Villainess by Birth, Heroine by Rewrite / Chapter 5: Truths, Ties, and Twists
Villainess by Birth, Heroine by Rewrite

Villainess by Birth, Heroine by Rewrite

Author: Anna Miller


Chapter 5: Truths, Ties, and Twists

When I woke up again, I was in my own room, opening my eyes to see Savannah with red eyes. The sunlight streamed through the curtains, painting stripes across her worried face. —Morning after.

She immediately started crying, calling me affectionately, “Lex, do you feel okay?” Her voice cracked, and she wiped her nose on her sleeve. —Messy but sweet.

Remembering what happened before I fainted and what I heard in the limo, I suddenly felt indifferent to everything, wishing I could just check out. "I’m fine, I’m just thinking—is it too late for me to join a convent now?" —Drama queen.

May God bless me. I made the sign of the cross, just in case. —Can’t hurt.

Savannah let go of me with pity. “It’s too late. Your folks are outside talking marriage with Senator Jennings and his wife.” Her grip was surprisingly strong. —No escape.

“Where are you going?”

I was almost in tears, as if I could see my whole family being ruined. "Ethan is Natalie’s... How can I marry him..." —Life is so unfair.

Savannah knocked my head hard. “Who told you he belongs to Natalie? Lex, what’s wrong with you?” She looked at me like I’d grown a second head. —Tough love.

Seeing I didn’t answer, she frowned but didn’t press further. “Forget it, your mom told me to make sure you drink your medicine.”

She handed me a mug of black, bitter-smelling cough syrup. The smell alone made my stomach turn. —Ugh.

After looking at it for a few seconds, I gagged. “...ugh.”

Savannah was merciless, calmly saying, “You’ve seen this since you were little, Lex. Drink up.”

To be precise, I was force-fed a mug of medicine and lay on the bed in despair. The taste lingered, bitter as regret. —Never again.

Savannah cheerfully wiped my mouth. Then she narrowed her fox-like eyes and said, “I was thinking, if your folks found a matchmaker but no one came, I’d find a way to have the President’s son support you.” Her gaze sparkled with mischief. —Always scheming.

“I didn’t expect Ethan to still like you, which saves a lot of trouble...”

I didn’t hear the rest, because the medicine was too strong and I was very sleepy. My eyelids drooped, and the world faded to black. —Game over.

But nothing wakes you up faster than finding yourself tied up with Ethan holding a pocketknife by the bed. The light glinted off the blade, and my heart leaped into my throat. —Not the wake-up call I wanted.

I instinctively shrank back and tried to reason with him. “Let’s talk this out.” My voice was squeaky, but I tried to sound brave. —Total fail.

Ethan played with the knife in his hand and casually asked, “I heard you think I belong to Natalie?”

Savannah, you traitor! —Thanks a lot.

I replied seriously, “I’m not, I didn’t, you misunderstood.” I shook my head so hard my hair whipped my face. —Desperate times.

Ethan smiled. “So you’re unhappy with our engagement? Now you want to run out and have your parents break it off?”

I quickly shook my head. “Having you is my great fortune.” I tried to sound sincere, but my voice wobbled. —Nailed it. Not.

Ethan looked at me deeply, cut the rope with the knife, then looked at me and said, “Had enough fun?”

Free at last, I realized this was my home. The familiar wallpaper, the scent of lavender—safe at last. —Relief.

So, emboldened, I snapped at him, “You don’t even know what it’s like to work a nine-to-five!” —Truth bomb.

Ethan was stunned, then smiled gently. He was really good-looking, and that smile made me dazed. —Dangerous territory.

“Did you learn that phrase from Natalie too?”

Now it was my turn to be stunned. “How do you know?”

Ethan stopped smiling, a little helpless. “Lex, it’s been so long, you should have figured it out by now, right?”

I knew there was more to his words, but for some reason I just wanted to avoid it. So I deliberately widened my eyes and moved closer to him. “I’m awake?”

Ethan pulled away, frowning, but I still noticed his ears were a little red. He was cute when he was flustered. —Adorable.

After a while, he sighed, got up, and rummaged through my wardrobe for a small box. I watched him, suspicious. —What now?

