She Lied on Our Anniversary Night / Chapter 2: The Locket and the Lie
She Lied on Our Anniversary Night

She Lied on Our Anniversary Night

Author: Kathleen David


Chapter 2: The Locket and the Lie

We went back to my tiny five-hundred-square-foot apartment. The place smelled like old takeout and laundry detergent. The walls were thin enough to hear the neighbors arguing two doors down. I’d always thought of it as cozy—now it just felt small. I dropped my bag on the floor and just stood there, numb.

Savannah was there, bundled up in a tight-fitting shirt to hide the marks on her body, her face still flushed. She was fussing with her hair in the mirror, humming softly. When she saw me come in, she immediately smiled and hugged me gently. It made my skin crawl.

"Honey, why didn’t you come home last night? I was waiting to celebrate our seventh anniversary."

Her arms wrapped around my waist, her voice sweet as honey. For a second, I almost believed her. Almost.

She pointed at the cake on the table. It was store-bought, the kind with too much frosting. The candles were already half-melted, leaning drunkenly to one side. The whole thing looked sad.

Truth is, we always called each other husband and wife, even though we weren’t married yet. It was a private joke, something we whispered to each other when no one else was around. Now it just sounded hollow.

I looked down at her kiss-swollen lips and suddenly spoke: "Where’s the locket? Give it back to me."

My voice was cold, flat. Just thinking about my mom’s only keepsake hanging around her neck made me sick.

Savannah froze for a moment, eyes darting away as she waved it off: "Of course I’m keeping your mom’s keepsake safe. I just didn’t bring it now."

She laughed nervously, twisting a strand of hair around her finger. I could see the lie in her eyes.

If I hadn’t caught her cheating outside the gates last night,

I probably would’ve hugged her, moved as always, then gone to the kitchen to make her a full homemade dinner,

blow on her soup so she wouldn’t burn her tongue,

pick out the fish bones for her.

The old routines flashed through my mind, each one a little knife. I used to love doing those things for her. Now I just felt empty.

But this time, I just looked at her coldly, waiting for her to confess on her own.

She avoided my gaze, fidgeting with the edge of her shirt. The silence stretched between us, heavy and uncomfortable.

"Remember Leonard Brooks? He asked me to show him a house last night, but then stood me up. I waited for him in the community all night."

A flicker of guilt flashed in Savannah’s eyes.

She cut a piece of cake and, on tiptoe, offered it to my mouth. Her smile was forced, too wide. The cake smelled sickly sweet. I didn’t move.

"Oh, maybe he was just busy, don’t take it to heart."

"Besides, that’s how it is in sales. You have to take some lumps to make money."

She was talking fast, words tumbling over each other. I could tell she was trying to distract me, to steer the conversation away from the truth.

"It’s all for our future home, honey, just bear with it. Maybe he didn’t mean it."

She took my phone and gently stroked my face, pretending to be concerned. Her touch felt wrong, like a stranger’s. I pulled away, my skin crawling.

"By the way, honey, did you see anything last night?"

Her eyes searched mine, desperate for reassurance. I shook my head, and the last bit of light in my eyes went out.

"Should I call him and reschedule?"

She was relentless, pressing her advantage. I clenched my fist, face darkening, and snatched my phone back.

Calling her lover right in front of me. What, is this some kind of game for them? Am I just part of their little play?

I’d loved Savannah so much, felt bad for her working hard, told her to rest at home.

Every day I’d go out selling houses, putting up with people’s attitudes, then come home to cook for her, rub her feet, massage her neck after a day of playing on her phone.

I’d given up all my family’s wealth just to be with her. Even in bed, I was afraid of hurting her, never daring to be rough.

And now, with her kiss-bruised lips, she still treats me like this?

I almost couldn’t hold it in. I was about to confront her and just blow everything up.

But then Savannah pointed at my phone, beaming:

"Honey, Mr. Brooks is coming over to discuss buying a house from you. I heard he’s super rich—even just a little bit from him would be enough for us to live well!"

Hearing that, my heart ached all over again. All these years of effort, and for what? It all went to the dogs. Not worth it.

She happily went to change into new clothes, grinning as she opened the door:

"Mr. Brooks is here! Come on in!"

Her voice was high and bright, like she was welcoming a celebrity into our home. I stood there, numb.

"Honey, go pour Mr. Brooks some water!"

She barked the order like I was the help. My hands shook as I stared at her, disbelief warring with anger.

I stood there, unmoving.

She secretly pinched my arm. Her nails dug into my skin, sharp and insistent. I didn’t flinch. Let her see how little I cared now.

"Go on, why are you just standing there like an idiot?"

I couldn’t help but laugh in anger. The sound was bitter, ugly. I felt something inside me snap.

Suddenly, I didn’t want Savannah to know the truth just yet.

Let her play her little games. Let her think she’s won.

The cups were on the tiny coffee table.

Leonard Brooks was a pot-bellied man in his forties. His critical gaze swept around my tiny apartment. He looked at the peeling paint, the mismatched furniture, the old TV set in the corner. I could see the disdain on his face, like he was slumming it for sport.

