cold-hearted player, or something darker? As jealousy explodes and every lie unravels, Riley faces the truth: some cages are built from longing, and some lovers don’t let go without a fight. When loyalty and desire collide, will she finally break free—or is she the one who can’t let go?
I Kissed His Rival, Not My Crush
I Kissed His Rival, Not My Crush
4.9
She kissed the wrong boy—and it changed everything. For years, everyone believed Lila was hopelessly in love with her cocky stepbrother Carter, but she kept her real feelings hidden, even from herself. One impulsive dare turns the rumor mill upside down, igniting Carter’s jealousy and exposing the tangled secrets of their past. When her quiet crush Mason reappears, Lila is forced to choose: keep playing Carter’s game, or finally step into her own story. But as old wounds resurface and new sparks fly, Lila learns that the truth is messier—and far more dangerous—than any high school gossip. When a simple birthday dinner reunites her with Mason, he asks the one question she’s never dared answer. Is she ready to risk everything for the chance at something real?
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
I Was the Villain, Now I’m Trending
4.9
Falling for America’s sweetheart was never part of the script—but neither was waking up as the villain girl on a live gaming reality show. Now, every move I make is under the world’s microscope, every glance with Savannah (the girl I’m supposed to hate) becomes a viral ship, and my biggest rival is her gorgeous, mysterious brother. As alliances shift and the internet explodes with rumors, I have to decide: chase the win, protect my new friends, or risk it all for a love that’s as unexpected as my sudden fame. But with a possessive “lone wolf” prince and a meddling future mother-in-law in the mix, will my real happy ending survive the spotlight—or will I lose everything the moment the cameras stop rolling?
Coach’s Secret: Touched in the Locker Room
Coach’s Secret: Touched in the Locker Room
4.9
After a humiliating scandal rocks Silver Hollow Academy, sophomore 'Little Five' must fight to keep her place on the team—and her secrets buried. Torn between loyalty, guilt, and a forbidden connection with Coach, every rumor and stare threatens to unravel her life. One wrong move, and she could lose everything she’s ever fought for.
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
Stolen by My Boyfriend’s Secret Admirer
4.8
When I defend a classmate from public humiliation, she turns her gratitude toward my boyfriend—and then invades every corner of our lives. Betrayed and blindsided, I fight to keep my love and dignity as a cunning rival spins a web of lies and sabotage. With my relationship and reputation at stake, I must decide: stand my ground or lose everything to the girl I tried to save.
Rumor Has It, I’m Chasing Him
Rumor Has It, I’m Chasing Him
5.0
Love is louder than small-town gossip—if you’re bold enough to chase it. Savannah Carter has always gone after what she wants, but when her daily hospital visits to Chris spark rumors, she finds herself at the center of Maple Heights’ favorite pastime: speculation. As she fights for a chance to win Chris’s heart (armed with pastries and stubborn hope), the whispers grow louder, making her question who she really is. But when Chris finally sees her, not the stories, everything changes. A garden ladder, a sour grape, and a name scrawled in careful handwriting spark a slow-burning romance neither expected. Can Savannah and Chris find something real in a town built on secrets—or will the truth about their feelings be the sweetest risk of all?
I Was Her Secret—Until He Showed Up
I Was Her Secret—Until He Showed Up
4.9
One blind date, two lives on the line. When Eli’s family arranges a date, his online girlfriend Savannah finally agrees to meet—just as her old-money world closes in. Humiliated by her rich friends and facing down a smug rival fiancé, Eli’s secret past and true strength are put to the test. But as the insults fly and alliances shift, Savannah’s loyalty—and Eli’s mysterious connections—threaten to turn the game upside down. When Savannah’s powerful father steps in, who will claim her future: the billionaire crown prince, or the underdog with a government plate and secrets to burn? In a world where love is currency and reputation is everything, can Eli prove he’s more than what meets the eye—or will he walk away before his past catches up? Whose side will Savannah choose when the truth finally comes out?
I Saved Her—Now I’m the Heartthrob
I Saved Her—Now I’m the Heartthrob
4.9
She’s the campus heartthrob—except she’s secretly a girl, navigating a high school drama where the boys get all the screen time and the livestream comments never sleep. Riley Brooks only wanted to blend into the background, but when she steps in to save the school’s golden couple from disaster, she’s thrust into a storm of viral rumors, jealous rivals, and secrets even she can’t admit. As accusations fly and loyalties fracture, Riley must choose: protect her own secret, or stand up for the girls who never get their own story? When the heroine finally breaks the script, who will be left standing in the spotlight—and what happens when the truth is the biggest twist of all?
She Stole My Spotlight, I Stole the Show
She Stole My Spotlight, I Stole the Show
5.0
She was the reality star everyone rooted for—until her frenemy stole her spotlight, her job, and almost her future. But Brooke Lane isn’t just a pretty face in a ruthless industry; she’s a survivor with a secret dream—and a family legacy no one sees coming. When a viral dating show throws her together with Carter, the awkward 'poor boy' with a tractor and a hidden past, their chemistry sets the internet ablaze. But fame is a double-edged sword, and when a scandal explodes—framed by the same rival who’s haunted her career—Brooke must choose: retreat into obscurity, or fight for her truth in front of millions. With her reputation, her love life, and her future on the line, will Brooke finally claim the life she deserves—or lose everything to a world that never played fair? What happens when the underdog refuses to stay down?