I was horrified. “You actually hid something in my room! No, you actually dared to sneak into my room!”

Ethan sneered. “You said it yourself. Savannah, your parents—they all know.”

There’s such a thing? I blinked, trying to process it. —Mind blown.

Before I could react, Ethan handed me a small journal from the box. “See for yourself.”

I took it in confusion, but before I could open it, a maid rushed in. She was out of breath. “Something’s wrong, Miss! Miss Monroe and Natalie are fighting at school!” —Not again.

How could I stand by when my best friend was being bullied? I kicked off my slippers and bolted for the door. —On a mission.

So, ignoring the journal, I rushed out. My heart pounded in my ears as I sprinted down the hall. —Adrenaline rush.

The scene before me was quite a sight: Natalie was soaked and crying, while Savannah, with black stains on her clothes and face, was being wiped down by a maid when I arrived. The chaos was pure high school melodrama. —Peak drama.

I instinctively started giving orders. “Ethan, go check on Natalie, I’ll check on Savannah.”

Ethan said nothing, only squeezed out a “Hm?” —Classic Ethan.

I quickly smiled. “I’ll go check.” I darted over to Savannah, who was shivering and glaring at Natalie. —Ready for round two.

Before I could ask what happened, the President, my parents, and others arrived, escalating the situation. The tension was back, thicker than ever. —Déjà vu.

Savannah took the initiative. “Mr. President, I was just passing by and didn’t know what Natalie was doing. Suddenly there was a loud bang, and my face and clothes ended up like this.”

She started crying as she spoke. Tears streaked her cheeks, but her voice was steady. —Resilient.

“But not only did Natalie not apologize, she argued with me. It was my fault for accidentally dragging her into the pool. Please punish me.”

Savannah finished both the good and bad parts, but Natalie also performed well. She dabbed at her eyes, voice trembling.

“Dad, I didn’t mean it. I just recently wanted to try making something new.”

“But I didn’t expect it to be so powerful, and didn’t expect to bump into Miss Monroe. It was my oversight. Please punish me.”

The pressure was on the President. He checked what Natalie made. The air was tense as he turned the object over in his hands. —Judgment day.

After hearing the report, the President’s eyes were full of praise. “Natalie has always been bright, always coming up with new ideas, which is great. That loud bang just now was so powerful; if used in battle, it would be even more effective. Do you remember the process of making this?”

Natalie’s eyes lit up but hesitated. “I just made it casually; I’m not sure about the materials and steps. If you need, Dad, I can try to recall.”

The President nodded, then looked at Savannah and gave his decision. “You offended the senator’s daughter and even pushed her into the water, but since you suffered too, you’ll be grounded for a month. Natalie, come back to the mansion with me.”

“Yes, Dad.”

I wanted to speak up for Savannah, but Ethan pulled me back. His grip was gentle, but firm. —No arguing.

Savannah kept her head down, seeing off the President and the others. Her lips trembled, but she didn’t cry. —Tough cookie.

I felt bad and hurried over. “Savannah, are you alright? Don’t take it to heart...”

Savannah looked up, confused. “Take what to heart? Lex, help me up, my legs are numb.”

Speechless, I pulled her up, and Savannah laughed happily. Her laughter was infectious, and I found myself grinning despite everything. —Mood lifter.

“Ethan, you’re something. You actually made her bring it out.” Savannah shook her head in disbelief. —Plot twist.

Ethan just frowned, looking at the pile of things, saying nothing. He was lost in thought, no doubt planning his next move. —Schemer.

“Lex, why are you frowning? Isn’t this the day we’ve been waiting for?” Savannah nudged me, her eyes bright. —Am I missing something?

Waiting for this day? —Seriously?

I was puzzled. —Totally lost.

Ethan sighed. “She still hasn’t figured it out.” —Story of my life.

I was still muddled when I got home. My head ached with unanswered questions. —So many mysteries.

My parents were happily preparing my wedding trousseau. My mom was picking out fabrics, my dad was consulting the guest list. —Wedding bells.

My wedding with Ethan was set for next month. The invitations were already being printed. —No turning back.

