She Catfished Him With My Face / Chapter 5: Truth, Forgiveness, and Second Chances
She Catfished Him With My Face

She Catfished Him With My Face

Author: Tyler King MD


Chapter 5: Truth, Forgiveness, and Second Chances

In the police station hallway, I sat on a bench, bandaging Ryan’s hand.

“How hard did you hit them? Your hand’s all bruised and bleeding.”

His fair, slender hand was red and bloody at the knuckles.

Ryan’s face was ice-cold.

“If the police had come any later, I’d have killed those two animals.”

I didn’t doubt it. When Scarface and Baldy were taken away, they were unconscious—still in the hospital now.

“Did you come to see me for something?”

Ryan pulled something from his pocket and handed it to me.

“You said your face was scratched. I brought you some ointment.”

Looking at the blue tube, a strange feeling welled up in me, and I couldn’t help but smile.

After bandaging his hand, Ryan walked over to Mallory, who had just finished her statement.

The camera Mallory had so cleverly brought with her became the strongest evidence of her and the two men’s crimes, along with her phone full of explicit chat logs.

The next few years, her companions would be a cold prison bed and a whole lot of regrets.

“Can I talk to her for a minute?” Ryan asked the police.

They nodded, stepping out and closing the door.

For a moment, only Ryan and Mallory were left, staring at each other through the bars.

Uh... and me, eavesdropping outside the door.

After a while, Mallory spoke first.

“If I told you the girlfriend you treasure is a fraud, would you be hurt?”

Her voice was low, but full of desperate spite.

Ryan didn’t react.

“What do you mean?”

Mallory slammed the table, her face twisted as she shouted,

“The person who chatted with you for a year wasn’t her—it was me! The one who called you ‘baby’ and said good morning and good night was me!”

“I only asked her to meet you once, and she stole you from me... I admit I lied, but I’m the one who really likes you!”

Tears streamed down her face as she looked at Ryan.

He lowered his eyes, tapping the table with his fingers.

After a while, he suddenly laughed.

“How do you know the person you chatted with for a year was really me?”

Both Mallory and I froze.

I quickly covered my mouth to stifle a gasp.

Mallory forgot to cry, stammering,

“What do you mean?”

Ryan’s voice was cold and emotionless.

“My cousin was badly burned in a fire—seventy percent of his body was burned, especially his face. He could only use fake photos to date online.”

“However you begged Kelsey to meet, that’s how he begged me.”

My jaw nearly hit the floor.

What a twist—an online couple, both using fake photos!

I couldn’t help but sigh—never thought I’d meet someone as unlucky as me.

Mallory broke down.

“No way, you’re lying!”

Ryan smiled, indifferent.

“Someone like you? I wouldn’t want you in this life or the next.”

Mallory picked up on something, asking quietly,

“You like Kelsey?”

Ryan admitted openly,

“Yes. Actually, I should thank you for giving me the chance to meet her.”

“Too bad you won’t be around to get my thanks. Enjoy your time in prison.”

Mallory went silent, her face ashen, lips trembling. She probably wouldn’t even feel it if someone stabbed her now.

I was even more shocked than Mallory. In my panic, I accidentally bumped my head on the door with a thump.

Ryan turned sharply.

I panicked and ran.

As soon as I reached the police station entrance, someone grabbed my arm.

I turned and saw Ryan. For once, his usually calm, handsome face looked uneasy.

“You heard everything, didn’t you?”

I looked away, embarrassed.

“Uh... if you don’t want me to know, I can pretend I didn’t hear.”

There were a lot of people passing by, not the best place to talk.

Ryan took my hand and led me to his car.

Once it was quiet, he said slowly,

“I was going to tell you all this anyway.”

“The person Mallory dated online wasn’t me—my cousin used my photos.”

“I didn’t want to meet you, but he begged me. When I saw you at the restaurant, I was suddenly glad I agreed.”

“Kelsey, you’re not the only one who went along with a mistake.”

“Will you keep making this ‘mistake’ with me?”

His deep, narrow eyes were full of seriousness and hope, fixed on me.

I’d never been in this situation before—my hands and feet didn’t know where to go, and sweat poured down my forehead.

“You... you like me?”

“Yeah. Very much.”

“Why?”

“I don’t know. The moment I saw you at the restaurant, I was already thinking about what we’d name our kids.”

Wow.

He really was a little love-crazy.

A top-tier, rich, handsome guy fell for me at first sight!

I took back everything I said about him not liking me.

This was love!

After thinking it over, I said confidently,

“We both started out making mistakes, so that means—you were wrong, and I was wrong.”

“But in math, two negatives make a positive. So us being together is right!”

Ryan paused for a second, then smiled, the tension in his eyes melting away.

“Right, we’re right together.”

“Heh.”

Outside, snow started falling again.

Outside was grand and romantic; inside, warm and quiet.

Hand in hand, Ryan and I walked through the snow, each step leaving a clear footprint.

Snowflakes fell on our heads.

Before we knew it, we were growing old together.