"Tyler, is this a slum? It’s way too small."

His voice was loud, echoing off the walls. He didn’t bother to hide his contempt.

Before I could reply, Savannah jumped in eagerly:

"Yeah, it’s tiny. Mr. Brooks, you’ve seen real mansions, of course you’d look down on the place my boyfriend rents."

She was all smiles, fawning over him like a butterfly, while I sat there stiff-faced, watching her flatter Leonard Brooks with every word.

Without realizing it, Savannah had already moved to sit right beside him, just a step away.

She scooted closer, her perfume filling the air. I felt sick, watching her cling to him like I was invisible.

"Tyler," Leonard Brooks said with a mocking smile, "I want to buy a house for my girl. Why don’t you show me something?"

As he spoke, he glanced at Savannah beside him, making her eyes light up with excitement. She couldn’t hide her glee as she looked at me.

So, he came here just to show off? Cheating behind my back wasn’t exciting enough—they had to rub it in my face?

I laughed to myself. The sound was sharp, hollow. I wondered if they even noticed.

"Sure, the mansion you asked me to show you last night—the crown jewel of the neighborhood. Perfect for your girl."

The mansion where they hooked up last night. My family’s mansion.

After I said that, I shot Savannah a cold look. She was too excited to notice, her face flushed, and she even shot me a look of approval, nearly grabbing Leonard Brooks’ arm to beg for it.

Seeing her like that, my heart just went numb, and a cold sneer followed.

That mansion’s worth ten million. If I remember right, Leonard Brooks’ total assets are only two million.

I did the math in my head, biting back a laugh. Let’s see him try to swing that.

After I spoke, Leonard Brooks looked smug, his gaze full of contempt.

"Alright, I’ll take it. For my girl."

He puffed out his chest, like he was making some grand gesture. I almost felt sorry for him.

I looked at him and said, "Then remember to bring proof of funds tomorrow."

Let’s see if he can actually pay.

Leonard Brooks didn’t care, puffing out his greasy belly and lighting a cigarette with his yellowed fingers, filling the tiny apartment with smoke.

He leaned back, blowing smoke rings toward the ceiling. The smell was acrid, clinging to the curtains and my clothes.

"I want my baby to live well, not in a dump like this. Her boyfriend can’t even buy her a bottle of perfume—what a loser."

Can’t even buy a bottle of perfume?

I glanced at Savannah’s vanity, covered with bottles of perfume in every color.

I thought, Each of those perfumes costs over two hundred bucks, and you’ve got a whole table full.

Savannah, after all these years, have I ever treated you badly? Why betray me? Was it really just for money?

I remembered the late-night trips to the mall, the way she’d drag me from store to store, her eyes lighting up at every new scent. I never said no. Not once.

Savannah’s eyes darted, surprised I’d bring this up. I’d never cared about her makeup or jewelry before, always handing over my entire paycheck for her to spend as she pleased. Now I just felt bitter.

"Really? Then what were you doing last night?"

A flicker of guilt crossed Savannah’s face, but she quickly put on a smile and snuggled into my arms. Her touch felt colder than before. I stared down at her, unmoved.

"A friend dragged me out. Why so serious?"

She tried to sound playful, but her voice shook. I could see the cracks in her facade.

I shook my head, looking at her, and suddenly felt that these seven years had just rotted away. The memories felt rotten, spoiled from the inside out. I wondered if any of it had ever been real.

"I’m tired. Didn’t sleep all night. I’m going to bed."

"Don’t forget to find my mom’s locket."

"Okay, get some rest. When you wake up, let’s go to the mall. Didn’t you say you wanted to play the arcade games there?"

Yeah, but that was a year ago. No wonder people say when your partner cheats, they try to make it up to you out of guilt. She was way too obvious.