I protested, “Dad, Mom, I can’t marry Ethan.”

“Why?”

Faced with their simultaneous question, I answered without thinking. “Ethan should be with Natalie.”

My mom frowned. “What are you talking about? You and Ethan have been engaged since you were kids. What’s it got to do with Natalie?” —Plot holes everywhere.

Engaged? —Wait, what?

My dad sighed. “Alexis—Lexie still hasn’t figured it out.” —Here we go again.

That phrase again. —Déjà vu.

My head ached, and I remembered Ethan’s behavior. Right, the journal. The answer must be in there. —Time to investigate.

I ran to my room, grabbed the journal, and read it, panting. My hands shook as I flipped through the pages. —Truth bomb incoming.

This chapter is VIP-only. Activate membership to continue.

You may also like

Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
Villainess Rewrite: Marry the Enemy
5.0
I always thought I was the heroine—until I watched the real one fall into the lake, and my memories snapped into place. Turns out, I’m Autumn Whitlock: the villainess doomed to destroy her own family, locked away by the man she loves, and forgotten by everyone. But this time, I’m rewriting my ending. When a staged tragedy nearly frames me, I risk everything to save my rival—only to be rescued myself by Sebastian Carter, the cold and powerful heir with secrets of his own. Now, as old alliances shift and the threat to my family grows, I must outwit the story’s script, bargain with the enemy, and confront a marriage proposal that could save—or ruin—us all. Can a villainess steal back her fate, or am I destined to lose everything I love, one calculated move at a time?
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
I Became the Villainess—And Broke the Script
4.9
Waking up as the notorious villainess in a brutal historical romance novel was never part of my five-year plan. My job? Torment the wild heroine Nora and win over the cold-hearted male lead, Carter. With a mind-reading perk and my office-honed instincts, I thought I could outplay everyone—but Nora’s stubborn warmth and Carter’s hidden cruelty flip the script. As secrets unravel at glittering galas and county fairs, I realize the stakes are more than reputation or romance: it’s about rewriting fate itself. When my sabotage puts everyone in danger, loyalty and love collide in a final, fiery showdown. Can a mean girl rewrite her story—or is she doomed to play the villain forever?
Villainess Rewrite: Stolen Fate in Ohio
Villainess Rewrite: Stolen Fate in Ohio
4.8
I woke up as Nicole Reed—the small-town villain who shattered Jason’s dreams and doomed her own family. With the whole town watching, I must rewrite my story: save Jason from ruin, outsmart the perfect heroine, and steal the happy ending that was never meant for me. But every step closer to redemption risks exposing my darkest secret—and losing everything, all over again.
I Refuse to Be the Villainess
I Refuse to Be the Villainess
4.9
Fate always cast me as the villain, but what if I could rewrite the ending? The night my mother vanished, she warned me: when the beloved heroine enters our home, my world will collapse—and I’ll be the one blamed for every heartbreak and scandal that follows. Now, with Savannah dazzling my father and brother, I’m forced from my room, my reputation ruined, and my heart shattered by those I once trusted. But when a historic opportunity for women emerges in our town, I see a glimmer of freedom beyond the story’s script. If I refuse to play the villain, can I escape the fate written for me—or will jealousy and betrayal destroy my last chance at happiness?
Reborn to Serve My Villain Daughter
Reborn to Serve My Villain Daughter
4.7
I died as a mother, and was reborn as a maid—only to find the cold, feared mistress of the governor’s mansion is my lost daughter from a past life. Everyone whispers that Mrs. Reynolds is a monster who destroys anyone who crosses her, but I refuse to believe the sweet child I once loved could become so cruel. To protect her and uncover the secrets that broke her soul, I’ll risk everything—even if she never knows who I truly am.
I Became the Villainess—He Became Obsessed
I Became the Villainess—He Became Obsessed
4.9
Death wasn’t my ending—it was my messed-up beginning. One moment, I’m a slacker picking a side role in a romance novel’s system; the next, I’m the villainess who’s supposed to die at the hands of a broken, beautiful male lead. To survive, I bluff my way into hiring him as my art model—only to find myself swept into moonlit road trips, secret wishes, and a slow-burn obsession neither of us can escape. Every sketch I draw peels back a layer of his pain, but when his wish is revealed, I realize the line between love and possession is razor thin. The system says his darkness is off the charts. I thought I could change the story—but now I’m trapped in his. Will I become the heroine he can’t let go, or just the next victim of his twisted devotion?