End of main story.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

Catfished the Genius, Exposed by My Rival
Catfished the Genius, Exposed by My Rival
4.8
Ava faked her way into a year of secret tutoring from Ryan, MIT’s golden boy, using a stolen photo and a lie she almost believed herself. Now her jealous cousin has stolen the spotlight—and Ryan—while Ava’s ugly truth explodes across campus, turning her into a viral villain. As everyone she loves turns against her, Ava must face the boy she betrayed and the family that always wanted her to fail, with the whole world watching.
Catfished by My Academic Rival
Catfished by My Academic Rival
4.9
Luke fakes being gay to trick his campus nemesis, Shane, into writing his thesis—but when Shane discovers the deception, revenge turns into an electrifying, twisted power struggle. As guilt, attraction, and betrayal spiral out of control, Luke realizes he may have unleashed a dangerous obsession. In this game of secrets, someone’s heart—or future—could be destroyed.
He’s My Simp—But He’s Faking Amnesia
He’s My Simp—But He’s Faking Amnesia
4.9
Falling for my childhood enemy was never the plan—especially not after he got hit by a car, lost his memory, and let me move in to 'help him recover.' But Carter Evans, my rival-turned-roommate, isn’t just playing the amnesiac—he’s playing me, and suddenly, I’m tangled in a game of cat theft, fake relationships, and dangerously real feelings. With our meddling parents plotting a wedding and my bestie giving disastrous advice, one thing’s clear: if I don’t win over Carter (and his cat), I might just lose my heart. Will I finally outsmart my nemesis—or has he been waiting for me to fall all along?
My Cat Is Plotting My Death
My Cat Is Plotting My Death
4.6
After catching her cat planting a thumbtack under her pillow on home security footage, a lonely office worker realizes her cuddly companion might be a criminal mastermind. As paranoia spirals, every innocent purr and midnight cuddle starts to feel like a threat—and even her friends warn her that cats are never truly tamed. But when her cat fakes an injury to stay, the chilling truth emerges: this isn’t just a pet, it’s a predator with unfinished business.
He Called Me By My Real Name
He Called Me By My Real Name
4.9
I thought hitting Diamond would be the hardest part—until my ex called me out in front of the entire internet, and my gaming idol knew my real name. With the season on the line, I swallowed my pride and begged my ex for help, only to be left on read and publicly humiliated. My best friend hired a booster, but not even money could save us from Elo hell. Just when I’d given up, a single Twitch donation landed me in a game with Jax—the Comets’ legendary jungler and the guy I’d secretly crushed on for years. But Jax isn’t just cold; he’s heartbroken, and the whole world is watching. When he slips and calls me by my real name on stream, everything I thought I knew shatters. Am I just another fan—or is there a secret connection I never saw coming? What happens when your online life and real heart collide on the world stage?
She Stole My Face, I Took Her Life
She Stole My Face, I Took Her Life
4.8
Fame made me a star—betrayal made me a survivor. When my own twin sister stole my face and my life, I had to claw my way back from a brutal accident, a family who wished me gone, and the one man who saw the truth behind every mask. As secrets unravel on the world’s brightest stage, my revenge is as public as my pain—no one escapes the spotlight unscathed. But when the final curtain falls, will I find love, justice, or just a new kind of loneliness? Who am I when the world only knows my sister’s smile?
Dumped Online for Having 'Kids'
Dumped Online for Having 'Kids'
4.6
Melissa thought her biggest secret was being a divorced cat mom—until her online boyfriend ghosted her, convinced she was hiding real children. Humiliated and heartbroken, she faces the digital fallout alone—until her best friend sets her up with a real-life crush who’s obsessed with winning over her 'kids.' Will Melissa risk her heart again, or will her cats be her only happily ever after?
My Tutor’s Secret: The Harvard Lie
My Tutor’s Secret: The Harvard Lie
4.7
Alex lied to the online girlfriend who saved his grades, choosing MIT over Harvard—and cut her off with a single, gut-wrenching message. Now she’s back as his cold, beautiful lab mentor, holding his future in her hands. Can he survive her revenge, or will their unfinished past destroy them both?
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
4.7
I thought we were planning our future, but behind my back, my girlfriend was sneaking around with her high school crush. I uncovered their affair one photo, one deleted message at a time—while she played the perfect fiancée, he played the doting fiancé to someone else. Now I’m left with the truth: I was just her cover story, and their betrayal cuts deeper than any lie.
My Grandma’s Cat Is Internet Famous
My Grandma’s Cat Is Internet Famous
4.6
Abandoned by the city, I became Grandma’s reluctant sidekick—until a viral talent show turned me into the internet’s favorite ‘Boss Cat.’ But even as #WhiskersTheBoss trends worldwide, my biggest battles are at home: a stubborn old lady, a heartbroken grandson, and a country full of chickens who want revenge. When the boy suddenly hears me talk, everything changes—because in this family, even the cat has secrets.
Heirless: The Catfish Queen's Revenge
Heirless: The Catfish Queen's Revenge
4.9
Revenge isn't always loud—sometimes it simmers. When a six-fingered woman loses her adopted daughter to the ruthless Whitaker dynasty, she finds her child dead and discarded, fueling a vendetta that cuts deeper than any blade. Armed with nothing but grit and a food cart, she charms the town—and the powerful Harrison Whitaker—into letting her inside their fortress of secrets. But beneath every flirtation and every perfectly sliced fish lies a hidden agenda: to make the Whitakers pay for every stolen life and broken promise. As the mansion fractures under her rising influence, and forbidden alliances threaten to explode, one question remains: when the past is weaponized, can any of them survive the reckoning to come?
He Stole My Show, I Stole His Heart
He Stole My Show, I Stole His Heart
4.9
Falling for a stranger on reality TV was never part of my plan—especially not when my rival would do anything to erase me. When my spot on a hit show is stolen, I’m ready to walk away from the spotlight forever. But fate has other ideas: a viral dating show, a mysterious boy-next-door with secrets of his own, and a world eager to watch me rise—or crash. As my fake romance turns dangerously real and a jealous rival sets out to destroy me, I’m forced to choose: fight for my own story, or let someone else write my ending. When the cameras stop rolling, can love survive the truth? Or will my biggest enemy finally win?