You may also like

He Loved Her, Not Me
He Loved Her, Not Me
4.9
He loved her—just not me. On the night of our fourth anniversary, I watched Carter Langley slip further away, his heart claimed by another while our marriage became nothing but a headline. I was supposed to smile, play the perfect wife, and pretend not to notice the pitying looks or the silence that suffocated our home. But pain demands a witness. When betrayal cuts deeper than bone, how far will a woman go to make her absence felt? Carter’s indifference is legendary—until my final act leaves him with a haunting question and a secret he can never bury. If love is dead, what’s left for the living to regret?
Dumped and Humiliated on Her Birthday
Dumped and Humiliated on Her Birthday
4.6
Mike spent weeks crafting the perfect surprise, only to be ambushed and shamed by his girlfriend and her ruthless friends in front of a packed restaurant. The heartfelt gift he poured his soul into is mocked, his love called cheap, and his dignity shattered—while the real luxury surprise waits just outside. When the wine flies and the insults burn, Mike faces a devastating truth: sometimes, the biggest betrayal comes from the one you love most.
His Secret Girlfriend for Seven Years
His Secret Girlfriend for Seven Years
4.8
For seven years, I loved America’s hottest pop star in silence—always his secret, always called by another woman’s name. On my birthday, he humiliated me in front of Hollywood’s elite, making it clear I was just a stand-in for his first love. But now, with my hearing restored and my heart shattered, I’m ready to expose every lie and take back the life—and the music—he stole from me.
I Was Her Stand-In Husband
I Was Her Stand-In Husband
4.8
She came home on our anniversary with another man’s mark—and I didn’t even ask why. For three years, I played the perfect husband, a stand-in for the man she truly loved. Now, with only seven days left until my assignment ends and I can finally leave this world, every lie, every bitter silence, and every leftover gift is one step closer to my freedom. But when Rachel tries to pull me back with guilt and old routines, I realize I’m done being her lapdog. If she wants Lucas, why not go to him? The clock is ticking, the portal is opening, and our marriage is about to shatter. But will walking away finally set me free—or will the truth I’ve hidden destroy us both?
Caught Cheating on Livestream: Her Birthday Betrayal
Caught Cheating on Livestream: Her Birthday Betrayal
4.8
He planned the perfect birthday proposal—roses, champagne, and a livestream for family and friends. But hidden in his own SUV, he watched his girlfriend cheat with her married boss, their affair broadcast to everyone he loved. Humiliated and heartbroken, he realizes her betrayal is only the beginning, as the whole world tunes in to his worst nightmare.
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
She Cheated With the Class Heartthrob
4.7
I thought we were planning our future, but behind my back, my girlfriend was sneaking around with her high school crush. I uncovered their affair one photo, one deleted message at a time—while she played the perfect fiancée, he played the doting fiancé to someone else. Now I’m left with the truth: I was just her cover story, and their betrayal cuts deeper than any lie.
Lipstick on His Collar, Lies in My Heart
Lipstick on His Collar, Lies in My Heart
4.9
I thought I’d married the perfect man—until I found the lipstick stain on his collar and the apartment across town he kept for her. In Maple Heights, everyone praised our union, but behind the white-picket fences, my heart was breaking. Nathaniel’s betrayals forced me to choose: play the dignified wife, or lose myself entirely. As the women around me whispered that this was just 'the way of men,' I clung to my pride, even as my marriage unraveled. But when a mysterious stranger’s smile lights up my lonely world, I begin to wonder—can I break free, or am I doomed to live a lie? When love is a game of appearances, who dares to want more?
He Cheated, I Gave Away the Ring
He Cheated, I Gave Away the Ring
4.7
On my birthday, my fiancé’s mistress crashed the party—pregnant and desperate, while the whole town waited for me to break. Instead, I slipped the engagement bracelet onto her wrist and walked out, leaving Maple Heights and my old life behind. But when Ethan tries to win me back with public humiliation and a new 'apology' bracelet, I’m forced to choose: reclaim my dignity, or let him—and my family—destroy what’s left of my heart.
He Left Me at My Own Party
He Left Me at My Own Party
4.9
He shattered our marriage at my own birthday party—now I’m rewriting the ending. When Savannah Carter’s perfect life implodes in front of a hundred witnesses, she’s left reeling from her husband’s betrayal and the public humiliation that follows. As her world crumbles—friends gossiping, colleagues advising her to ‘play the game,’ and her family pushing her to forgive—Savannah refuses to be the woman who quietly fades away. With nothing left to lose, she teams up with the one ally she never expected: her husband’s former best friend. But when the mistress delivers damning evidence straight to Savannah’s phone, she’s faced with a choice—walk away with dignity, or fight for everything she built. If love can turn this cruel, what’s left to believe in? And who will Savannah become when the world expects her to break?
He Betrayed Me for My Sister's Honor
He Betrayed Me for My Sister's Honor
4.8
On the night of our engagement, my perfect fiancé was found in bed with my younger sister, destroying both our reputations in front of the entire town. He claimed to have taken advantage of her, choosing her honor over the love he promised me—leaving me to face the shame, heartbreak, and whispers alone. But the real truth is darker, and in Savannah, betrayal is a family tradition.
She Lied, I Nearly Lost Everything
She Lied, I Nearly Lost Everything
4.8
Some rides change your whole life. One stormy night, a rideshare driver is caught between a desperate passenger and a toxic ex-client—Sydney Ramirez, a woman who turns a lost phone into a public nightmare. When Sydney’s insults escalate and the driver’s own family crisis explodes, everything unravels at the police station, where truth becomes a weapon and the crowd turns savage. With reputations, jobs, and even lives at stake, can justice survive the noise, or will one lie destroy it all? When the world is watching, whose story will be believed?
He Bought Me, But Married Her
He Bought Me, But Married Her
4.7
Rachel thought her boyfriend’s love was real—until she overheard him boasting about buying her loyalty with a condo, all while planning a $400,000 wedding to another woman. Forced to plan her own ex’s lavish marriage, Rachel must hide her heartbreak and secrets, even as he tries to keep her on a string. When the final vows are spoken, will she finally break free—or will betrayal claim her future too?