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
I Woke Up as the Villain’s Wife
5.0
Waking up as the tragic villain’s muse in a gothic romance, I thought I could dodge heartbreak and survive as a footnote. But when a cruel system ties my fate to Marcus Hawthorne—the brooding, misunderstood heir—I’m forced to play a deadly game where every wound he takes, I suffer. To survive, I must rewrite my doomed story, outsmart the hero and heroine, and win the villain’s trust without losing my heart. With assassins, poison, and forbidden secrets lurking in every shadow, every move could be my last. But as the line between enemy and lover blurs, I face an impossible choice: betray the man who could save me, or risk everything for a love that was never meant to exist. If you could rewrite your ending, would you dare to trust the villain?
My Daughter Is the Reborn Heroine
My Daughter Is the Reborn Heroine
4.7
When my rebellious daughter suddenly became obedient, begging for private school tuition, I thought she’d finally changed. But pop-up comments only I can see reveal she’s the heroine of a second-chance romance, scheming to run away with her bad boy boyfriend—and in her last life, I was the villain who ruined her happiness. Now, as she plots behind my back and strangers invade my home, I must decide: fight for her future, or let her go and risk losing everything—including my own life.
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
I’m the Villainess—Now I Write the Rules
4.9
Being the villainess was never part of my plan—especially not in a small Southern town where everyone knows your secrets. When I wake up as Savannah Whitaker, the spoiled princess doomed to a tragic end, I decide to rewrite my fate: play matchmaker for the main couple, keep my head down, and maybe, just maybe, survive this story. But the plot has other ideas. The cold, dangerously handsome Mr. Carter isn't just my teacher—he’s the man I’m supposed to avoid, and he’s suddenly paying way too much attention. The gentle heroine, Elena, is as cunning as she is sweet, and every move I make only entangles me deeper in their world. Can I outsmart fate and claim my own happy ending, or will my attempts to change the story write my downfall? When the script flips, who gets to decide the ending?
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
I Was the Villain—Then He Chose Me
5.0
Some stories are written for someone else, but what if you refused to follow the script? Autumn Sinclair has spent seven years as the villainous supporting girl in a world ruled by fate, heartbreak, and a heroine with supernatural luck. She’s loved the hero in silence, fought schemes she was never meant to win, and watched her every move become fuel for someone else’s glory. But when betrayal, murder, and the unraveling of every role collide at the center of Maple Heights, Autumn is forced to choose: stay trapped as a pawn, or break free and claim her own ending. With enemies lurking in plain sight and love hanging by a thread, can Autumn rewrite her story—or will she lose everything, including herself? When the script shatters, whose story survives?
I Refused to Be the Villainess
I Refused to Be the Villainess
4.9
Waking up as the villainess in a soap opera life should have been Autumn Caldwell’s worst nightmare—especially with Nathan Pierce, the dangerously hot revenge-obsessed hero, gunning for her heart and her fortune. But Autumn’s got a plan: rewrite the script, dodge the heartbreak, and never, ever fall for the boy who’s supposed to destroy her. As family secrets unravel, rivalries spark, and one wrong move could cost her everything, Autumn discovers that destiny isn’t set in stone—and sometimes, your greatest enemy is your only shot at love. Will she escape her villainess fate, or has Nathan already stolen the ending? When your second chance means rewriting every rule, how far would you go to win your own happy ever after?
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Sister
Reborn as the Villain’s Scapegoat Sister
4.6
After dying young, I woke up inside a novel as the infamous sister doomed to bully my autistic brother—and die hated by all. The whole family expects me to fight for love and attention, but I just want to survive without becoming the villain again. But when my brother reaches out with silent kindness, and the world keeps twisting my every move, can I rewrite my ending—or am I trapped in someone else’s tragedy?